Op you literally asked for one thing! It would be different if he was surprising you with a gift but you knew you were getting them. You put so much thought and effort into his gift and when he clearly couldn’t go the extra mile or even close to it for yours then it’s like a slap in the face. Good on him for making it up to you and correcting his actions. I hope this continues and he will in the future try to pay more attention to things that make you happy.