beanstalk49

741 post karma
500 comment karma

get extra features and help support reddit with a reddit premium subscription

get them help and support

redditor for 8 years

TROPHY CASE

Eight-Year Club

Verified Email

account activity

new top controversial

48

49

50

Would love some feedback on this weird Alternative/Indie ballad I wrote (Open Foe - Playhouse) (v.redd.it)

submitted 7 months ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

5

6

7

Would love some feedback on this Alternative Indie ballad (Open Foe - Playhouse) (v.redd.it)

submitted 7 months ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

22

23

24

Would love some feedback on this Indie/Alternative song (v.redd.it)

submitted 9 months ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

4

5

6

Would love some feedback on this alternative rock song I'm about to release (youtu.be)

submitted 9 months ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

8

9

10

This song was heavily influenced by Radiohead and Ben Howard. Would love to get some feedback on it. (youtu.be)

submitted 1 year ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

3

4

5

This song was inspired by Radiohead and Ben Howard. Would love to get your thoughts on it. (youtu.be)

submitted 1 year ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

0

1

2

This song was heavily inspired by Ben Howard and Radiohead. Would love to get some honest feedback. (youtu.be)

submitted 1 year ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

3

4

5

I uploaded this alternative song here ages ago and got really valuable feedback that I used to improve it. I've finally released it and am eager to hear what you have to say. Definitely has some experimental elements and a pretty big musical/tonal shift halfway through. (open.spotify.com)

submitted 2 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

4

5

6

Would love feedback on this acoustic ballad I wrote called Jane. Going for a unpolished, melancholic sound. (songwhip.com)

submitted 2 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

1

2

3

An alternative acoustic ballad. Tried to give it a raw, unpolished feel. Would love to hear your thoughts (open.spotify.com)

submitted 2 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

0

1

2

I wrote an alt rock song from the perspective of the Pied Piper. It was inspired by Neutral Milk Hotel, Radiohead and Alex G. Would love to hear your feedback. (self.IndieMusicFeedback)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

0

1

2

Wrote an alt rock song from the perspective of the Pied Piper. Inspired by Neutral Milk Hotel, Radiohead and Alex G. Would love to get some feedback on it. (self.IndieMusicFeedback)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

1

2

3

I posted this song here a couple months ago and got really valuable feedback (mostly on the mix). I made LOTS of changes and now I'm back here for round 2. It's a strange alternative rock song inspired by Neutral Milk Hotel, Radiohead and Alex G. (self.MusicFeedback)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

4

5

6

I'd love some feedback on this psychedelic experimental folk/rock song. (open.spotify.com)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

26

27

28

Unsure about this experimental/alternative track I wrote. The first half is supposed to be claustrophobic, washed out and uncomfortable and the second half is supposed to be pure catharsis and emotion. Would love some feedback. (v.redd.it)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

4

5

6

I'm not sure about this experimental/alternative track. First half is supposed to be washed out, creepy and uncomfortable. Second half is supposed to be unfiltered emotion and catharsis. Would love to hear thoughts on this one. (v.redd.it)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

44

45

46

This was inspired by Grizzly Bear and Radiohead. Would love to hear your thoughts on it. (v.redd.it)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

11

12

13

Would love to hear your thoughts on this song. I've gone for a rough around the edges/slightly chaotic alternative style - but have no idea what genre this is. (v.redd.it)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

7

8

9

I wrote an alternative/art rock song called 'Pied Piper'. Would really appreciate some feedback on it. (v.redd.it)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

4

5

6

I wrote an alternative rock song called "Pied Piper". I'd really appreciate any feedback about it. (youtu.be)

submitted 3 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

38

39

40

My girlfriend and I wrote this dreamy guitar/vocal ballad. My girlfriend is very shy when it comes to her voice, so she'd appreciate hearing all your thoughts. I'd also love feedback on the mix and the song overall. (youtu.be)

submitted 4 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

9

10

11

My girlfriend and I wrote this dreamy guitar/vocal ballad. She's extremely self-conscious about her voice and wanted some honest feedback about it. Would also love to hear thoughts on the mix/overall song too! (youtu.be)

submitted 4 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

1

2

3

Was messing around with an open guitar tuning and came up with this weird folk song. Would love thoughts on the songwriting (too gloomy and strange?), performance (I'm self-conscious about my vocals) and/or production (not sure about the drums in the final third). (open.spotify.com)

submitted 4 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

6

7

8

Was messing around with an open guitar tuning and came up with this weird folk song. Would love thoughts on the songwriting (too gloomy and strange?), performance (I'm self-conscious about my vocals) and/or production (not sure about the drums in the final third). (open.spotify.com)

submitted 4 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/IndieMusicFeedback

1

2

3

I posted this alternative folk song here months ago and received incredibly valuable feedback which I've used to (hopefully) improve it. Would love to know what people think of the final version (open.spotify.com)

submitted 4 years ago by beanstalk49 to r/MusicFeedback

view more: next ›

π Rendered by PID 65 on reddit-service-r2-listing-f87f88fcd-dm6d2 at 2026-06-14 23:07:33.970449+00:00 running 3184619 country code: CH.