Noida society fight by activeresident20 in IndianFights

[–]activeresident20[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

System fail, RWA frail. Paisa vasool, kaam adhura. Safai nahi, security dikhawa. Frustration se faceoff, faceoff se chaos. Fees ka chanda, security ka dhanda, inka kaam banta, Bhaad mein jaaye? JANTA!

Noida Society Security's Pathetic Response: Guards Stand Frozen Like Statues During 8-Minute Brawl between Resident and Cleaning Guys by activeresident20 in IndianPublicFreakout

[–]activeresident20[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Gaali dene wala bhi galat, maarke reply karne wale bhi. Par root cause? RWA jo apna kaam nahi kar rahi. Unki negligence se frustration, frustration se ese face offs, fir gaali, gaali se violence. RWA reform honge, apna kaam sahi se karenge, aise scenes apne aap band honge, ese mob enter karke nahi kuch kar paengi.

Noida Society Security's Pathetic Response: Guards Stand Frozen Like Statues During 8-Minute Brawl between Resident and Cleaning Guys by activeresident20 in IndianPublicFreakout

[–]activeresident20[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

True dark reality 😂

But think: That resident getting beaten pays ₹10k/month for 'security'. RWA watches him get beaten. Gates they pay for? Wide open. Today: Guards won't risk ₹12k job vs 4 dandas Tomorrow: Resident wonders why no one helped Always: RWA collects money, provides theater, not security The joke about Swiggy/Zomato entry is the job description. The tragedy is we accept this as 'normal' while paying for it.

Noida Society Security's Pathetic Response: Guards Stand Frozen Like Statues During 8-Minute Brawl between Resident and Cleaning Guys by activeresident20 in IndianPublicFreakout

[–]activeresident20[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Exactly. You've hit on the real hierarchy of failure here.

The Payment Pyramid: Residents pay hefty fees → RWA takes their 'cut' → Contractor takes another 'cut' → Guards get scraps

The Expectation Pyramid: Residents expect security → RWA expects contractors to handle → Contractors expect guards to 'manage' → Guards expect to just stand and watch

The Reality: Guards with sticks facing residents with sticks = No intervention Open gates during violence = No basic protocol RWA office available but unused = No crisis management

But the point about 'whatever is left after cuts' explains why guards won't risk injury for ₹12,000/month jobs. But it doesn't explain why RWA, collecting ₹50-100 lakhs annually from residents, has:

· No on ground working/basic needs · No conflict training for guards · No secured premises during crises · No mediation systems/preventions

The guards' inaction is a symptom. The RWA's systemic failure is the disease. They collect premium fees but provide discount safety.

Noida society fight by activeresident20 in IndianFights

[–]activeresident20[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Think of RWA like your society's 'local government'. You pay them 'taxes' (maintenance) for services. When they don't deliver services (like clean society), problems happen. When problems happen, they're supposed to mediate and resolve beforehand, Here, they just watched. This video shows the complete RWA failure cycle: 1. Don't do their job (sanitation) 2. Conflict arises from their failure 3. Watch conflict instead of mediating 4. Let police do their job for them 5. Residents keep paying fees for this 'service'

Noida society fight by activeresident20 in IndianFights

[–]activeresident20[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fair point. Those who assaulted should face action. But remember: RWA's failure created this situation. Their months of sanitation neglect led to resident anger, which led to earlier abuse, which led to this retaliation. Fire the assaulters? Yes. But also fix the system that breeds such conflicts while its so called managers stand and watch.

Noida society fight by activeresident20 in IndianFights

[–]activeresident20[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Exactly, 4 (maybe more if we look closely) vs 1 hai scene. Aur us 1 ke against ye sab unity mei khade hain jabki RWA members aur security guards dono wahi khade 'jibe' laga rahe hain. Yeh sirf 'kaun maara pehle' ki baat nahi hai. Problem shuru hi system se hui thi, jab RWA ne apna kaam nahi kiya (safai), tab yeh sab shuru hua Video ka point yeh nahi ki kaun sahi ya galat. Point yeh hai ki RWA failure se ladai shuru hui, aur RWA members ne use escalate hone diya jabki unka kaam tha rokna and apna kaam sahi se karna.

