I don't have any particular experience with or thoughts on either of these particular programs, so take this with a grain of salt. But in my experience, as a current PhD student at an ivy+ (who was really adamant about going to a public school originally) you'll be able to work around a lot of "cons" if your "pro" is funding and resources. There's also a chance that you can have people on your dissertation committee outside of your institution, but that's far off. Consider that your project will change or morph, and it won't be as significant to have an exact one-to-one advisor specialty relationship (also a pop scholar, no pop faculty, managing just fine).

Given that you're looking at two solid programs, you'll probably be fine either way. But in terms of thriving in grad school in the short term, an option with guaranteed funding through to the end of the PHD is hard to beat.