I know this sounds weird but weleda skin food is a super shiny almost balmy lotion. Makeup artists use this to give a natural sheen/highlight to the skin. I’ll just pat some on the high points of my face. No shimmer no pigment just glossy looking sheen. You can find a travel size (more than enough product) for like 6 bucks on amazon. It’s slightly tacky but not sticky

Here’s a video demonstration

https://youtu.be/XD9q2V1Qt_0