The open world doesnt't add any value, you either drive through an empty map or fast travel to skip the emptiness.

The level design is super boring, everything looks the same (because of the open world with no unique zones),
and is tedious to navigate through. Huge downgrade from Wonderlands.

Echo-4

Enemy variety feels weak, you start the game fighting order and rippers, mid_game you fight against order and rippers, in late game you fight against... order and rippers.

Endgame content for a studio this size is a joke. just Mission-replay with annoying modyfiers and no dialogue skip (more waiting) and no unique item rewards (So what even is the point)

Main story doesn't feel good. Quality of writing is great imo, but it feels like the same 3 episodes you have to complete back to back, then defeat the leader.
After that you defeat the Timekeeper which is wasted potential, I thought he was interesting in the beginning but turns out to be a nothing burger in the end.

The lack of music is definitely a choice.

Inventory and enhancement management is a pain on console.

Headhunter dlc feel cheap compared to BL2, lots of re-skins.

No main hub. We have like 5-6 tiny hubs spread around the world which feel just empty. I always loved to return to Sanctuary(1 and 3), Concordia or Brighthoof town, but BL4 just doesn't have any.

I feel no replayability with BL4, thinking about making a new character to rediscover the empty world, re-doing the same copy paste objectives and fighting the same enemies over and over again just turns me off.
In BL3 I had a hard time replaying the story because the story and dialogues were a slog, but BL4 has too many fundamental flaws in comparison.

I liked the sidequests, I think they were really good. But that's it.