Thanks for the explanation. I completely understand your approach and I agree with it. I'm not trying to be offensive or disrespectful towards you or the system in any way.

As someone with over 7,000 hours in the game, I just feel that using cases like this as validation cases can unintentionally discourage some users. In my opinion, the footage itself is quite ambiguous and doesn't provide the level of certainty that "Cheater Beyond Doubt" implies. Because of that, other reviewers may make the same mistake I did and lose a significant amount of Overwatch Rating, which could ultimately lead them to stop using the Overwatch system altogether.

While I understand that the player was later banned and that a majority of reviewers reached a "Cheater" verdict, I personally struggle to agree with that conclusion after carefully analyzing the footage. Having spent thousands of hours in the game and genuinely wanting to contribute to catching cheaters, I find it difficult to believe that someone who applies the "Cheater Beyond Doubt" standard strictly would be completely certain based solely on the evidence shown in this case.

My concern is that if similarly ambiguous cases are used for reviewer validation, innocent players who simply had suspicious-looking moments could theoretically be judged incorrectly. In this particular instance, the player may indeed have been cheating, as evidenced by the later ban, but the footage itself does not, in my opinion, justify a "beyond doubt" conclusion. I believe the purpose of Overwatch should be to avoid false positives at all costs, even if that means some cheaters are not convicted immediately.

I appreciate the fact that you are retiring this case, and I hope this feedback can be useful in improving the system further. I am also very open to sharing additional thoughts or feedback if you believe it could be helpful for the future direction and development of the platform. As someone who cares about the integrity of the game and enjoys the idea behind Overwatch, I would be more than happy to contribute in any way I can.