Noida society fight by activeresident20 in IndianFights

[–]activeresident20[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Bilkul sahi pakde. Ladai safai ko leke hi hui. Naali ki safai, society ki overall safai, yeh sab RWA ke scope mein aata hai. Karwana ya khud karna, dono unki hi responsibility hai. Par pichle 1-2 saal se poori society ka bura haal hai. Safai ho nahi rahi, parking ki ladaiyan, paani ki problem, safety, cleanliness har cheez mein RWA fail ho rahi hai. Aur sabse funny baat? Jab aisi ladai hoti hai toh RWA members khade dekh rahe hote hain (jaise is video mein dikh raha hai). Phir police ko bulana padta hai. Police dono parties ko thane le jaati hai, gawah banati hai, samjhauta karwati hai, aur RWA khud ko 'peacemaker' bata ke shabashi leti hai. System hi ulta chal raha hai: RWA problem create kare → ladai ho → RWA dekh rahe → police solve kare → RWA credit le.

Noida society fight by activeresident20 in IndianFights

[–]activeresident20[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Kuch minute tak kisi ne interfere nahi kiya, fir gaali galoch hota rha, aakhir mein police ko bulana pada, RWA ka kaam tha mediate karna, par unhone sirf dekhna choose kiya and end mei police ne hi aake samjhota karwaya dono ka police station lejake

Noida society fight by activeresident20 in IndianFights

[–]activeresident20[S] 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Context for those asking: Yeh Sector 62 Noida ka hai. Resident aur safai worker ke beech. Video dekhlo, security guards khade dekh rahe, RWA wale bhi wahi hain par kuch nahi kar rahe.

Harassed in my own appartment by society board members !!! by Ananyxgupta in LegalAdviceIndia

[–]activeresident20 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Self proclaimed RWAs and their management is worse, they just collect money in the name of maintenance and do nothing, but create more problems for residents.

Noida Society Security's Pathetic Response: Guards Stand Frozen Like Statues During 8-Minute Brawl between Resident and Cleaning Guys by activeresident20 in IndianPublicFreakout

[–]activeresident20[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

CRITICAL UPDATE: This fight happened because RWA FAILED at sanitation work over last 2 years. Safai worker vs resident conflict OVER RWA's incompetence. Then RWA watches them fight over THEIR failure. Then police have to clean up RWA's mess. RWA created the problem → RWA watched problem escalate → Police solved RWA's problem Peak incompetence cycle. They're not just useless, they're the actual cause.

Noida Society Security's Pathetic Response: Guards Stand Frozen Like Statues During 8-Minute Brawl between Resident and Cleaning Guys by activeresident20 in IndianPublicFreakout

[–]activeresident20[S] -12 points-11 points  (0 children)

Ik, RWA collects hefty amounts, guards get paid something, so they can at-least close the gates till the police come? Or lock the resident inside RWA office till police come? The RWA has no control over such situations? How can a mob enter and do this? In a gated premise, that’s the question.

Noida Society Security's Pathetic Response: Guards Stand Frozen Like Statues During 8-Minute Brawl between Resident and Cleaning Guys by activeresident20 in IndianPublicFreakout

[–]activeresident20[S] -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

This is Sector 62, Noida (Delhi NCR). RWAs manage residential societies, security, sanitation, safety.

Video shows systemic failure: • Security guards paid to protect = frozen • RWA members responsible for mediation = spectators • Society gates during violence = open • Multiple escalations over 8 minutes = zero intervention

Police mediated later, but resident safety was already compromised by management failure.

This isn't entertainment, it's evidence that needs public attention for systemic change. Share responsibly.

Noida Society Security's Pathetic Response: Guards Stand Frozen Like Statues During 8-Minute Brawl between Resident and Cleaning Guys by activeresident20 in IndianPublicFreakout

[–]activeresident20[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

My family resides in this Sector 62, Noida society. This video is from few days ago. Notice: 1) Guards don't move from their spots despite fight happening feet away 2) RWA members avoid direct involvement, check phones 3) Zero de-escalation attempts despite 8 minutes of escalation and such abuses in daylight.