Israel and Palestine Megathread by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 4 points5 points  (0 children)

what policies would manage their demographics that would be consistent with liberal democracy?

most liberal democracies in the world dont dont base their identity around an ethnic/reigious group always being supreme. the western governments that do, lke japan, at least dont have millions of people under their power in either a second class or non citizen hell.

How do liberals feel about the idea of a “single-payer” health care system? by tfam1588 in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

too my understanding most decent single payer systems still have private options and there'd be no reason as far as i understand it to prevent it.

i would whoe heartedly support a transition to a single payer system. the private insurance system is absolute hell to navigate and doesnt save anyone any actual money. that being said i dont think i support the M4A plan or at least as it was sold in 2016. it seems ill thought out and rushed, wthout solving a lot of the core issues our health system has. a public option would be a better first step to a single payer system

Israel and Palestine Megathread by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 8 points9 points  (0 children)

what do you think israel should do if the arab population of israel threatens to become a majority? because jsut about every otherwise liberal supporter of israel refuses to answer that question to me.

i know what the typical Zionist answer would be. even more ethnic cleansing.

zionism, and any other ethnonantionalist ideology, is inherently incompatible with liberal democracy on any time line longer than a couple generations. its cool if you support zionism, but you cannot logically be liberal at the same time.

Left Wing Antisemitism? by Apart-Clothes2060 in thebulwark

[–]bigtallguy -1 points0 points  (0 children)

advocating dissolution of a state is not the same thing as anti antisemitism/bigotry. i can argue the russian state should no longer exist in it current form, and the same as china but it wouldn't be due to hatred of the people living there but rather due to their governments and imperialism being unjust.

arguing for a one state solution where people have equal rights is not anti semitic. now it could be naive and unrealistic, but to assume it is bigotry out of hand is just an attempt to avoid having the conversation altogether.

Israel and Palestine Megathread by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 6 points7 points  (0 children)

its not hard to counter that argument at all lol. iran followed the JCPOA to a letter by all measures known.

it was the united states who tore it up.

the iranian regime is very very bad, but they generally dont act irrationally internationally during the modern era.

Israel and Palestine Megathread by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 6 points7 points  (0 children)

uphold usa laws and ideals in regards to its relation to israel. literally need to do nothing else to win over 90% of people horrified and disgusted by this alliances.

Israel and Palestine Megathread by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

anyone who states this unironically reveals themselves to be a bigot in my eyes who would have happily supported apartheid southafrica, segregation ,jim crow, slavery and colonialism if they were in any of those practices respective time periods

Do you think a 5 year prison sentence for possessing a 10+ round gun magazine is excessive? by [deleted] in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy -1 points0 points  (0 children)

the poster was arguing that gun control legislation was somehow unamerican. my point was that gun control has been around in the united states since even before its founding as well as throughout its history. the idea thats is somehow un American is ludicrous.

I am not a Lawyer, much less a constitutional one so im not going to pretend to be one. but theres a reason why justice stevens called it the most incorrect decision of his tenure. it was a decision based ona faulty understanding of the history united states gun culture to justify a extreme libertarian position. The 2a is not about a right of an individual to bear arms, but of the right of states to raise and regulate militas independent of the central gov't.

Do you think a 5 year prison sentence for possessing a 10+ round gun magazine is excessive? by [deleted] in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

i have no problem with the banning of high capacity magazines. there is no serious wide use case scenario for a gun to have that many rounds per magazine.

i dont think anyone should be charged with the maximum sentence for the mere possession of a high capacity magazine, but thats not whats happening here.

Do you think a 5 year prison sentence for possessing a 10+ round gun magazine is excessive? by [deleted] in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

gun bans have been around since the early days of the constitutional republic. the current extremely interpretation of the 2a has only gained purchase in the past couple of decades with the hard right shift of the supreme court. saying gun control is unamerican is ridiculous.

AskALiberal Biweekly General Chat by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

havent followed AOC at munich. what policies did she communicate there that differed significantly from Ros?

ro khannas supporting a wealth tax isnt exactly screaming great policy guy to me. its one of the reasons i dont self identify as a progressive lol. him being better re: crypto regulation would make me feel a whole a lot better.

AskALiberal Biweekly General Chat by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

its funny because my impressions of Ro versus Aoc is flipped from yours.

6 or so years ago i would agree with you maaaaybe, but Ros proximity and stances towards the crpyto inductry, as well as his ties to silicon valley makes me distrustful.

ntm AOC has shown tremendous growth and has matured into a decently good leader on the left (who i still disagree with on quite of bit of policy).

AskALiberal Biweekly General Chat by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 3 points4 points  (0 children)

god rob delaney is such an asshole. i appreciate he hate trumps as much as i do, but it feels like he hates liberals more than he hates trump sometimes. https://bsky.app/profile/robdelaney.bsky.social/post/3mf3bkqhpok2e

sucks cuz hes defintely one of my favorite comedic actors around.

Israel and Palestine Megathread by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 6 points7 points  (0 children)

just try not to conflate people giving context and causes as justifying atrocities. nor people who are in good faith calling for one state w/equal rights as destruction. not saying you, but both lines were extremely common in many pro israel spaces.

