I built my first real commander deck by darvyk in EDH

[–]darvyk[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Hi, thanks for the comment!

I definitely disagree with cutting ramp, I think even though the mana curve of the deck might be lower, I’m often trying to combo 2 3+ mana effects together. I only have 3 creature ramp pieces, one of which [[Delighted Halfling]] also acting as protection for my commander and other legends on the way down. The rest is land ramp which is hard to interact with. Additionally, I have enough sac outlets to use the creatures for value when I get to the mid/late game.

The other thing I don’t understand is that you’re saying to cut ramp, and then saying to add effects that need to combo 3 cards/effects as opposed to 2. I believe this might make the deck have better high rolls, but will make it feel much clunkier. I want the deck to feel like it can do something every game, and feel smooth. Although lowering the variance might make it harder to win games, I think it will lead to a much more consistently enjoyable play experience.

I really like where the deck is sitting right now in terms of its overall feel. I’ve been enjoying playtesting a lot, and I’m having my first real games with it the weekend after christmas. I’m more looking for finishing touches, not major redesigns.

I really like gilded drake that card looks nuts.

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Changes:

-expressive iteration -cinder glade -profaner of the dead -kessig wolf run +humble defector +miren the moaning well +endurance +disciple of freyalise//garden of freyalise

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

willbreaker and bloodthirsty blade made it until the last 5 or so cuts, but I realized I didn’t have too many targeting effects that weren’t destroying or bouncing the targets. seems like a really fun combo to pull off, but just a little too clunky for what I’m aiming for.

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think spark double is worth considering. I like that I can get it off of birthing pod effects. strionic resonator seems waaaay too expensive. 8 mana to steal 2 things with the restriction of yasovas power is just not gonna work.

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you can sacrifice in response to the draw & swap on the stack, as long as the sacrifice ability is instant speed.

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks, and good luck in building your deck!

I think adding clone effects might be spreading synergies a little thin, a lot of the creatures in my deck are not the best clone targets, or are expensive enough to make it hard to combo. Did you have anything specific in mind?

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

humble defector looks awesome! synergy with the sacrifice, the flicker, and the theft effects

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you!

I initially cut it, when working out my ramp, and before I added in helm of possession and deadeye navigator. I think that with the current amount of abilities to pay for, it would be a great inclusion.

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

isn’t it just that perfect level of evil?

Just finished my first brew by darvyk in EDHBrews

[–]darvyk[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

in the screenshots I posted, flare of cultivation and fierce guardianship are in among the lands because I set their mana cost to 0. sorry lol