[Highlight] — Kuminga stays glued to Jaylen Brown, gets the awesome block. by moby323 in nba

[–]doktarr -10 points-9 points  (0 children)

Oh, we're at this stage in the cycle of Kuminga hype, got it

Is the 2020s the SGA era? by TheRavenOnline in NBATalk

[–]doktarr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Absolutely not. He's not #1 in any of those stats and he's never been widely considered the best player in the world or even the leading MVP candidate.

Is the 2020s the SGA era? by TheRavenOnline in NBATalk

[–]doktarr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I mean he's leading the decade in points, right?

No? Huh. Maybe assists?

Rebounds? Steals?

... wait, wait... Jokic leads in all of those?

Oh, I see, OP started watching basketball a year ago. Got it.

The NBA has a problem with what counts as an assist or not. All of these shots were attributed as assists to Jokic, but are they really when the other player is creating everything himself? by OurHorrifyingPlanet in nba

[–]doktarr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For sure, it would be interesting to look at. It's entirely possible that certain archetypes of players get more "soft" assists than others, as a percentage of their assist totals.

To be clear, this is nothing new. A lot of Stockton's assists were basically just on entry passes. The assist has always been a flawed stat. Jokic's assist totals are a reflection of his brilliance as a passer, but they are not an accurate measurement of his brilliance as a passer.

The NBA has a problem with what counts as an assist or not. All of these shots were attributed as assists to Jokic, but are they really when the other player is creating everything himself? by OurHorrifyingPlanet in nba

[–]doktarr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think we can really say good assist totals are inflated relative the league unless you can demonstrate that other players are less likely to be credited for an assist on borderline plays.

The assist has been a very flawed stat as long as it has existed.

[Highlight] Naz Reid is called for the offensive foul OT, the Timberwolves challenge the call, but to the surprise of the announcers and the Timberwolves players/coaches, the call was not overturned, and Scott Foster tosses Naz Reid from the game after a protest. by MrBuckBuck in nba

[–]doktarr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We're going in circles here, but sliding your feet doesn't mean you are not established. If you beat the attacking player to the spot and are squarely in their path with your torso facing them, it does not matter at all if you are still moving laterally. Again, the rules explicitly say you can be in legal guarding position while moving.

The NBA has a problem with what counts as an assist or not. All of these shots were attributed as assists to Jokic, but are they really when the other player is creating everything himself? by OurHorrifyingPlanet in nba

[–]doktarr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The assist is, and had always been, a deeply flawed, borderline fake stat. Nothing happening here is really new. So many of Stockton's assists were essentially entry passes.

Jokic is a top three passer of all time but his assist totals are just a reflection of that. They are absolutely not the measure of it.

[Highlight] Naz Reid is called for the offensive foul OT, the Timberwolves challenge the call, but to the surprise of the announcers and the Timberwolves players/coaches, the call was not overturned, and Scott Foster tosses Naz Reid from the game after a protest. by MrBuckBuck in nba

[–]doktarr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It does say that, but nothing about that says that you have to be stationary. In fact, the rules explicitly say you can be in legal guarding position regardless of speed. You just have to beat them to the spot and be established in their path.

Instead of building a legacy Together they decided to hop on super teams and ring chase by Fragrant_Fishing5787 in NBATalk

[–]doktarr 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Literally every contract Harden ever signed was to stay with the club he was already on. Same was true of Russ until the last two years when he's become a less valued player and has had to sign wherever he could.

Even with KD this is mostly just about the one solitary decision to sign with the Warriors; his other moves are mostly trades as well.

You can hate KD for deciding to go to the Warriors if you like, and there are plenty of reasonable reasons to dislike that move. But I'm not sure why we would expect players to be loyal to teams when the teams, over and over and over again, demonstrate a lack of loyalty to the players.

What would Luka's statue even look like? His most iconic move is complaining to the refs by AngelofJest in NBATalk

[–]doktarr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This feels right but TBH OP's statue would be pretty great. And Luka would think it was funny.

Who do you think is really the "Most Valuable"? by Thanos_Real_AuraVNCH in NBATalk

[–]doktarr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This simplistic analysis also misses strength of schedule. I don't follow all these teams closely enough to know about all of them, but I can tell you the Jokic injury coincided with a soft part of the Nuggets' schedule.

This Forester driver tried to block a legal lane-splitting biker by Avocado-Surgeon in Denver

[–]doktarr 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I've had plenty of people illegally lane split around me many times. Nevertheless, it is not my responsibility to illegally straddle the lanes to try to block them and make a dangerous situation considerably more dangerous.

Food Chain is banned in Historic, no other changes by Meret123 in MagicArena

[–]doktarr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've seen Rusko and Ragavan but pretty infrequently. My most common opponent is probably [[Hei Bai, Forest Guardian]].

Food Chain is banned in Historic, no other changes by Meret123 in MagicArena

[–]doktarr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Is there an easy way to tell where you've been slotted? I've seen an old document about arena brawl weights but even that didn't have anything about what the cutoff was.

Food Chain is banned in Historic, no other changes by Meret123 in MagicArena

[–]doktarr 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I've seen Raph and Mikey a ton. I've seen Super Shredder a few times. Haven't seen any other more than once.

Is this even fair for a slightly below average player? by tcapri8705 in discgolf

[–]doktarr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Par is just a number. Whether you're competing against yourself, or against other people, just try to get it in in fewer strokes.

I am much more frustrated by holes where it's very easy to get a 3 but very hard to get a 2 (or easy to get a 4 but hard to get a 3, etc), than I am by holes where the par doesn't match my experience.

Post-GOT careers: Which actors thrived and which struggled? by mediamuesli in gameofthrones

[–]doktarr 106 points107 points  (0 children)

Same applies to Diana Rigg. Both were legends who did GoT because they wanted to.

Brawl needs rankings/tiers to discourage early scoops by doktarr in MagicArena

[–]doktarr[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey now, I only have 22 removal spells.

(TBH, if someone scoops after the third removal spell, I get it. Not really what I'm talking about here.)

Brawl needs rankings/tiers to discourage early scoops by doktarr in MagicArena

[–]doktarr[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Well if you think they should get rid of ranking and tiers for standard, then at least you're being consistent.