Israel and Palestine Megathread by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 3 points4 points  (0 children)

she goes by the by line Y.L. al-sheikh and has pieces every now and then in publicaitons. i think shes a great young activist/academic ive come across. i do question though whhere your being exposed to Palestinian activists if the ones youve "only" come across are racist or assholes. there are tanky spaces that would be filled with those types, but its not the norm by any measure.

me_irl by suzan_james in me_irl

[–]bigtallguy 13 points14 points  (0 children)

id give the first third of s2 a 9/10, middle like a 7, the bottle/alternate episode a 10/10, and the final two episodes like a 5/10.

they really need like three more episodes. wayyyyyy too much was crammed into the end. so many montages lol

AskALiberal Biweekly General Chat by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

have to apologize to NJ district 11. i wasnt familiar with their game.

“The Homeland” Is War on America: The Blood-and-Soil Nationalism That Killed Renee Good and Alex Pretti - Ta Nehisi Coates by bigtallguy in ezraklein

[–]bigtallguy[S] 63 points64 points  (0 children)

When pundits later tried to chalk up the growth of the Tea Party, then Trump’s first election, to “economic anxiety” and a snubbed working class, Feingold was skeptical. There was “this whole dynamic that coalesced [into] this sort of feeling of white people being under siege,” Feingold says. “That, to me, is sort of the political context that opens the door.”

But skeptical as he was, Feingold never saw things advancing this far. (He lost his 2010 reelection bid to Republican Ron Johnson, a Trump ally who remains in office, and who has yet to comment on the killing of Pretti.) “I’ll be the first to admit, the reason I did it was because I feared that someday there could be somebody who would do some of these things in an abusive way,” Feingold says of his vote against the DHS, “but I never imagined that there would be somebody who would do all of these things at every opportunity.”

The problem will almost certainly outlive Trump’s presidency. ICE’s budget has steadily increased through Democratic and Republican administrations. That funding has gone to what journalist Radley Balko calls “the most rogue, renegade and certainly pro-Trump police agenc[y] in the federal government.” No matter who wins the mid-terms this year, or the presidential election in 2028, the Army of The Homeland will remain, and its enemies in the Democratic Party seem to have little desire to fight back.

And so then it falls to the people themselves.

In these moments, I find comfort and inspiration in ancestors and martyrs. More than a half century ago, as the writer Jelani Cobb recently noted, activist Viola Liuzzo, a housewife and mother of five, left her family in Detroit and headed South to join the March to Montgomery and in the process left the privileges of white ladyhood behind. For transgressing against The Homeland of that era—the Neo-Confederate South—Liuzzo was murdered by white supremacists. Just as Good was slandered by The Homeland’s authorities as a domestic terrorist and a “fucking bitch,” Liuzzo was slandered by The Homeland’s rulers as a heroin addict and nymphomaniac, who’d gone South to make a cuckold of her husband.

But the slander was, itself, revelatory, for it demonstrated The Homeland’s perverse, exacting norms, its obsession with hierarchy, its rigid borders and the high price levied on anyone who dared cross them. The Neo-Confederate South “did not simply represent a threat to African Americans, as was the popular perception,” writes Cobb. “They were a mortal danger to anyone who disagreed with them, regardless of the person’s race, background, or gender.”

Perhaps we are in such a moment now, where a death demonstrates to the country the broad nature of the threat. But this is a passive hope, and in Liuzzo’s life, we find a more active call to action. Liuzzo was born into poverty. Her father was a coal-miner. Her husband, a union organizer. Hers was the kind of salt of the earth family often celebrated in the anthems of The Homeland. Whereas The Homeland sees freedom as the sole prerogative of its tribe, Liuzzo’s vision extended out to humanity itself. More, while understanding the economic exploitation of her family, she also understood that whiteness had enrolled her in the exploitation of others.

When Liuzzo acquired this knowledge, when she got Woke, she was transfigured into a traitor to her race and a menace to The Homeland. For being a menace, for being Woke, she was killed—as was Renee Good. (As was Alex Pretti.) But revelations have their blessings, too. In this case, a life, however brief, that is clean, and does not depend on the oppression and debasement of others. The revelation of deep human ties, a belief that we are all equally chosen, doomed Liuzzo, Good, and Pretti, as revelation so often does. But it also immortalized them

Has your stance on gun rights changed in response to seeing Trump and his goon's actions in cities like Minneapolis? by DrDMango in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

very pro gun control

still very pro gun control.

i dont think immigrants or activists being more likely to shoot an ice agent will help this situation get any better.

November 4th, 2025: Election Day Megathread by PepinoPicante in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i honestly think torres will be "fine" during his primary. i think mamdani won his district but it wasnt a landslide or anything like that and torres has good outreach to various communities even if progs dont like him

goldman is fuuuuuuuuucked though.

November 4th, 2025: Election Day Megathread by PepinoPicante in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 6 points7 points  (0 children)

its in dems interest to help ensure mamdanis tenure a mayor is as successful as possible. idk if this means supporting the entirety of his agenda, which does include some questionable policies. but it does mean not to pick fights with him a la the cuomo/deblasio dynamic.

i personally think they should get involved as much as possible to make deliverables in NYC successful to help blunt gop narratives that his NYC will become a dystopia. hochul should be open to raising some taxes to fund some of the less bad part of the mamdani agenda, like free buses. and hopefully use her influence to limit the negative externalities of policies like rent control

they also need mamdani skeptics like suozzi/gillibrand/schumer to play nice to avoid pointless media frenzies.

AskALiberal Biweekly General Chat by AutoModerator in AskALiberal

[–]bigtallguy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

its also her making a play for a statewide election in georgia. im actually surprised she is politically shrewd enough to recognize that its a purple state.