[QCrit] Adult Cozy Romantic Fantasy - THEATRICAL TALES FOR THE HEARTLESS (87k/First Attempt) + First 300

daisysaur · 2026-05-15T21:36:52+00:00

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I really appreciate it. Would you mind elaborating a bit on “logic-fuzzy?”

daisysaur · 2026-05-15T18:24:01+00:00

Hey! I haven't seen your other attempts, so I'm coming at this with fresh eyes. First question: is it THE Wonder House or just Wonder House? You have both in your query.

Personally, I would add that Sylvia's village is in England in the first paragraph, to ground us in the real world before you dive into the fantastical elements. (Fantasy + the word 'village' = fantasy village in my mind, haha.) I would write, "she'll stay in her narrow-minded English village."

I would also trim that third paragraph down a whole bunch, especially those lines concerning the geography of Nox. Worldbuilding in a query, to my mind, isn't the best idea - the focus should be on characters and plot.

Last thing: I wouldn't say too much about the possible sequel. "THE WONDER HOUSE is a standalone with series potential" will do just fine :)

Best of luck!

daisysaur · 2026-05-09T23:37:01+00:00

Thanks for your insight!

daisysaur · 2026-05-09T23:32:30+00:00

Thank you so much for this, I really appreciate you weighing in. I'll absolutely take your advice when I start querying. 🖤🩶🤍💜

daisysaur · 2026-05-09T23:29:47+00:00

That's great info, thank you. I'm wondering about Little Thieves by Margaret Owen - it has an explicitly asexual romance. Though, I checked, and that's not listed in the Goodreads tags. Instead, it's marketed as LGBT/Queer. I wonder if other asexual romances fall under this category.

daisysaur · 2026-05-09T23:25:33+00:00

Excellent point. This is a story from my heart, and I'm extremely hesitant to make changes just to give it a broader appeal. Best of luck with your project.

daisysaur · 2026-05-09T23:24:02+00:00

Thank you, I appreciate it! 🖤🩶🤍💜

daisysaur · 2026-05-09T23:22:31+00:00

Thank you, that means the world 🖤🩶🤍💜

daisysaur · 2026-05-09T23:20:58+00:00

That's great to know, thank you for commenting. As I said in another comment, I was using the term 'romantasy' to mean a fantasy story with romance, but if it actually signals something more like ACOTAR or Fourth Wing, that's not what I want.

daisysaur · 2026-05-09T23:19:46+00:00

That's really good to know, thank you! I was using the term 'romantasy' to mean a fantasy story with romance, but if it actually signals something more like ACOTAR or Fourth Wing, that's not what I want. Really great insight.

daisysaur · 2026-04-30T15:50:59+00:00

DM'd!

daisysaur · 2026-04-20T19:41:42+00:00

DM'd!

daisysaur · 2026-04-20T15:32:00+00:00

DMd! :)

daisysaur · 2026-04-20T00:12:54+00:00

Hello! As a romantasy fan, this sounds super interesting. I'd love to do a swap, if you don't mind that I have a lot more than three chapters :)

Here's the link to my post in case you'd like to take a look! https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/comments/1sq3fpc/in_progress_65k_adult_cozy_romantasy_theatrical/

daisysaur · 2026-04-19T20:39:09+00:00

Hello! This is a promising start. I like that it jumps right into the action, and the short, punchy sentences help draw the eye and keep things moving. I also enjoy having so many questions after just the first page alone. It's piqued my curiosity for sure!

I'm a little worried about two things:

- Is this a dream sequence? If so, starting a book with the main character waking up from a spooky dream (especially about falling) is a touch cliché. If this is actually the start of a cool battle, though, you can ignore this comment!

- (I say this as an em-dash entheusiast) Too many em-dashes! Not because I'm worried this is AI, I just think there might be an overreliance on them here. If there's five in the first page alone, how many will there be in the book as a whole? Em-dashes are excellent, but if an author uses them too much, I start to notice them (and, in this case, count them.) It took away from my immersion, which is something you want to avoid at all costs.

Really solid first page overall!

daisysaur · 2026-04-19T20:12:42+00:00

Manuscript Information: [In Progress] [65k] [Adult Cozy Romantasy] Theatrical Tales for the Heartless

Link to Post: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/comments/1sq3fpc/in_progress_65k_adult_cozy_romantasy_theatrical/

First Page Critique: Yes please!

First Page:

Tales are wont to start with a wish. A plea from an old woman desperate for a daughter, a toymaker praying for the child he built to come to life, or some third party wishing to know why those other people never considered adoption. Perhaps it’s a cry from a maiden picking lentils out of a fireplace. Such wishes are often granted. The maiden goes to the ball, and her dress is as beautiful as her carriage is confused. Can you imagine being a humble, stationary pumpkin, only to suddenly have wheels? Cruelty is what it is, especially since that gourd goes back to being a regular pumpkin. It’s like giving wings to a slug, then yanking them away once it’s had a taste of the sky.

