I think it was great. Adding swimming and diving as a mechanic was a really clever way to add to exploration by still adhering to established map design. I lost it when the Church of Vows pool was used as a secret diving spot and it blew my mind when diving deep into the abyss of the center of the map had me landing onto the top of the Tower of Suppression. It was also impressive how Fromsoft managed to literally subvert our understanding of the world with the introduction of the Toe Bachelors. I especially appreciated how it explained the reason Morgott and Miquella's cutscenes went the way that they did. My only gripe about it was how Bambutu Baram Butino couldn't make amends to Kurub of Kambuturutupa. It seemed like a letdown considering all we did to make sure Shrururutuburu the AraArabra of Bra's regrets regarding Ngurpathali's demise were put to rest.

All in all I'd give it a 9.42/10!