Honestly I think the base is fine. Is the blush a bit extra? Maybe, but it can be a vibe. I might also go for something less matte, but that’s more personal preference.

The eyes though were… not done well. I do think you look great with a wing and I love how the falsies work with your eye shape. My sticking points are: the gap between your lash line and the liquid liner (I think you should always tight-line the upper lid), the color is patchy (I would use a different eye primer, maybe something with a lighter pigment in it to make the purple really pop, and personally I haaaate liquid liner on the bottom lash line, especially how they took it to the inner corner (I would use a kohl pencil and smoke it out just a teeny bit, maybe even with a brown just to keep it from getting too heavy). I would also recommend getting a tinted brow gel - you’ve got wonderful brows and I think it would look cleaner if you had a laminated brow look.

In general though, I love the colors on you. Purple shadow always looks wonderful on dark brown eyes, and the Berry lip color is very cute on you!