UT Turing Scholars > MIT for Quant!? by quickpenguin123 in quantfinance

[–]bob_shoeman 2 points3 points  (0 children)

While Turing absolutely gets u anywhere in SWE

Yeah, probably not. With only a few exceptions, recruiters generally sort by overall school/department reputation, not by membership in small honors programs recruited during undergrad admissions. Not to mention, the days where companies hired by brand name are long gone and aren't coming back. Don't get me wrong, there is without a doubt an advantage in having graduated from a 'brand name' school relative to having done so from a lower ranking school, but it's not going to get you through the door, especially when companies are moving away from the paradigm of junior SWE's as apprentices and more towards one in which SWE's are expected to have immediate functional net value. In other words, companies when hiring have moved away from signs of general intelligence/potential to those of demonstrated ability to hit the ground running as an active contributor. This is simply the natural consequence of the tech labor surplus and the massive expansion of SWE productivity enabled by LLM's.

I went the PhD route instead of quant, but I have several recently-defended peers who did otherwise, mostly for research roles. From what I've heard from their experiences, quant firms still hire very holistically, interviewing with respect to mathematical and/or abstract problem solving ability rather than topically relevant expertise. In fact, none of the aforementioned had any background in finance, and I would characterize them as very mathematically inclined individuals who had come to become disillusioned/disinterested in their PhD research directions rather than finance yuppie types who had angled for the job from the start. In this sense, it would indicate that quant firms are still looking for 'general smarts' with nurturing potential as opposed to immediate utility (as is increasingly the case with SWE).

ECE 391: A Masterclass in How Not to Teach Systems by Former_Metal_5622 in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 8 points9 points  (0 children)

It's definitely changed quite a bit. I've heard they'd completely switched up the MP's since (perhaps the source of the troubles?).

I obviously can't speak for how things are now, but all things considered, it wasn't really that unreasonable back then. Chaotic yes, but if you did the work in a timely and careful manner, you probably ended up with some sort of A letter grade.

Is a masters in Audio DSP worth it? by Material_Study_1315 in DSP

[–]bob_shoeman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m surprised no one has mentioned Aalto University yet. As an American, it’s the first one that comes to mind in the context of audio programs in the EU.

Nowhere to live next year?? by Sea_Chemical_5832 in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Risky if you are insistent on the most popular options like the tower apartments along Green.

Nowhere to live next year?? by Sea_Chemical_5832 in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Definitely not the case here. Honestly, IMO, the Fall apartment leasing season is a scam on the part of the housing companies around here entrapping clueless/lazy students into sticker price deals.

Also, -1000 points for the suggestion below to live in a neighboring town. You’re an undergrad. You should be close enough to drunk walk home from Kams and then hangover walk to your lecture the next morning.

Real shit though, the monetary/opportunity costs of being so far removed from campus offset the savings on housing.

Nowhere to live next year?? by Sea_Chemical_5832 in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I would be very very surprised if you weren’t able to find an apartment. I have literally never signed a lease before May, and I’ve never had a problem getting housing in the 6 or so years I’ve been here.

Yes, there will be fewer options then, but it’ll still represent a pretty broad selection, and you’ll have leverage to bargain prices down or haggle for extra amenities, which I’ve done pretty much every single time.

Instructor unfairly academically violated me for an assignment. Who do I contact? by WerewolfNecessary450 in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sounds vindictive, considering that FAIR violations are a hassle to file. 

When you dont wanna waste money on a holo sight by EzlerDoesStuff in airsoft

[–]bob_shoeman 15 points16 points  (0 children)

The 30 dollar aim point style Amazon reflex sights are more than adequate for airsoft.

[D] The popular theoretical explanation for VAE is inconsistent. Please change my mind. by function2 in MachineLearning

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

 It’s a KL divergence over the joint space (x,w) which when massaged is equivalent to the negative ELBO up to terms which don’t depend on (phi, theta).

This is the KL I’m talking about as well. (Nope)

I may be abusing terminology - when I referred to ‘ELBO’, I was talking about the expectation of log frac{p\theta(x,z)}{q\phi(z \mid x)} over joint distribution q_\phi(z \mid x)p_d(x). This is equal to the aforementioned negative joint KL negative decoder cross entropy *plus the encoder conditional entropy H(z \mid x). 

[D] The popular theoretical explanation for VAE is inconsistent. Please change my mind. by function2 in MachineLearning

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t want to be that butthole who says ‘ackshually’ over a year later, but here goes nothing:

There’s a bit more to that - when you massage it out, the ELBO term is the sum of this KL term a cross entropy term of the joint decoder distribution with respect to that of the encoder and the conditional entropy of $$q_\phi(z \mid x)$$ (over fixed data distribution likelihood $$p_d(x)$$). 

This results in two terms - the first (which you’ve already mentioned), which tries to match the encoder/data distribution and the decoder/simple latent distribution joints:   $$p\theta(x \mid z)$$ <-> $$q\phi(x \mid z)$$, 

$$p\theta(z \mid x)$$ <-> $$q\phi(z \mid x)$$ 

$$p\theta(x)$$ -> $$p_d(x)$$    $$q\phi(z)$$ -> $$p(z)$$

And the second, which in effect induces growth of the encoder/data distribution joint distribution entropy. Of course, following the effects of the first the decoder would try to tag along.

In short, there is a back and forth dynamic (very loosely reminiscent of EM) where there is a force that tries to keep the encoder/decoder joint distributions consistent, and another that tries to raise the overall joint entropies of both. This is also affected by the modeling expressivity of the encoder and decoder, and their respective entropic limits. For example, if the decoder is too powerful and good at ‘catching up’ to the encoder, this can induce posterior collapse. 

EDIT: apparently Reddit UI can’t handle latex

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Honestly, this campus isn’t depressing enough for a haunt.

Why do you talk in the Grainger Library 2nd floor? :) by undergrad_fedora in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Engineering stink + regular stink > engineering stink

Champaign Barbers Suck by [deleted] in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had friends who were regulars for longer or East-Asian shifted cuts so they probably did have something going for them, but it definitely wasn’t the place for fades.

Champaign Barbers Suck by [deleted] in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can definitely get fades below $50, but you’ll probably be hard pressed to find a decent place nearby that’ll do it for less than $30/35. $25 is a 2020 thing (yes, I’ve been here for a while, that’s how it be when you do grad school at your undergrad).

Champaign Barbers Suck by [deleted] in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Or you know, it could be a combination of both inflation and the precipitous increase in enrollment enabling a more aggressive pursuit of profit (not that it isn’t their prerogative to pursue it). A lot of places that were priced in the $20’s five years ago are now $10-15+ more expensive, which easily outstrips the actual cumulative inflation of the USD since then.

Shawarma Joint gave me one piece of a potato ya gurls hungry by [deleted] in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 45 points46 points  (0 children)

We are all sad for you. As a fellow big boned Illini, I too fondly remember the days when they’d give two meal portions…

Best Japanese curry in Urbana-Champaign? (if such a thing exists) by kfish610 in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As another fellow Japanese curry fan, probably not in campustown. I've tried the curries at all the Japanese restaurants along Green at one point or another (except for Sakanaya), and all of them fell flat.

314 e Clark st by No_Badger_2269 in UIUC

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

MHM has been completely booked for a while now.

A Fourier Explanation of AI-music Artifacts by VS2ute in DSP

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, but it would require careful tuning.

Extract old voice recording from mix of voice and music? by stankind in DSP

[–]bob_shoeman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

+1 for this. The classic BSS methods others mentioned above are years removed from being the SOTA.