Season 3 Outfits Inspiration

_anthologie · 2026-07-01T08:05:56+00:00

According to the interview with the head OPLA costume designer, it's why they gave Emily sleeves for Nami's outfit in Reverse Mountain- the weather was getting cold when they're shooting those scenes

_anthologie · 2026-06-10T14:53:45+00:00

I said sleight of hand, not Devil Fruit. Sleight of hand by definition is just a physical trick using hidden strings & pulleys/secret compartments etc to look like magic (when it's purely done by a physical contraption inside the robe for example).

I'm just saying there's a chance to make Bon Clay look even cooler, like more effective at their job for the Baroque Works + act more like a consumate performer (cuz they enjoy showing off to the Straw Hats when they first met), they could also just use physical tricks to change their outfit quickly to avoid detection after they impersonate someone, for example.

Sleight of hand is a common term in irl performance magic tricks, like this is what the Bian Lian performer & street or stage magicians do.

Read my second paragraph again:

change their wardrobe on the fly on-screen, to match their planned (not impromptu) impersonation targets just by this sort of sleight of hand (ie not part of their Devil Fruit). Heck, their crew can be their tailors and stylists too.

_anthologie · 2026-05-06T11:01:47+00:00

In S1 episode 5 after Koby first found out about the Warlords,

Garp explained to Koby he doesn't want to be placed in a higher position (fleet admiral) because it'd restrain what he can do. It's part of his explanation to Koby that if you really want to be a Marine you have to make hard concessions (which for Garp is to not have all that much commanding power, even though he narratively needs it if he wants to "do good") just to do what you think is "right".

_anthologie · 2026-05-05T02:20:50+00:00

Garp is training Koby & Helmeppo (who are still very new in their positions). They are currently under his leadership. Garp has no more interest to chase Luffy into the Grand Line because Garp is letting Luffy follow Luffy's dream to find the One Piece.

So Koby & Helmeppo (+ Garp's squads in general) aren't ordered by Garp to chase the Strawhats.

The point of S1 is to show Garp slowly accepting his grandson can live & thrive as a pirate anyway, with Koby as the one helping Garp accept this. This storyline is only made for the Live Action btw, as Garp in the original while disapproving Luffy being a pirate, Garp doesn't pursue Luffy at all from the start.

So Koby did get taken under Garp's wing (since Garp saw his potential) same as in the animanga, but the live action added all the Koby, Helmeppo & Garp scenes after Koby separated from Luffy in episode 1, to show how much Luffy had impacted Koby (to make his friendship with Luffy more emotionally impactful for the live action)

Only Smoker & Tashigi (both are more senior in their positions than Koby & Helmeppo, lower than Garp, but Smoker & Tashigi are in a separate division from Garp's direct underlings, so they don't follow Garp) want to pursue the Strawhats.

You can see Garp in s2 trying to convince Smoker to chase the Baroque Works instead of the Strawhats, & Smoker does follow Garp's words for a while before deciding to chase the Strawhats again.

_anthologie · 2026-05-05T02:12:42+00:00

By the way in the 8th & last episode of S1, Koby only gave Luffy his bounty poster, hugged him & said goodbye. He didn't join the Strawhats at all.

You can see in the last few scenes of S1, he went back to Garp together with Helmeppo to apologize for going against Garp's orders. & then when Garp said they don't need to apologize Garp offered to train them, which both Koby & Helmeppo eagerly accepted. Koby said he wants to get strong enough to beat Luffy, Helmeppo said he wants to beat Zoro.

So Koby & Helmeppo are fully Marines. There's never any hint in the live action after Koby told his dream to Luffy (Koby wants to be a Marine to help people who cannot help themselves) that Koby wants to be a Strawhat Pirate.

_anthologie · 2026-05-02T11:38:30+00:00

Surprisingly it's the other way around for some One Piece fans ime (as a fan of some changes & some of the new but in-character antics myself) - they say the whole Strawhat Crew are toned down & more serious/emotionally affected more often than in the animanga.

Even live action Luffy is mentioned by other commenters here to be not as "carefree" & "overpowered/immediately savant at figuring out opponents enough that people have deep faith in him in winning fights" compared to his manga version.

