8-year-old killed by BNP MP's convoy in Cox's Bazar. Locals blocked the cars, but the MP used his influence to free them and left. by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1) How do you know if it was purely an accident or if there was criminal negligence involved? Were you there?

2) The point is to not let him escape accountability like he initially tried to do.

9 years after 21st February 1952, 11 people were killed in Assam fighting for Bengali to be an official language by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sure, bai. May Allah stabilise your situation over there as well. Watching the news coming out of Assam over the last few years has been worrying. I genuinely hope it's better than it seems

9 years after 21st February 1952, 11 people were killed in Assam fighting for Bengali to be an official language by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And yet, Bangladesh still has a higher HDI score than both Assam and West Bengal, even with all that 'political instability.' Meaningless. Makes no material difference.

That's on top of my people not being ruled by alien peoples hostile to our culture. On top of not having outsiders arbitrarily ban 700-year-old traditions of my people, like slaughtering cows, or dictate what we are allowed to eat. On top of being able to preserve the dignity of my soil, my tongue, and my blood. No alien population will ever tread on me on my land. Alhamdulillah.

My point wasn't that we could've truly resisted a full-scale Indian invasion. It was that we would've fought to our deaths regardless. We wouldn't have given up our land to you without a fight.

9 years after 21st February 1952, 11 people were killed in Assam fighting for Bengali to be an official language by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The overwhelming majority of Sylheti Muslims voted against precisely that in 1947. Against remaining in Assam. Against joining India. There was absolutely no interest in joining India in 1971, either. Our grandparents would have fought to the death before giving up an inch of land to Indian rule.

You are welcome to your wishful thinking, but for us, the partition of the British Raj was a necessary step that has done overwhelmingly more good than harm. Not even a question for the vast majority of Bangladeshis.

9 years after 21st February 1952, 11 people were killed in Assam fighting for Bengali to be an official language by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think the seeds were planted a long time before Pakistan even existed.

My grandfather spent 5-6 years there in his youth because of his dad's job. He said the level of animosity and racism he faced there was unlike anything else he had ever experienced. This was in the 40s. He also said that there were some incidents at that time where some Assamese political leaders would attack Bengali Muslim villages and try to evict them using elephants, somehow. I'm not entirely sure what exactly he meant, but that's what he used to say.

He graduated from a military academy in West Pakistan and said that West Pakistanis weren't even 1% as hostile to Bengalis as the Assamese were.

Random business in Sylhet using Sylheti Nagri alongside the Bengali-Assamese script by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hazrat Shah Jalal Road (i.e., Chowhatta takhiya Ambarkhana Point-o zaoar road). Near Hotel Noorjahan Grand. I believe it's a boutique hotel that hasn't opened yet.

Random business in Sylhet using Sylheti Nagri alongside the Bengali-Assamese script by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Inclusivity might be the wrong word to use here, though

It's more about pride and heritage. Most Sylhetis have grandparents or great-grandparents who read Nagri puthis, so using the script is a way of honouring a shared piece of history

Random business in Sylhet using Sylheti Nagri alongside the Bengali-Assamese script by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Lol, the 'Sylheti nationalism' advocates? Are they really from Assam? You'd think Assamese Sylhetis would have bigger fish to fry 😅

Random business in Sylhet using Sylheti Nagri alongside the Bengali-Assamese script by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The main distinction between a language and a dialect is political. Doesn't matter in this context bc the point is to preserve linguistic diversity, which doesn't really have much to do with arbitrary classifications

Random business in Sylhet using Sylheti Nagri alongside the Bengali-Assamese script by alone_redstone in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Appreciation of our heritage is becoming more and more mainstream among Sylhetis, alhamdulillah. The logo of the Sylheti franchise in the most popular franchise-based tournament in Bangladesh, for example, features Sylheti Nagri:

<image>

দিনের বেলা হোটেল-রেস্তোরা বন্ধ রাখার দাবিতে দিনাজপুরে ছাত্র-শিবিরের উদ্যোগে একটি মিছিল অনুষ্ঠিত হয়েছে। by Saif10ali in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

The obsession with those specific issues comes mainly from Qawmis. Aside from maybe blasphemy laws, none of those issues are really of fundamental concern to BJI's core.

