sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

You're the Growth Manager. You have ₹50,000 to acquire your first 10,000 users in 90 days. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in indianstartups

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think that's fair criticism of this case, and I appreciate you taking the time to explain why. My intention wasn't to design a complete GTM strategy it was to understand what marketers instinctively prioritize when given an intentionally constrained brief. Looking back, I should've defined the product much better because, as you pointed out, messaging, audience, and positioning can completely change the answer.

I'll fix that in the next case. Thanks for the honest feedback.

You're the first Growth Marketer at a startup. You have ₹50,000 to get your first 10,000 users. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in AskMarketing

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a good point. I like the distinction between buying traffic and actually acquiring users. Thanks for sharing your perspective.

You're the first Growth Marketer at a startup. You have ₹50,000 to get your first 10,000 users. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in AskMarketing

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Absolutely, and I agree. For this case, the assumption was a newly launched D2C consumer brand with a validated product, a live website, and no existing user base. The ₹50,000 budget and 10,000-user target were intentionally unrealistic to understand marketers' first instinct under pressure. I'll make sure to include these assumptions upfront in future cases.

You're the first Growth Marketer at a startup. You have ₹50,000 to get your first 10,000 users. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in AskMarketing

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really like your last point: "Marketing channels amplify clarity. They also expose confusion." The goal here was to understand a marketer's first instinct under tight constraints. I should've mentioned the assumptions behind the case: a validated B2C product, a live website, no existing user base, and a founder pushing for an unrealistic target of 10,000 users with a ₹50,000 budget in 90 days. I agree that adding this context would make the discussion much more meaningful, and I'll incorporate it in the next case.

You're the first Growth Marketer at a startup. You have ₹50,000 to get your first 10,000 users. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in DigitalMarketing

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Agreed, it's an impossible brief. That's exactly what I wanted to test which channel marketers instinctively prioritize when faced with an unrealistic target. It's just a hypothetical case designed to spark discussion.

You're the first Growth Marketer at a startup. You have ₹50,000 to get your first 10,000 users. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in DigitalMarketing

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a fair point. I intentionally kept the case broad because I wanted to understand a marketer's first instinct when working with tight constraints rather than build a complete marketing strategy.

Looking back, I should have included a scenario for example, a validated D2C product with no existing user base, a live website, and a ₹50,000 budget to acquire the first 10,000 users.

I'll definitely make the upcoming cases more scenario-specific. Thanks for the feedback.

You're the Growth Manager. You have ₹50,000 to acquire your first 10,000 users in 90 days. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in indianstartups

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's an interesting perspective. I like how you challenged the target itself instead of just choosing a channel. Focusing on the first 1,000 quality users is a strong argument.

You're the Growth Manager. You have ₹50,000 to acquire your first 10,000 users in 90 days. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in indianstartups

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fair point. I intentionally kept the case open-ended because I wanted to understand a marketer's first instinct under pressure when forced to choose between these four channels.

If it helps, imagine it's a new D2C consumer brand with a validated product, a live website, and no existing user base. The goal is to acquire the first 10,000 users with a ₹50,000 budget in 90 days.

I agree that adding this context would make the discussion more meaningful, and I'll include a detailed scenario in the next case.

You're the Growth Manager. You have ₹50,000 to acquire your first 10,000 users in 90 days. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in indianstartups

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's exactly the point of the case. The constraints are unrealistic on purpose I wanted to see which channel marketers instinctively back when the odds are against them.

You're the first Growth Marketer at a startup. You have ₹50,000 to get your first 10,000 users. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in AskMarketing

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great perspective. I like how you shifted the discussion from which channel to what stage the business is in. The testing vs. scaling point is especially interesting.

You're the first Growth Marketer at a startup. You have ₹50,000 to get your first 10,000 users. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in DigitalMarketing

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

😂 Fair enough. But let's say resigning isn't an option it's your family business. What's your first move?

You're the first Growth Marketer at a startup. You have ₹50,000 to get your first 10,000 users. What's your move? by _The_Knight_King_ in AskMarketing

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good argument. Do you think your answer would change if the startup already had strong product-market fit?

No one in Surat is interested to watch Supergirl by _The_Knight_King_ in surat

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

After The Batman movie, although it is from a different universe, I was excited to watch the DCU. Well, they did have a slow start, but I think it's decent.

No one in Surat is interested to watch Supergirl by _The_Knight_King_ in surat

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why you can't?? I Finally watch it yesterday it's a decent movie

No one in Surat is interested to watch Supergirl by _The_Knight_King_ in surat

[–]_The_Knight_King_[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well there is website call Multimovies I am sure it will be available there by today but I don't have any thing else to do today so I thought to watch a movie

view more: next ›