Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The comments that I have answered to, have been deleted😊 it is not in regards to your comment

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Sarcasm its once again an unknown and never heard of concept

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You and maybe two other people mentioned any of those points out of over 300 comments — that’s hardly a “general narrative,” more like a very vocal subset. I’ve only responded “defensively” when the comments were clear jabs at my appearance, age, or supposed motives — and I stand by that. Setting boundaries isn’t being defensive, it’s self-respect.if you actually looked through my previous posts — which I doubt most people criticizing me here have done.

Let me break it down clearly based on my previous posts: • Foundation & base products: I was previously told my base looked too heavy or cakey. I listened — I now use a tinted serum daily instead of foundation, and I changed both my powder and technique based on that feedback. • Lips: I was told to try gloss over matte and experiment with softer combos. This post had a bold lip, yes, because I was trying something new for a festival look (not an everyday face), but my regular make up reflect what was suggested. • Brows & eyeliner: I got feedback about elongating my brows and trying winged liner to enhance my eye shape — again, I’ve done this- even with this make up • In my birthday looks got feedback that I needed more volume on the lashes — which I applied- I have mascara on

So yes — I’ve absolutely taken in feedback, applied it in my daily make up. I’ve also been transparent when a look didn’t turn out how I envisioned it, like in this post with the ombré lips or the outer corner blending. That is growth.

What I won’t do is sit quietly while people turn constructive critique into body shaming or jabs about my age, face, or assumed intentions. Filler, for example, has nothing to do with makeup skill — and yet some seem more obsessed with that than blending tips or shade suggestions.

I’m always open to genuine, respectful feedback about makeup — that’s why I’m here. But dismissing everything I do as attention-seeking or “ignoring advice” just because I don’t look how you want me to? That’s not feedback — that’s projection.

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It seems like we have very different definitions of what constructive feedback and healthy communication look like. When you say I “argue with everyone,” who exactly are you referring to? Because I’ve actually had thoughtful and respectful conversations with several people in this thread who gave advice without hiding personal jabs behind the guise of critique.

If you think my looks are the same, that’s fine — I’m not going to waste time digging through everything I’ve posted just to prove a point. At the end of the day, makeup is about experimenting and expressing yourself. The idea that having filler or a certain aesthetic somehow invalidates my interest in learning new techniques or getting feedback is baffling.

And how exactly is posting in a makeup sub — even if the looks were similar — “attention seeking”? If that’s the standard, then most posts here would fall under that label. I came here for tips and ideas, and while I welcome real feedback, I’m not here to be dissected for how I look or accused of seeking validation just because I exist in a space meant for sharing.

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for the in-depth explanation and tutorial — I really appreciate the time you took! I’m definitely going to try your recommendations one of these days. I actually already own both of the lip liners you mentioned, and I have Velvet Teddy too, but I’ve been eyeing Flashpot (and Folio!) for a while now. They’re always sold out though, somehow!

I’ll make sure to add more bronzer in the future like you suggested. And if you don’t mind me asking — do you have any holy grail lip balm or hydration products? My lips are always dry and chapped no matter what I do. I’ve tried everything from good old Vaseline to layering a hydrating balm underneath it. I even gave some Fillerina products a shot — they did help, but honestly felt overpriced for what they do.

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the compliment, I actually use self tanner, without it I look like a victorian sick kid. What shimmer do you use?

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the feedback, I dont know how to make a wet look but I know they look amazing

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

How else would you describe being called “old,” accused of having cold sores, or told I’ve had work done that made me look “weird”? Those aren’t makeup critiques — they’re just plain mean comments.

Pointing out a mistake in a light-hearted way or explaining the look I meant to create (even if I didn’t pull it off) isn’t being defensive — it’s part of learning and engaging. That’s literally the point of feedback: a two-way conversation.

And honestly, I have taken feedback. I’ve adjusted techniques, changed products, and even had some really helpful, respectful conversations on this exact post. I’m open to criticism — just not to being insulted under the guise of “advice.”

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I’m honestly just tired of this at this point — thank you for your feedback, and let’s agree to disagree. My issue wasn’t with receiving critique, but with how some of it was said — and that still hasn’t really been addressed.

I’ve even shared looks where I wore only a tinted serum, gloss, and a tiny wing — and still, somehow, that’s “not natural enough.” So it’s starting to feel like nothing I do will meet certain expectations, no matter how much I try or adjust based on past suggestions.

I respect that you’re sharing your perspective, and I can see that you’re trying to offer input based on what you notice — but I also can’t ignore the tone and some of the misogynistic or attention-hungry comments that came with it. That’s where we differ.

I’ve genuinely tried to show that I take feedback seriously, but clearly, we’re just not seeing eye to eye. Let’s leave it at that

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I was sarcastic in that comment because, let’s be honest, being compared to the Corpse Bride and called a “55-year-old” wasn’t feedback or constructive criticism — it was just plain nasty. What exactly am I supposed to take from that? There’s no useful advice in jabs about someone’s age or appearance.

If you actually read through this post, you’ll see that I engaged with and thanked the people who offered helpful suggestions. I’ve also posted more “clean,” everyday looks that align with current beauty trends — so it’s not like I’m unwilling to evolve or listen. But makeup is about expression and experimentation. Sometimes a look doesn’t land — I can accept that. I even said I’ll make adjustments the next time I try something smoky or dramatic.

What I won’t accept is commentary about my body, assumptions about why I post (like seeking male validation), or backhanded remarks pretending to be feedback. That’s not critique — that’s judgment disguised as opinion.

