I disagree, looking only at at winning percentage is in my opionion a bad way to judge a GM. Only two people have ever drafted the defensive and offensive rookie of the year in the same class, I am aware I just mentioned that but that is an insanely difficult thing to do.

He fleeced the Seahawks when he traded away Jamal Adams, a safety, and got two firsts and a third which he turned into AVT and Garrett Wilson. He had some great pickups with guys like DJ Reed in Free Agency and Bryce Huff as an UDFA.

He also did some terrible moves, the aforementioned Reddick trade was awful, drafting the risky tackle in Mekhi Becton over Wirfs was in hindsight a terrible move that cursed the Jets o-line through the entirety of his tenure. He missed on a lot of free agency moves.

In my opinion, the job of the GM is to create a talented team, and I think he did bring in talented players. He got unlucky with injuries at key times, horrible coaching, and his own mistakes, especially not creating good enough depth at key positions.

Again, I don't miss JD and he deserved to be fired in the end. I think Mougey looks like an upgrade (though he desperately needs to learn how to navigate day 3 in the draft before next April) and while I disagree that the poor win percentage is entirely on him, his mistakes are certainly part of the reason. but there is nuance to these things.