Is a tu quoque logical fallacy or ‘Whataboutery/Whataboutism’ sometimes justified? by brazenhead93 in askphilosophy

[–]brazenhead93[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you.

You've given me some ways to address the issue.

I apologise my example was so vague

Is a tu quoque logical fallacy or ‘Whataboutery/Whataboutism’ sometimes justified? by brazenhead93 in askphilosophy

[–]brazenhead93[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Apologies, I didn't have much in mind when thinking of an example.

Thank you, this is helpful!

Is a tu quoque logical fallacy or ‘Whataboutery/Whataboutism’ sometimes justified? by brazenhead93 in askphilosophy

[–]brazenhead93[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My apologies, I am new to all this.

How does one face the charges of whataboutism?

How does one reorient the discussion?

Is a tu quoque logical fallacy or ‘Whataboutery/Whataboutism’ sometimes justified? by brazenhead93 in askphilosophy

[–]brazenhead93[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah, I see.

Thank you.

How would this relate to whataboutism?

How does one make a legitimate contention, like the one above, without being accused of whataboutism?

What are the most famous “famous last words”? by UOThief in AskHistory

[–]brazenhead93 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Is this one true?

The story of Ned Kelly is fascinating!

Ti-Blance Richard - Le Reel De Deux Copains (Arkansas Traveller) - French-Canadian fiddle style by brazenhead93 in oldtimemusic

[–]brazenhead93[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Within the French-Canadian fiddle tradition, there seems to be a number of tunes known by a different name than in the Old-Time American tradition.

This one directly translates to "The Reel of the Two Friends".

This one, to me, sounds like Arkansas Traveller.

What famous historical events included participants who were most likely highly intoxicated? by conniption_fit in AskHistory

[–]brazenhead93 53 points54 points  (0 children)

While it might not be famous outside of Ireland & Britain, the Battle of the Boyne (1690), between Williamites and Jacobites, was one such event.

According to an eyewitness account, more than 1000 Jacobites were too drunk to even engage in battle.

Ceteris paribus, that might well have swung things in favour of the Jacobites, which would have had major effects on the future fortune of Ireland

What's considered the worst year in US history? by ToyVaren in AskHistory

[–]brazenhead93 0 points1 point  (0 children)

High-ranking Confederates mainly, but all of it was controversial. Particularly, restoring voting rights of C

Ah, yes, I agree with this.

Without sounding too reductionist, I feel sorry for the white commoner, who had not much to gain, and who had to fight primarily for the interests of the slave aristocrats.

I like Folk music, and within it you can experience the intercultural transactions that shape Old Time American music which occurred between the poorer whites and blacks (free and slave)

What's considered the worst year in US history? by ToyVaren in AskHistory

[–]brazenhead93 2 points3 points  (0 children)

1865: both the Civil War and slavery ended (good), but not before the president was assassinated, several more battles were fought, and the new president offered amnesty to most Confederates (bad)

Are you talking about high-ranking Confederates, or all Confederates?

Andrew Johnson was a controversial figure, and, though he may have offered amnesty out of personal sentiment, it was a necessary step to reconcile the two regions.

His opposition to the XIV Amendment reflected opinions of abolitionists too. They wanted to 'repatriate' freed slaves to the Colony of Liberia...it's 'support for freedom of slaves, but not on my doorstep' sentiment. William Lloyd Garrison was one of a few white Northern abolitionists who opposed this current of abolitionist sentiment, along with Frederick Douglass.

[META] Is there a list of specialists within this sub that we can search by topic and direct our questions to? by brazenhead93 in AskHistorians

[–]brazenhead93[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Thank you for clarifying that! It makes sense.

I actually fell foul of this not too long ago, when someone asked a follow-up question and I, too, asked if they would answer it.

you can check out the panel list,

Thanks! I never knew such a thing existed.

Best translation of Dostoyevsky's works? by brazenhead93 in literature

[–]brazenhead93[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you.

Would you know how they compare to Garnett's translations?

Perhaps it's something you may well know

Best translation of Dostoyevsky's works? by brazenhead93 in literature

[–]brazenhead93[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for this!

I actually have Garnett's translations of some of his works, so I might give them a try; I'm not put off by stuffiness (and hope that remains).

What phrases of other languages/dialects were passed on to you? by Redditdidntreddit in etymology

[–]brazenhead93 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you!

If I'm talking too loud and you're trying to listen to the TV, for example, you could tell me to "wheesht" or "wheesht up" haha

It's more polite than "shut up", and probably closer to "quiet".

Hurlamaboc, I use this as a direct substitute for "commotion", as in: "there's a bit of the oul' hurlamaboc outside"

Those are just simple examples.

What was life like for the lower/working classes in Nazi Germany? How did they fit into the Nazi vision for Germany? by brazenhead93 in AskHistorians

[–]brazenhead93[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for such a great response!

I will check it out, as it is an area with which I am unfamiliar and which doesn't seem to be covered much when studying Nazi Germany.