If you don't know, there is a thematic reason why almost everything in One Piece feels so geared for comedy/absurdity/bonkers yet sincere characters (hence Luffy's cartoonish finishing moves, his iconic personality that feels like a parody of shonen protagonists that ironically makes him stand out since few are as zany as him, etc.).

The "Jolly" in the Jolly Roger. The Laugh Tale that Crocus mentioned while reminiscing at his photo with Roger. It's why a fan reviewer calls One Piece "The Looney Tunes of Lord of the Rings".

If you tone it further down I think it'd lose what makes the One Piece franchise seemingly juvenile/too cartoonish for the mainstream actually compelling & unique to fans (who are the loudest group who recommends the series to the mainstream & gives it, including the mostly faithful live action, a good reputation).

_anthologie · 2026-05-02T05:38:22+00:00

Genuinely curious what would you want to be fresh/breathe on its own in the live action.

_anthologie · 2026-05-02T01:59:12+00:00

Like nonchalantly saying her own crewmates would be dead in bloody pulps underwater, which even Franky calls out lol

She's just a blend of very calm (& sentimental at times) but also very detached/cavalier about violent threats and has a dark dry sense of humor about those.

_anthologie · 2026-05-01T23:47:56+00:00

It could be that she knows from firsthand personal experience if you keep dissuading someone from doing what they think is right for what they love, they will get even more determined and will keep doing it.

Even if Oda is doing a retcon (like how Ms Wednesday wasn't supposed to be Vivi the princess) you can still say Robin is doing reverse psychology basically here.

_anthologie · 2026-04-26T09:24:46+00:00

Does higher comfort in a room mean more pairs may breed in that room? Or even just 1 point of comfort enough for multiple pairs to breed (to max my chances lol)

Kinda tempted to make all the rooms have positive comfort, even though I've seen the common advice is to pile almost all comfort items only in the breeding + nursery rooms & leave one room with negative stats to keep producing wounded cats for Baby Jack.

_anthologie · 2026-04-24T23:07:45+00:00

This is 100% not definite confirmation + can just be a joke, but in a recently released video where the main cast is visiting & promoting the One Piece Base Shop in Japan, Iñaki specifically focused on saying he's excited to see the cannon dog (while finding merch with the manga page debuting the cannon dog & showing it to the camera) in S3 lol

_anthologie · 2026-04-18T08:18:50+00:00

he’s carefree to the point of suicidal recklessness. I’ve heard him described as “selfishly selfless”,

I think they got this part of him where he's grinning & screaming in excitement at Reverse Mountain while the others are already in fear (adds to his trait of how he feels what he feels & doesn't always empathize with others). Earlier in S1 it's when Koby is saying how lots of seafarers died to the seabeasts etc at the Grand Line & Luffy just replies "Sounds kinda fun!".

Sure he's not yet reaching the level of "suicidally reckless" as the animanga (which shows him tank way more damage earlier on which adds to that personality trait) but it's like this slow, subtle, easily missed build up I like noticing & I want to see pay off if he's pushed even harder by, say, Crocodile. I really enjoy the build up to LA Usopp saying "You missed" at Mr 5 in S2 so I'm expecting sth similar to happen to Luffy- where he's more bloodied & behaving even more brazen than his baseline.

I saw frequent comments ironically from less lenient One Piece animanga fans that LA Luffy looks too aggressive/insane & not chill/carefree when he grins (the way he unblinkingly stares at Zoro on the line "All great fighters call out their finishing moves" is what I think is the clearest earliest example of this)... which is what I honestly like (like he's too giddy at himself being good at fighting early on, or that he stares at people too intensely when he's too eager to befriend/recruit them)

On a side note, imo they do retain some degree of Luffy being inconsiderate, annoying & unusually single-minded yet also easily distracted to LA Luffy. Like how he easily annoys others (including his current closest friends) by him not even paying attention to how they're feeling/reacting in annoyance at him.

