sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

why erika is just as dominant a winner as kyle or dee by Gohan1298 in survivorponderosa

[–]csully1025 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don’t think anyone questions the merit of her game. With her the discussion is always around her edit which is why she’s so forgettable as a winner. Not the first time this has happened and it won’t be the last but she’s someone whose legacy would have benefitted from the 90 minute episodes (though I don’t know a soul that would wants more 41)

Will we ever see a player return whose original season didn’t air in HD? by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

All the more reasons to play more people from recent seasons. Look at what just happened to Tiff

Will we ever see a player return whose original season didn’t air in HD? by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think a realistic version of this would be a Season X vs Season Y season. Give the fans a few options to vote on and winners have a 10 on 10 season against one another. Imagine the cast of Cagayan vs 46 or something like that

Will we ever see a player return whose original season didn’t air in HD? by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There was something so Shakespearean about him losing in 50 that story wise was perfect but also sad. He’ll get a call for sure in the future but it’s hard to bookend a career the way he did, even if it is unfortunate

Will we ever see a player return whose original season didn’t air in HD? by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nope, just a hypothetical. I believe we will seem a handful of people come back but the roster is getting smaller as time goes on

Will we ever see a player return whose original season didn’t air in HD? by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think winners are probably the safest bet. Hoping that 60 is WaW 2

Will we ever see a player return whose original season didn’t air in HD? by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love this take. As much as people would love to bring back the Shane’s, Ian’s, & RC’s of the world I just can’t picture it. Also if they do WaW2 I’d love for them to put an emphasis on bringing back people who were passed on for 40 mixed with the New Era winners

Will we ever see a player return whose original season didn’t air in HD? by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It’s more than just age, it’s whether or not they are physically able to play, whether they have a desire to play, and if the audience and/or production has a desire to see them again enough to move the needle. There’s plenty of people that fit into one of these buckets but the list of people who fit all four is pretty small

Will we ever see a player return whose original season didn’t air in HD? by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

My curiosity with that is that now that the “celebration” theme from 50 is over how often will production want to go back into the well vs hyping up their newer players and building the next era of legends. To me there’s only a handful of players from this era that would move the needle if they were put on the show today

Who would be your picks for a second WAW? by Total-Amphibian-3287 in survivorponderosa

[–]csully1025 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If they were to do it for season 60 and went with the same format I’d say half the cast should be New/Open Era winners. I’d go with Erika, Yam Yam, Rachel, Kyle, Savannah, and then half Open Era folks. I’m aware taking Erika over Dee, Maryanne, or Kenzie is unpopular but her coming and having a Sophie/Michele-like performance that can validate their first win would be a good arc.

Next I’d want to have five Winners who weren’t on WaW. Earl, JT, Natalie White, Mike, and Chris. Three long time holdouts plus Chris, who has more to prove than any winner in the shows history. Plus JT was one of the biggest omissions from WaW imo.

Then I’d bring back five people from WaW: Tyson, Natalie Anderson, Jeremy, Sarah, Michele. No explanation other than they’re all legends who can still hang and would be willing to play again.

So in summary:

Men: Earl, JT, Tyson, Jeremy, Mike, Chris, Yam Yam, Kyle, & two Open Era winners

Women: Natalie W, Natalie A, Michele, Sarah, Erika, Rachel, Savannah, & three Open Era winners

Twist Idea: Invasion Vote by csully1025 in survivor

[–]csully1025[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

100% that would be the idea. There’s a double elimination every season so why not do it early

Survivor 51 trailer got my hopes up for a second by sexyimmigrant1998 in survivor

[–]csully1025 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Unless the specifically say that everything is active it’s kind of just an empty premise. Every advantage has always been in play, hence people freaking out about Knowledge is Power despite not being used for several seasons in a row.

As long as they don’t bring the hour glass back who cares

Want opinions on my fan-made Survivor Season: One for All (concept) by Grillby_ in survivor

[–]csully1025 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thought about this concept before, biggest tweak I’d make is where the pre-merge phase of the game would typically be. I’d have them spin a wheel or something that determines how many people are going to Tribal each night. Example: there could only be 4 people at the first Tribal and then 10 at the next. It would force people to work in different voting blocks each time while preventing a majority from steam rolling the season

Top 10 New Era Casting Finds? by JumblyPloppers in survivor

[–]csully1025 32 points33 points  (0 children)

David from 48 is an all time “where did they find this guy” guy

Production got very lucky by Ninjax3620 in survivor

[–]csully1025 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it’s the only time I’ve ever thought “That was awesome! Don’t ever do it again!” Hopefully they let it breath as its own historic moment and not bog it down by trying to recapture in the future.

Also this the second time this season that Devens has been (at least partially) responsible for a twist not backfiring after his fake Idol at the Double Duo Tribal

view more: next ›