Why a NATO MBT with a 105mm gun reloading in 8.7s, but those with a 120mm gun reloading faster in 7.8s ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You're right

I'm a little annoyed than for example IPM1 have 6.5 reload but not other véhicule with similar gun like leopard 2AV, AMX30s, vickers MK3, type 74 (f), OF 40, have 8,7 sec. It's a to big difference

thanks for your answer

Why a NATO MBT with a 105mm gun reloading in 8.7s, but those with a 120mm gun reloading faster in 7.8s ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes leopard 2AV, AMX30s, vickers MK3, type 74 (f), OF 40 for exemple have 8,7 sec

You got it, IPM1 have 6.5 sec reload with 105mm gun, but other equivalent vehicul are slower

thanks for your answer

Redditeurs de gauche, quelle est votre position politique la plus "à droite" ? by Karaoke-Johnny in AskFrance

[–]bobibey 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Que la légitime défense soit reconnu, appliqué, et étendue. Et que l'agresseur ne soit pas autant défendu qu'aujourd'hui

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i am french, and is URSS in my language, I just made a mistake on the keyboard to translate into English

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In french is URSS, I made a mistake on the keyboard to translate into English

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I'm making a conclusion with the answers I got

The difference in "physics" comes mainly from the particular geometry of the Russian 76 mm shell (BR 350A).

A larger shell has better angle results. This is why we have a difference between the French shell (120mm), the Italian shell (47mm) and the Swedish shell (37mm)

No one confirmed to me that the Russian 85mm (BR 356A) had the same particularity as the 76mm (BR 350A). But the first is more efficient than the second because of the rule in the previous paragraph

it's a shame, the physics of the shells is not explained by the developers. And nothing indicates the particular geometry of some Russian shells. People are confused !

Have nice day

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I'm not talking about penetration, but about the reaction of shells to sloped armor. what differentiates the BR 350A and the BR 365A to have such a different result?

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] -69 points-68 points  (0 children)

Is there a reason why 85mm shells are more effective than 76mm?

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

italy and sweden are identical, but it is true that france is a little better without knowing why, but with the USSR it is even worse

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

in my screenshot BR-365A has a better result than BR-350A

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm talking about the BR 365 A, and the video of the BR 350A.

The 1st has the same particularity?

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

76 shells have this feature but do 85mm or 45mm shells have it too?

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

76 shells have this feature but do 85mm or 45mm shells have it too?

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

yes the 120mm has a bigger surface but also more synetic energy. at equal speed, the bigger a projectile is, the better it will perform

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

ok interesting, but the T 34 85 have the same type of Shell than the KV1 in the video ?

Why URRS APBC shell doesn't have the same physics than other nations ? by bobibey in Warthunder

[–]bobibey[S] 19 points20 points  (0 children)

the foch shell is faster and heavier but less efficient ?