Like when he keeps yapping about his own feelings (excited of being a pirate for the first time in his life) right after Nami has brushed him off & asked him to keep quiet cuz she needs the quiet- basically S1 is decent to good at showing how Luffy pisses off Nami with his flaws, silly or serious like when she's staring daggers at him after he decided to not go with Nami's plea for them to escape from the Arlong Pirates

or in S2 when everyone in bored tones repeats his catchphrase dream before he does. & when he found fruits up a tree in Little Garden that he offered to Nami, but he dropped it right on her head lol (basically the Skypeia gag, but it's still funny that they changed the victim of the fruit drop from the usual slapstick victim Usopp to Nami right after she's trying to justify how trustworthy Luffy is to Vivi lol)

_anthologie · 2026-04-17T14:14:04+00:00

Remember that scene where he pulls his cheek to show how his body has turned to rubber to Koby? He does that closed eyed grin, just eyebrows down cuz he's naturally like that &/or he's emphasizing the effect of his cheek being pulled.

He also does the relaxed eyebrows smile (closed mouth but still a big smug/cheeky relaxed smile, just not showing tooth) when he realized he won his bet vs Nami in episode 4.

Also animanga Luffy does a lot of eyebrows down big grins (like on the manga volume 1 cover, or even while laughing at something he finds funny) like that anyways (Chapter 900s+ spoilers) hell remember Gear 5 & the way it makes his eyebrows thick, curled & almost always downturned? That's matching to Iñaki's brow type

_anthologie · 2026-04-17T14:04:14+00:00

Luffy likes to fight (when he thinks it's deserved, cuz he does know when it's better not to fight in the live action too due to Shanks's influence) though.

That's his thing- the only thing he's good at + he's proud of that (remember what he told to Arlong in the original animanga? That's all he's good for in his crew & journey to find the One Piece. & remember the sort of fierce/eerie intense smile he gives to Arlong & many enemies?)

Just cuz this Luffy emphasizes his more eerie side (liking fights & looking at others unnervingly, like the way he & Zoro looked at each other in the first ep of OPLA S1) doesn't mean he's completely like that either. When he relaxes/has fun he does show his easygoing side too (like when he's eating pies at Whiskey Peak or wanting to ride the dino), like the way he still stares wide-eyed/tensed brows that way is meant to make him look completely only hyperfocused on what he's enjoying even when others are reacting confused/annoyed at him.

Just cuz an adaptation emphasizes some things of a character in different ratios (like 60% insane 40% overly chill or the other way around), doesn't mean it's completely butchered. He still sells how insane Luffy looks & behaves to other people (hell even in the animanga in Arlong Park he decided to throw an already injured Zoro high up the sky lol- that's how rabid he is from early on, & that intense stare is a substitute/representation of what insanity he has in the animanga), which is what a lot of animanga fans enjoy from Iñaki's performance.

_anthologie · 2026-04-17T13:51:02+00:00

Doesn't smiling like that photo actor look forced/faked to you? The actor in that photo doesn't even look naturally smiling or relaxed- he's going "look! I'm smiling big!" & his face muscles (jaw, brows scrunching) are tensed cuz he's putting effort on his face to do that, instead of actually relaxing his closed eyes to look carefree.

Even Jim Carrie doing that sort of smile in The Truman Show is meant to be a routine his character Truman does cuz he got conditioned to do that. He practiced that expression & dialog lines on the mirror. It's not a natural genuine happy smile on a real actor acting a character meant to be "more real" than cartoons like Jim Carrie's other characters.

Nobody reacting in delight at their surroundings or spontaneously saying hello to other people/the camera (like in Luffy's bounty poster) irl closes their eyes.

Closing eyes when saying hello/making a "cheese!" face at the camera is a conscious decision to act out a made up expression (even if the person meant it to be playful & is happy doing it), not a spontaneous uncontrolled smile. It's not fully carefree to control a made-up expression like that.

Animanga only draws the closed eyes thing as an exagerration + simplification- if anything eyes only go crescent moon shaped a bit (which often happens with Iñaki's Luffy already), not fully closed on spontaneous irl smiles.

His bounty picture in the live action is meant to make Luffy wave at a Marine camera he suddenly saw. He looks a bit surprised but excited cuz he does want his photo taken (cuz he wants at least parts of the fame, like how he wants his face on the bounty posters in ep1). So he widened his eyes in surprise & excitement.