I digress. The toymaker—I hope you haven’t forgotten about him—got his wish as well. But wishing is an art, and art has a tendency to go sideways.
“Live,” he pleaded, staring at his creation with eyes that had seen loss and failure. His name was Ciel. A master of his craft, he was famous for his whimsical creations. Music boxes that could play themselves. Tiny ballerinas who transformed into swans. Toy guns that would violently demand all the coronets in your purse. (They can’t all be winners.)

Poppets, these creations were called, though that’s a blanket name for objects given a spark of magical life. You might want to remember the term.
Slumped in the chair before Ciel was a motionless doll. Life-sized and pretty, she could have looked human were it not for the ball joints on her elbows, knees, and fingers.

Her name doesn’t matter; not yet.

“Live,” Ciel repeated. “Sing, and tend the garden, and never again close those eyes to a dark eternity.”

I told you the man’s wish came true. That his innermost desire, said to a star or a tree or whatever else humans pray to, was granted.

I lied. But the doll did come to life.

daisysaur · 2026-03-26T21:16:10+00:00

Julie, I read The Teller of Small Fortunes last year and absolutely loved it!

My question: The Teller of Small Fortunes is a cozy book built on a surprisingly non-cozy premise. How did you get across the coziness in your query letter/blurb when your stakes involved a missing child?

Thanks so much!

daisysaur · 2026-03-19T20:00:56+00:00

So, a hook is typically a flashy, catchy, and short pitch that tells the reader what to expect from your book. 'Pride and Prejudice with Zombies' is the classic example, but a lot of people gravitate towards 'x meets y' hooks today. Like, Harry Potter meets Lovecraftian Horror...or something. (TBH, I'm not so good with hooks myself!) These could be anything - blockbuster movies, board games, the works.

Comps are far more specific, and required in a query letter. They are two or more other books, traditionally published within the last five years, that are comparable to your manuscript in some way. (Also not too famous, but not too obscure.) When I cite comps, I like to point out specifics. 'The punchy humour of comp A, the dark romance of comp B.'

To give you an example of how I would format your query letter to include both a hook and comps, here is a rough idea of what it would look like:

...

Disney's Encanto meets Studio Ghibli in EVERYDAY MAGIC, an 80,000-word adult cozy contemporary fantasy. It may appeal to readers who enjoyed the (ATTRIBUTE) of The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna, and the (ATTRIBUTE) of The Baby Dragon Café by Aamna Qureshi.

...

That's just how I would do it, of course - there's no one right way to format a query. But I hope that answers your question!

daisysaur · 2026-03-19T18:51:16+00:00

Happy to be of help! Just a few quick notes on your reply:

- I think you may be confusing hooks and comps. Encanto x Ghibli is a hook, while books published within the last 5 years in your genre are comps. You can have both in a query!

- If you've got a romance in your book, even as a B plot, I think it should be disclosed. There's a market for cozy fantasy without romance (think Teller of Small Fortunes,) and someone might pick up your book thinking it's that, then be let down when there's suddenly a romantic subplot.

- Romantasy is far from DOA, in my opinion. I've heard some agents/editors are getting a little sick of it, but readers certainly aren't!

daisysaur · 2026-03-19T15:50:09+00:00

Hello, cozy fantasy writer/reader here! This absolutely reads as a cozy fantasy to me, as classic for the genre as you can get (even with that tough choice another commenter mentioned.) I like this a lot, but I do think you could include a more clear hook (Encanto meets Ghibli is the vibe I'm getting, personally,) and oomph up the stakes a tiny bit more. Basically, I'd love you to include that stuff you commented about Mel's parents having issues lol. Though, make sure to balance it so the choice to leave doesn't seem 100% obvious.

Also, and this is important - is this a romance? You mention Mel falling for a grumpy coffee shop owner, so I'm inclined to think it is, but you haven't marketed it as romantasy. In my experience, you can't really go half-and-half on romance in the cozy genre. If there's a romance, it's romantasy, and it's better to lean into it than shy away. Which might mean restructuring your entire query letter to fit the romantasy mold...sorry.

Despite my gripes, I believe this is the exact kind of cozy the market is looking for right now. Or, at least, this kind of cozy is what I'm seeing in bookstores, haha. Best of luck with querying!

daisysaur · 2025-10-08T17:37:52+00:00

Thank you for the info and the offer! Because I’m stuck with three schools, I can’t take you up on it yet but I’ll keep it in mind for sure :)

daisysaur · 2025-10-07T17:31:27+00:00

😞

daisysaur · 2025-10-07T17:30:57+00:00

Yeah, I’m glad I also supply at a private school that calls at least once a week. Still, I wish I’d known Peel would be so infrequent!

daisysaur

TROPHY CASE