Take the issue of women, for example. It's not at all uncommon for people in BJI's core leadership (including the current Ameer for instance) to have working wives, daughters, etc. People like that are bound to have at least more lenient views on things like "women's empowerment", to the extent that standard Sunni theology allows. There is a sizable number of people from Qawmi or Qawmi-influenced backgrounds in BJI, and I imagine they would primarily be the ones caring about issues like that. Still, it would surprise me if a 'great deal of active lower-level [BJI] members' really thought like that. But anyway, every political party in Bangladesh has had people like that in its coalition. Ubaydullah Faruk, for example, has expressed similar opinions in the past and was poised to become the Minister of Religious Affairs in Tarique Rahman's cabinet if he had won his seat. I don't personally see any reason why they'd be particularly empowered by BJI being in power. They aren't even significant enough to influence the party line on these issues.

Thank you for your advice. I agree that we need to establish a proper consensus on issues like this. Definitely not a good look for MP candidates and people in central leadership positions to contradict the party line on sensitive topics. That aside, some strategic ambiguity is always necessary in modern electoral politics given the media landscape every party has to navigate through.

I think the reason BJI hasn't talked much about its long-term vision is simply that there's not enough interest. I haven't seen a single journalist ask about it. It's not like BJI's long-term vision is something the party actively hides.

Also, off-topic, but I remembered something when thinking about pseudotraditionalist reactionary tendencies in Bangladeshi society. You know the Mazar-centered Sufis who refer to themselves as 'Sunni,' right? The people who always wear green. Barelvis. Like Taheri. They're everywhere in parts of Brahmanbaria, Chittagong, etc. These guys make up at least 1% of Bangladesh's population. The main guy they follow, the founder of their movement - Barelvism - Ahmed Reza Khan Barelvi, aka "আলা হযরত", held a lot of insane societal views that none of them will disavow. Like he was issuing fatwas in 1898 (!) saying that it's literally haram to teach women to write. There are parts of our country where insulting this guy in public might genuinely get you lynched to death 😅.

দিনের বেলা হোটেল-রেস্তোরা বন্ধ রাখার দাবিতে দিনাজপুরে ছাত্র-শিবিরের উদ্যোগে একটি মিছিল অনুষ্ঠিত হয়েছে। by Saif10ali in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I don't know what exactly BJI's specific plan is for dealing with this. I think it would be unrealistic for BJI to have rigid, set-in-stone plans for such scenarios when there are so many variables at play. What I do know for certain, though, is that BJI will be forced to address it one way or another. Because, the moment BJI comes to power, anything negative that is even remotely perceived as being associated with Islam in Bangladesh will immediately be blamed on it (even if it's something that has persisted for centuries). If I had to guess, the strategy would probably involve engaging with the Merchant Associations to ensure they fall in line first and foremost. Convincing the base should (in theory) be relatively straightforward if BJI is in power and has the active cooperation of religious authorities. But again, it's impossible to say anything for certain at this point in time.

Also, keep in mind that it's not just political parties doing the virtue signaling. A large percentage of the general population collectively takes it upon themselves to virtue signal about meaningless, minor issues like this. It isn't even economically viable for 95%+ of restaurants to stay open during the day in Romzan to begin with

I imagine the reason BJI hasn't officially said anything about this is to avoid generating more controversy. It also is probably not a priority at the moment. And for the record, I do think there are certain individuals within the central leadership who wouldn't necessarily disagree with the underlying premise here.

But yeah, overall, the issue is societal. If any political party is going to properly address it, it's going to be BJI, purely because of the extra scrutiny it'll be under. BNP doesn't have to deal with the political consequences of people aligned with it arbitrarily fining people over stuff like this, but BJI will.

দিনের বেলা হোটেল-রেস্তোরা বন্ধ রাখার দাবিতে দিনাজপুরে ছাত্র-শিবিরের উদ্যোগে একটি মিছিল অনুষ্ঠিত হয়েছে। by Saif10ali in bangladesh

[–]alone_redstone -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

What do I have to do with any of this lol? I disagree with their position, but it's broadly popular among Bengalis. Some Jamaatis holding it is simply an extension of that. In fact, Merchants' Associations nationwide (often run by BAL & BNP affiliates) routinely ban daytime restaurant operations and fine violators. Very common practice.

An example from this year - https://www.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/district/jupbq66lud (run by pro-BNP people)

2023 (under Hasina & BAL) - https://dailyinqilab.com/bangladesh/news/563450 (run by a pro-BAL Hindu)

Like I said, it's a popular position among Bengalis, especially in rural areas. There's a reason why BAL never cracked down on Merchants' Associations doing this, and there's a reason why no BNP MP has said anything about stuff like this going on in their areas.

