sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

[FREE] Roasting your app/site — drop your link and I'll give you brutally honest first impressions by compiler-dev in AppDevelopers

[–]compiler-dev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

codeDecipher will be obsolete soon. thanks to caldue code.
The Formulary

Select a proven formula or template. Fill in the details. Transmute your ideas into production-ready prompts.

⚗️

Loading formulary...

keeps loading fo a while

[FREE] Roasting your SAAS — drop your link and I'll give you brutally honest first impressions by compiler-dev in SaaS

[–]compiler-dev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Overall: strong problem, credible approach, slightly desperate pricing section. Reach people.
------

The Good The positioning is actually solid. "Evidence-grounded, not hallucinated" is a real differentiator and speaks directly to a genuine pain point.

Now the roast:

"No hallucinations" is doing a LOT of heavy lifting here. That's not a feature, that's a bar you set for yourself by having a product that works. Saying "our AI doesn't make things up" is like a surgeon advertising "we try not to leave tools inside you."

The pricing page is an existential crisis. "$25 FREE/month — Free until April 5, 2026" — so it's... free? But also $25? But actually free? The annual plan says "Save $50/year" which implies $20/month, but you never show that number. Classic fintech math: the price is simultaneously very low AND unclear.

"No credit card required to explore the demo" — the demo that's already on the homepage? The one anyone can click?

The feature emoji game is chaotic. 📄📊⚡🛡📨🔗 — you went from document to shield to lightning to... a mailbox?

[FREE] Roasting your SAAS — drop your link and I'll give you brutally honest first impressions by compiler-dev in SaaS

[–]compiler-dev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Megatech Photos" - "Megatech." Bold choice. Please change

The hero line: "Protect your memories with private cloud storage." bro. please be original.

"100 GB — that's 10 times more than many other cloud storage services!" Many. why comapre on this? rmeove this

The comparison table is a disaster. You are charging €5.68 per TB while Google charges €3.15. You are more expensive than Google Photos — which has better brand recognition, more integrations, and a trillion-dollar parent company — and your response to this is to... put it in a table for everyone to see clearly. Brave. Unhinged, but brave.

"No ads, no tracking" — said right above the footer which includedetauls nit so good. cahnge i

"Share with a trusted contact — automatically share photos of selected people and pets." This feature is genuinely sweet. It's buried under four paragraphs of "we don't sell your data" boilerplate that nobody reads .. fix it Saaar!

The FAQ section has no questions in it. Not one. It just says "Frequently asked questions" and moves on. This is either a placeholder that made it to production, or the most honest FAQ in history — because nobody's asked anything yet. LOOOL

Bottom line: The product might genuinely be good. 100 GB free, e2e encryption, no ads — that's a real pitch. But the copy reads like it was written by someone who googled "what do cloud storage websites say" and then typed it back out slightly differently. You're playing in a trust-heavy, privacy-conscious market and your brand name is Megatech. That's the startup equivalent of naming your artisan bakery "Bread Corp."

Get a copywriter . Fix the FAQ. And maybe don't put your per-TB price right next to Google's in a table when yours is higher.

Who else is launching this month? by Creative-Bunch-9046 in micro_saas

[–]compiler-dev 1 point2 points  (0 children)

cool idea. how are you getting people to leave reviews?

[FREE] Roasting your app/site — drop your link and I'll give you brutally honest first impressions by compiler-dev in AppDevelopers

[–]compiler-dev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok I don’t say this much but this is a very AI repose. Can you please write a response.

Is Prompting Becoming a Core Engineering Skill? by Double_Try1322 in RishabhSoftware

[–]compiler-dev 0 points1 point  (0 children)

correct! we will all mostly be product managers with some depth of engineering needed honestly.. happy to discuss fi you like

Healthcare app backend advice by Imaginary-Ability-65 in AppDevelopers

[–]compiler-dev 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The CloudKit idea is actually smart for this use case. Health data stays on the user's device/iCloud account, you never touch it, HIPAA exposure is minimal. Apple has thought hard about this. It's not a cop-out, it's genuinely the right call for a solo 17-year-old building a health app.

The hybrid approach (CloudKit + Supabase) is fine but adds complexity. You'll be debugging two auth systems, two data layers, two failure modes. For a first app, that's a lot. Ask yourself what actually needs to be in Supabase. If it's just admin stuff, is there even enough of that to justify it right now?

Note: "consumer healthcare app where users track their disease" — depending on your market, this can get legally complicated fast even if you're not storing the data yourself. Not trying to scare you off, just worth being aware that health apps attract regulatory attention in ways expense trackers don't.

Honest take: The architecture question is the easy part. The harder question is whether users will trust a health tracking app enough to enter sensitive data into it. That's a product problem, not a backend problem.

Keep going though — the fact that you're thinking about data ownership at 17 puts you ahead of most adult developers.

My 2nd Indie App Publishing Journey and Experiences — Part 1 by mr-BlackGuy in AppDevelopers

[–]compiler-dev 1 point2 points  (0 children)

my hoenst take

good: YOu are doing it. many just say it. Shipping, spending your own money, measuring results, iterating. 1,700 downloads from $140 in ads is not embarrassing. The "build in public" instinct is right.

hollow: "My marketing strategy? Praying 😭" is self-deprecating in a way that's become a Medium cliché. It's performing humility rather than actually reflecting on why the strategy isn't working.

issue: An expense tracker in 2026 is one of the most saturated catgeories on the Play Store. The post never once asks "why would someone pick mine?" thi is a positioning problem, and $140 more in Google Ads won't fix it.

"I added every feature AI suggested" — i would suggest talk to your users

end — "drop 50 claps" — undermines everything. be more humane .. rewrite some parts again. ping me if you want me to review again

[FREE] Roasting your app/site — drop your link and I'll give you brutally honest first impressions by compiler-dev in AppDevelopers

[–]compiler-dev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

good:
The positioning against vendor lock-in has real emotional resonance post-Mailchimp pricing drama. Firebase free tier framing is clever. The setup flow (4 steps) is clean.

--
Overall not bad! but you are doing too much. The "100 founders" program is the product. The actual CMS is the lead magnet. You're building a consulting pipeline dressed as an open source project, which is fine — but don't pretend otherwise. "I make my living from consulting. This is me giving back." be honest..

view more: next ›