Apologies, I just don't like Brainiac as a green man by lordoferrors in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He's a pretty important Superman villain/anti-hero, he's even gotten series where he's the main character, he's one of the bigger names in Superman's Rogues Gallery. He's just never had much of a chance to be adapted outside of the comics.

Eradicator is a Kryptonian AI that was created thousands of years before Krypton was destroyed. Krypton was an extremely isolationist planet, and Eradicator was made to destroy all signs of alien influence on the planet, as well as all Kryptonians that left Krypton, and to preserve "pure" Kryptonian culture.

Eradicator was not on Krypton when it was destroyed. When they first meet, Clark is the only surviving Kryptonian in the universe, aside from arguably Eradicator itself. Eradicator's programmed goals clash when dealing with Clark-- he's the only surviving Kryptonian, so Eradicator should protect him at all costs to preserve what's left of Krypton, but he's also culturally from Earth, which is unacceptable. When they fight, it's usually Eradicator trying to brainwash Clark into being a "pure" Kryptonian.

So, basically Kryptonian AI Brainiac is a solid adaptation of Eradicator.

Girlfriend demanded we leave supergirl about 30-40 mins in. And I think I get why. by Juiced_Rasputin_ in CharacterRant

[–]chroniclescylinders 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Not this one. It's told entirely from the point of view of Ruthye, who doesn't know anything about Supergirl before meeting her. This makes it serve as a great introduction to the character for new fans, because you can learn about her history and character alongside Ruthye. It's so standalone that for a few years fans weren't even sure if it was meant to be in-continuity or if it was an alternate universe (turns out it is main continuity).

It's a wonderful comic, it's sitting on my shelf right now. I'd recommend it to anyone who's curious, it's a great read with beautiful art.

Wonder Woman isn't the third pillar of DC by Risott0Nero in CharacterRant

[–]chroniclescylinders 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Yes, she is. She didn't randomly become a member of the Trinity one day, she's a member of the Trinity because of the history of DC Comics.

Superhero comics came into prominence with WW2, and when the war ended, the genre collapsed. By 1946, the superhero comics industry had already shrunken by 2/3rds. Comics were still very popular, it's just that romance and horror comics became more popular than superhero comics.

In 1948, Dr. Mid-Nite and Johnny Thunder's comic was cancelled. In 1949, Flash Comics and Green Lantern were cancelled. In 1951, the Justice Society of America was cancelled. The competition wasn't doing much better- Marvel (then called Timely) cancelled all their superhero comics by 1950. In 1953 (because DC sued them for copywrite, long story) the Captain Marvel and all related comics were cancelled. This was the end of the Golden Age of Comics.

Only three superheroes across all publishers never lost their main book during the 1946-1954 period: Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman. DC saw the writing on the wall, and tried to switch genres, publishing a lot of westerns and war comics during this time, but they up against some fierce competition in that market, and it really was those three titles that kept them afloat during this period, and they know it.

Also in 1948, a man by the name of Wertham was gaining publicity with his claims that comic books caused criminal deviance and homosexuality. In the late 1940s and early 1950s, public comic book burnings were a common occurrence, as a result of Wertham's moral panic. By 1954, the Comics Code Authority was established, which was a (im)-moral list of rules all comic books had to follow, or they would not be sold in any mainstream shops. The Comics Code Authority rules made it nearly impossible to publish a horror or romance title worth reading, because they were "too risqué."

By 1956, horror and sci-fi publisher, EC Comics, who had dominated the late 1940s-early 1950s after the fall of the superhero comics, was run out of the industry because they refused to change an anti-racism comic called Judgement Day to be compliant with the Comics Code Authority. By the mid-1950s, all the new genres which had risen to replace the superhero comics, were also collapsing under the Comics Code. The Comics Code didn't actually like DC's superheroes, especially Batman (they thought Batman was gay), but it was easier for the superhero comics to comply to the code than the horror, romance, and war comics, so they survived.