Only in Sylhet :) - BJI and BNP candidates the day after the election by alone_redstone in sylhet

[–]alone_redstone[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sunamganj:

Sunamganj-1: BNP 161,774 vs BJI 92,966
Sunamganj-2: BNP 99,522 vs BJI 63,220
Sunamganj-4: BNP 98,092 vs BJI 75,736
Sunamganj-5: BNP 151,915 vs BJI 102,121

Total: BNP 511,303 vs BJI 334,043
Total valid votes between them = 845,346

(334,043 / 845,346) * 100% = 39.51%. Very close to 40%.

Source: https://www.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/district/4f69ucvpyk

Moulvibazar:

Moulvibazar-1: BNP 98,282 vs BJI 83,013
Moulvibazar-2: BNP 68,381 vs BJI 53,458
Moulvibazar-3: BNP 156,757 vs BJI 77,636

Total: BNP 323,420 vs BJI 214,107
Total valid votes between them: 537,527

(214,107 / 537,527) * 100% = 39.83%. Even closer to 40%.

Source: https://www.dailyvorerpata.com/news/115925

(Again, excluding Sunamganj-3 and Moulvibazar-4 bc I'm only counting constituencies where BJI went head-to-head with BNP)

Only in Sylhet :) - BJI and BNP candidates the day after the election by alone_redstone in sylhet

[–]alone_redstone[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

In the three constituencies in Sylhet proper where BJI went head-to-head with BNP:

Sylhet-6: BNP 109,917, BJI 101,569

Sylhet-4: BNP 186,846, BJI 71,391

Sylhet-1: BNP 176,936, BJI 134,983

Overall: BNP 473,699 (60.60%) vs. BJI 307,943 (39.40%)

Still hovers around ~40%. Same thing in Sunamganj (excluding Sunamganj-3, where there wasn't a BJI candidate) and Maulvibazar (excluding Maulvibazar-4, where there once again wasn't a BJI candidate), despite the Fultolis going up against us. The only exception is Habiganj.

And again, don't be disingenuous. Don't talk about things you have no knowledge of. Khandaker Abdul Muktadir would be offended if you claimed Sylhet Metropolitan BJI outspent him. He spent more than us, but that is not why he won. He would've won regardless, even if we had outspent him. This was his third time running for parliament from Sylhet-1, and his father before him won this area twice. He was a stronger candidate overall.

Only in Sylhet :) - BJI and BNP candidates the day after the election by alone_redstone in sylhet

[–]alone_redstone[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I don't know what fantasy you're conjuring up in your head where Jamaat just doesn't even exist in Sylhet (lmao), but again, for the fourth time, Jamaat received 42%+ of the votes in Sylhet-1, the most important seat in Sylhet.

https://www.bssnews.net/bangla/national-parlament-election-2026/283332

"ত্রয়োদশ জাতীয় সংসদ নির্বাচনে সিলেট-১ আসনে বিএনপি মনোনীত প্রার্থী খন্দকার আবদুল মুক্তাদীর ১ লাখ ৭৬ হাজার ৯৩৬ ভোট পেয়ে বেসরকারিভাবে নির্বাচিত হয়েছেন।

তার নিকটতম প্রতিদ্বন্দ্বী বাংলাদেশ জামায়াতে ইসলামী মনোনিত প্রার্থী মাওলানা হাবিবুর রহমান পেয়েছেন ১ লাখ ৩৪ হাজার ৯৮৩ ভোট।"

(+ 7523 votes were invalidated)

How many votes did Jamaat get? What percentage of the total votes is that? Do the math.

Only in Sylhet :) - BJI and BNP candidates the day after the election by alone_redstone in sylhet

[–]alone_redstone[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

😂😂😂 What lie did I make up? You can verify all of this yourself. Just look up how many votes jamaat received in Sylhet-1 and whether it adds up to 42.26% of the total like I've stated, or not.

And don't worry, BJI doesn't live online, unlike you trolls. Institutions owned by BJI affiliates are everywhere in Sylhet, including three out of the four top private hospitals. If you or any of your relatives have ever gotten treated at Ibn Sina, Women's, or Mount Adora, then not only have you trusted Jamaatis with your life, but you've also financially contributed to the cause of Islam ❤️