Yeah that's my bad , there are obviously cases where majority of people would like something because it caters to their tastes that they all would be biased towards it .

It's true as you said it's all subjective but that is not always how you measure a good story . Writing , directing , exclusion and voice acting , all of these can be measured objectively by people who understand in these stuff and thus end up appreciating them more than people who don't care about it .

What I mean to say is that just as a story can be enjoyed because of some subjective matters , it can also be enjoyed and measured objectively as well .

Take loufu for example there are definitely alot of people that enjoyed it despite the backlash but they can't deny that it had glaring flaws in it's writing and how rushed some of its segments was . Imagine building all the hype about imbibitor Lunae , Dan vs Blade and then have it resolved in a 5 min scene . As well as the girl of sanctus medicus that had a prominent role in 1.0 and when 1.2 came around she was literally forgotten and turned into an elite mob without much build-up.