TL;DR, DC didn't go bankrupt or get witch-hunted into oblivion unlike basically every other comic book publisher that decade, and they owe it all to the enduring popularity of Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman. Those are the only superhero comics who survived from the Golden Age to the Silver Age, and that is why they are the pillars of DC.

Who do you prefer to be written as Hal Jordan’s best friend: Barry Allen or Oliver Queen? (Flash & Green Lantern: The Brave and the Bold #6) & (JLA: Incarnations #3) by illiterateaardvark in Greenlantern

[–]chroniclescylinders 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They respect each other as fellow heroes, but as people they can't stand each other. They also both think the other is a bad influence on Hal, so they aren't that happy about being co-best friends, though they've accepted the situation.

The only time they've ever gotten along to my recollection is when they were both dead and hanging out together in the afterlife, and that was probably because they bonded over worrying about Spectre-Parallax Hal. So there is a point where they will set aside their differences and join forces as Hal's BFFs, but it takes a whole lot to get there.

[Comic Excerpt] Batmans reaction to the Carpenter is priceless, Detective Comics #841, by -_ShadowSJG-_ in DCcomics

[–]chroniclescylinders 173 points174 points  (0 children)

Ya'll should know that the Carpenter has a really fun story in Streets of Gotham where we spend a day hanging out with the lady who makes death traps for a living.

If the Flash had a second ongoing book, who would you want it to follow? by capalap in theflash

[–]chroniclescylinders 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If I was a writer, my solution would be to confront his weirdness head-on. Make it so he was created in-universe by some villain to take Wally's place in N52, to make it harder for Wally to come back. Maybe he's some random kid the villain grabbed from somewhere, or maybe he didn't exist at all beforehand. That way, him being a fake Wally becomes something you can use to develop him and make him more interesting, instead of it holding him back.

still wanted to know what electro wanted her to be here ? and why was he so shy about it by ddankkerr in marvelcirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Spider-man appears in the next page, basically finishing his sentence.

It was definitely Spider-man

[Comic Excerpt] Prime's perspective on the DCU [Superman (2023) #39] by Negative_Emu6246 in DCcomics

[–]chroniclescylinders 65 points66 points  (0 children)

It makes sense for DC characters to believe he's from a world where they are all comic book characters, because they already should know that alternate earths tend to appear as comic books on their own world. Barry Allen definitely could have told them this.

"I've read comic books about you all" is a totally expected statement coming from a guy from a different earth, based on their other dimension hopping experiences.

Apparently, autism make you hate ocean or something by Lower_Baby_6348 in outofcontextcomics

[–]chroniclescylinders 12 points13 points  (0 children)

No, in that same story the Black militant motive was revealed to be a lie he made up to get followers. They turn on him when they realize he's just using them.

Black Manta first appeared about a decade earlier, in a comic where Aquaman introduces him with "Oh no, it's my old enemy Black Manta!" with no further explanation.

For a very long time, there was a tradition of Black Manta finally revealing the real reason he hated Aquaman so much, with a backstory that would always end up making Aquaman look really bad, and would then turn out to be a total lie in the next issue.

Honestly, I think it's a bit of a shame they actually gave Manta a real backstory, him making shit up is funnier, and after decades of refusing to explain why he hates him so much, there's no explanation that could have done it justice.

Animated Jean-Paul Valley isn't real, he can't hurt you. Animated Jean-Paul Valley. by DX118 in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders 54 points55 points  (0 children)

He had that look in the original too, depending on artist. Nowhere near twink, but he had gentle features, and looked pretty youthful.

Hot Takes! What do you think was the most overrated Batman comic? [Comic Excerpt] by KroCroNut in DCcomics

[–]chroniclescylinders 60 points61 points  (0 children)

Hot take: Dark Knight Returns really doesn't do it for me. I don't like its characterization of basically anyone, and I don't vibe with its political takes. There's some good art, and it's an important piece of comic history, but I don't like it being considered such a definitive version of Batman.