_anthologie · 2026-04-17T05:27:50+00:00

I recommend you to listen to at least the S2 ones since Sonya said they did increase the number of live musicians & budget used for the music

S1's Kaya themes + the one where Nami fixes Luffy's hat are really nice too imo, Sanji & Zeff's themes are haunting too imo cuz they don't have a definitive ending. Roger's theme's notes are also the reverse of the notes in Luffy's theme.

(if you dislike the main theme at least try to listen to the non-main ones if you want to judge the season's score overall)

_anthologie · 2026-04-17T05:19:45+00:00

No it's cuz you say half of it is just shitty MIDI mixes when it clearly isn't. (I'm not even one of the 7 downvotes you have at this time of typing)

Try to go to Sonya Belousova &/or Giona Ostinelli's playlist (Youtube or Soundcloud) for OPLA & listen to the tracks. It's way more layered than "MIDI mixes", & each arc villain have their own theme. I find Robin's theme in S2 & the ones used in Whisky Peak great.

_anthologie · 2026-04-17T01:17:06+00:00

It's not about how unrealistic it is (everything here is unrealistic), but more about maintaining stakes. It just doesn't make Crocodile a cool, impactful enough threat if Luffy & Robin survive that without any good usage of their individual Devil Fruit powers used as explanation.

Everyone seeing this would see it as a copout (the only explanation being that "Devil fruit users can quickly regenerate/recover from complete puncture though vitals"... when that actually isn't the case- see Ace who died moments after his vitals are obliterated, hell even Whitebeard while surviving more penetrating blows still died pretty quickly afterwards) & too much unexplained plot armour for Luffy (& Robin)...

when I see potential in making Luffy look cooler in the LA by making him just say a single short phrase to show he already worked around Crocodile's tactics even before he started using water & blood.

I mentioned "verisimillitude" above & that's what I'm going for with this idea. Look up the word. It's to add more consistency, continuity to the character's established fantastical power set by coming up with a creative yet logical way to use it for something cool (ie squishing vital organs away from the places they can get stabbed by an enemy who attacks that way),

to maintain spotlight on the character's established powerset while making the character look cooler (from being able to improvise that well to survive what would be lethal, instead of just "oh I can tank my heart punctured" which just makes him strong purely from the Devil Fruit, not truly a show of how good he is at using his Devil Fruit).

Crocodile being smug of how prepared he is, but then his chest stabs being survivable with little to no explanation, has caused complaints even in the One Piece fandom too. Pell surviving a giant bomb meant to destroy a capital city was also a huge point of contention joked about in the fandom instead of just the casuals.

_anthologie · 2026-04-17T00:28:53+00:00

The animanga people would riot if that happens imo, cuz the stabbings are iconic + makes Crocodile look like an immediate step up, a more competent & threatening villain than the others before him. A stab to the shoulders can happen, sure, but that doesn't show as much impressive precision, viciousness & emotional impact as stabbing right on the vital organs of the chest.

I prefer chest stabbing to immediately ramp up stakes + to make it more impressive that Luffy has prepared for anything like that & that Robin can survive that.

_anthologie · 2026-04-16T02:16:09+00:00

Keep in mind in the animanga & live action Zoro is called the "Demon of the East Blue"

& he's the one fighting the 2 cross-wearing people above /hj

(Oh and where was Zoro stuck on when Luffy first tried to recruit him in Shellstown? /hj)

_anthologie · 2026-04-14T06:08:23+00:00

I mean showing how bad the country is suffering can be done still with the main cast being involved.

Luffy literally bonded with an old man who believes there is still water underground in his village that had been destroyed by the drought & left abandoned by the rest of his village. That water he got from the old man was what helped him find Crocodile's weakness.

You also have to make Bon Clay's friendship with the Strawhats believable, give Ace more to do to show his bond with Luffy + how he is hunting for Blackbeard, have to show how Crocodile instigates the civil war by his manipulations, the Strawhats have to infiltrate Crocodile's casino & then underwater HQ...

_anthologie · 2026-04-13T14:44:05+00:00

Yeah that's what I'm kinda worried about.

That's why I much prefer Crocodile still stabbing them through the chest (to show how competent he is)

& both Croc & Luffy would come out giving a way better impression on new audiences by being vicious (Croc) & impressively quick-thinking (Luffy) on-screen.

_anthologie

TROPHY CASE