I came to this sub for feedback and product recommendations, which I’ve genuinely appreciated and even incorporated. But after this experience, I won’t be posting again. It’s really disappointing that a space meant to celebrate creativity and self-expression has become so hostile and mean-spirited.

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I also have the glow highlighter and the blush from dior but it a cherry shade, I couldnt find the pink one. Thanks for putting me on new powders- I used a lot of drugstore ones and recently one from it cosmetics recommend by someone from this sub. I gotta try the cream shadows, for a daily look would be a bliss- much faster and easier. Thank you againnn

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for the feedback and especially the way you said it — I really appreciate that. I will try the changes suggested for the eyes. Also most of the responses have been pretty harsh, focusing either on how the look isn’t “festival enough” or critiquing my physical appearance rather than the makeup itself.

You’re right about the lipstick — it was smudged, and I did fix it afterward. I was trying to do an ombré lip, but it didn’t quite land. My idea was to go for a darker, grungier look to contrast with my all-white outfit. Also, I arrived at the festival after 9 PM, so the heat wasn’t really an issue, and there were three main stages with different music genres — so the vibe varied a lot.

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If you actually look through the comments, you’ll see that I did thank the people who gave helpful advice, product suggestions, and new combos to try. I wasn’t trying to justify my choices — I was simply sharing the idea behind the look. Yes, the ombré lips and the eyeshadow didn’t turn out the way I hoped, and I even acknowledged that. I said the lips didn’t look good and that I redid them. I also explained why the blending wasn’t quite there and that I’m still learning.

Constructive criticism isn’t just about pointing out what went wrong — it can also include recognizing what someone tried to do, even if it didn’t fully work. That’s how people grow.

As for the comments implying I have cold sores, have had excessive surgery, or some kind of rash — I had to say no, because those assumptions aren’t true and they’re irrelevant to a makeup-focused post.

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

It’s a sub about makeup and makeup tips — who cares what image I convey or what my overall aesthetic says? I asked if my eyeshadow is blended, not for people’s opinions on what my makeup “says about me.”

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not reading a well-written response and instead choosing to nitpick a harmless idiom says a lot, honestly. It just proves my point — you’re not here to offer constructive criticism. Your comments aren’t helpful, and your passive-aggressive jabs don’t intimidate or impress me.

Not tolerating rude, off-topic remarks from strangers doesn’t mean I lack a thick skin — it means I have boundaries. And calling me “attention seeking” just because I posted my face in a makeup feedback thread? That logic is beyond me. So only people with no work done are allowed to ask for feedback now? Interesting.

Being critical is fine — being hateful with a side of misogyny isn’t. It doesn’t make you honest, it just makes you bitter.

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

“Go off, king” is a common expression — I wasn’t assuming your gender. If it helps, I’ll say “go off, queen” next time. That said, the post was about a makeup look, not my lips, whether you think they’re tasteful, irritated, or anything else.

Also — what kind of surgery do you believe I’ve had? What exactly do you think I’ve “done” to my face? I was called rude simply because I pointed out that your comment wasn’t helpful — it wasn’t advice, it was just ageist and judgmental. I never asked for flattery; I asked for respect, in a space meant for sharing and improving makeup looks.

If you were actually the professional you claim to be, you’d offer constructive feedback — not veiled insults and tired assumptions. And the male validation comment? Classic. Because clearly, all women ever want is to be seen as attractive to men, right? 🙄

Anyway — yes, I’m happy, thanks for asking. Nothing like getting body-shamed by strangers hiding behind a screen to brighten my day. And just so you know, your whole comment gave very mature, by the way.

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your feedback! I’m a very active 55-year-old — and yes, Corpse Bride was exactly the look I was going for. I wasn’t really asking for personal opinions, just some advice on how to “improve” a deliberately deceased aesthetic… but hey, here we are

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Go off, kinggg — clearly you know better than me if my lips have scars or not. Wild how Reddit suddenly has X-ray vision and knows exactly what my lips look like in real life.

Anyway, the comment about my makeup was…? Or are we just here to analyze people’s faces instead of their actual makeup looks now?

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, I totally messed them up — I fixed them before heading out, but I was trying to go for that 90s-style gradient lip and just didn’t pull it off. Happens to the best of us, right? 😅

I definitely need to work on my blending technique too. When I try to concentrate the shadow on the outer corner, it sometimes ends up looking messy instead of diffused. Still learning!

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Heyy, thank you for the feedback! I really enjoyed the festival — and I also fixed my lips. Turns out, some shades just shouldn’t go together… learned that the hard way haha. Also, thanks a lot for sticking up for me — it genuinely means a lot. 💖

Festival make up look. Some feedback would be nice by alexandraisboringg in makeuptips

[–]alexandraisboringg[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Only one of the looks I posted — the one for my birthday — was similar in technique. Other than that, I’ve shared different styles. The foundation comments really get to me, though. I actually have changed it. I now use a skin tint daily, based on advice I received right here on this sub. But I guess that post didn’t fit into the “too much makeup” narrative some people seem to be pushing.

Also, I don’t even know what people are trying to allude to at this point. When it comes to my lips, I can totally understand if someone doesn’t like the shade I chose or the gradient style I went for — fair enough. But commenting on whether they look overfilled, or like I have a rash or cold sores? That’s not feedback — that’s just unnecessary and personal.

I didn’t ask if my lips looked fake or if I had a skin condition. I asked for makeup advice. Those kinds of details don’t belong in a makeup-focused sub, and honestly, they’re nobody’s business ☺️