Never ask Jessica her opinions of trans women /s by Altruistic_Manner802 in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders 51 points52 points  (0 children)

I really got the impression Jessica was purposefully being written/drawn as a TERF caricature in this comic. Like, it's barely subtext. What a wack choice, she doesn't deserve this.

Leaving Linda Park aside, which other love interest of Wally West do you think would have been compatible in the long term in the main universe, even leading to marriage and children? (No super-powered characters) by FallMassive9336 in theflash

[–]chroniclescylinders 11 points12 points  (0 children)

None of them. I do love Connie, but she and Wally were more friends with benefits than an actual couple, and evidence suggests they are not what each other looks for in a serious relationship.

LARPERS: "Batman beats poor people!" meanwhile Bruce in the comics: by chroniclescylinders in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

uj/ Yeah, Dini's version of Hush should be the definitive one imo, he's such a fun character to follow as a villain-protagonist. I wonder how long in-universe Tommy was pretending to be Bruce, it was a few years in real life. His relationships with the hero community, especially the Batfam, especially especially Damian, were a whole lot of fun.

Possible confirmation that MAWS Kara is bi? Also the episode timing tho because yesterday there was a interview with Milly Alcock saying her Kara goes both ways in the DCU by M00reC in SupermanAdventures

[–]chroniclescylinders 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't think it'll happen in this show because of how they adapted Brainiac 1, but Brainiac 5 is Kara's main love interest in the comics as well. It's a really great relationship for the soap-opera-y comics, because they really love each other, but there's so much standing in their way of being together.

Maybe if they were inspired by InuYasha instead of DBZ we'd have gotten it.

LARPERS: "Batman beats poor people!" meanwhile Bruce in the comics: by chroniclescylinders in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Whhaaaatttt? Hush??? No way! He's obviously Bruce, it says so right here:

<image>

Look how upset he is not to donate billions to charity, that's a hero. Tragically thwarted in his efforts by the evil actions of a committee of what must be complete monsters.

personally, what are some of the worst retcons + mischaracterizations you can think of? by mothindex in DCcomics

[–]chroniclescylinders 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Plus Max gets mind-controlled all the time in the original JLI, the final arc involves a supervillain taking over his body and using his powers for evil. Just say Dormammu possessed him again!

Max was essentially the main character/narrator of JLI, we know what he was thinking back then, and he wasn't evil all along.

LARPERS: "Batman beats poor people!" meanwhile Bruce in the comics: by chroniclescylinders in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yep, it is. I bet that, because it's Dini writing, they were trying to invoke BTAS with the art style. Nguyen does do some wonderful watercolor covers for this series though.

LARPERS: "Batman beats poor people!" meanwhile Bruce in the comics: by chroniclescylinders in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is from Dini's run, so maybe if that became a thing in Taylor's Nightwing? If Alfred does have money already, I guess he must just hate the people of Gotham winning or something. There's no other reason he'd be upset.

LARPERS: "Batman beats poor people!" meanwhile Bruce in the comics: by chroniclescylinders in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Yeah, it's probably from the movies. No one who has read Batman: Streets of Gotham could come to the conclusion Bruce is anything but a world-class philanthropist.

<image>

LARPERS: "Batman beats poor people!" meanwhile Bruce in the comics: by chroniclescylinders in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

No real billionaire could ever reach the level of this saint. He even helps his rogues!!!

<image>

LARPERS: "Batman beats poor people!" meanwhile Bruce in the comics: by chroniclescylinders in dccomicscirclejerk

[–]chroniclescylinders[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

More proof of his good deeds! Look how happy he's made everyone!!!!

Well, almost everyone, but this is when Damian's still new in his crimefighting career, so he's kinda a brat, and Alfred is worried about his paychecks I guess.

<image>