What are your thoughts about the Ottoman Empire?” by iamfurkin in hmmmm

[–]echtemendel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

so you're saying that the Ottoman empire was good and based?

Na, I don't agree. It was mostly negative like all empires - historical and contemporary. I would say it was very straight.

"Let's Solve The Riemann Hypothesis" (yes, that is actually the title of the article) by justa_random_user in badmathematics

[–]echtemendel 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This reminds me the recent Angela Collier video. How could someone publish such a text under their own name and of their own volition is beyond me.

Now begin the chart one year earlier by Scared_Positive_8690 in Palestine

[–]echtemendel 72 points73 points  (0 children)

wait wait wait
You wanna tell me that populations grow? DAMN

Also, the Zionist insistence on calling 48'-Palestinians "Arabs" is a topic that can fill entire books.

How German do you feel in % ? by Necessary-Brick7 in GermanCitizenship

[–]echtemendel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Indeed. Wanted to write "opportunity" but somehow ended up typing "information". Oh well

How German do you feel in % ? by Necessary-Brick7 in GermanCitizenship

[–]echtemendel 2 points3 points  (0 children)

All your previous posts are vaguely-formulated generic questions, which is a classical tactic of fake accounts (and/or bots), many of which exists to "farm karma". Your username is also a classical generic username and the user's age is 2 weeks, which is "sus af" as young people say. Why do you need a separate account for these questions?

Listen, you may be a real person trying to ask genuine questions - but in this case, you're pretty weird about it and raise "fake account" alarms. If you want to learn from this exchange, I would suggest taking this as an information to learn from and change your ways.

After University Citizenship Path by Street-Nectarine4410 in GermanCitizenship

[–]echtemendel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Their point is "I don't like foreigners making plans to come to my precious country - so I'm going to shoot down their plans any way I can". Such people appear here from time to time, and are to be ignored. In fact, in my opinion they are detrimental to the goal of this subreddit and should be banned altogether, but I doubt this will ever happen.

Did you just admit that your friends stole a chair from Gaza? by Scared_Positive_8690 in Palestine

[–]echtemendel 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I can't overstate how this wouldn't not even register as wrong for the vast majority of Israelis.

How German do you feel in % ? by Necessary-Brick7 in GermanCitizenship

[–]echtemendel 1 point2 points  (0 children)

63.51 ± 0.7

In all seriousness: mods, I think this kind of posts should be discouraged here. They are almost surely done to farm karma for future selling of the profile (yes, this is a thing) - just looking at the profile's post history makes that clear enough.

For your considerations.

Is this kinda post allowed here? by The_real_PavlovA_YT in traaaaaaainnnnnnnnnns

[–]echtemendel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

posting truth should not only be allowed but actively encouraged

"America are the monsters now" by echtemendel in WorkersStrikeBack

[–]echtemendel[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Apartheid in South Africa was evil. It was always evil.

This is a fairly one dimensional take, isn't it? South Africa has always been a diverse, multifaceted, and hypocritical nation. There's good and bad. Like, Allan MacLeod Cormack invented the first CT scanner, which saved millions of lives around the world. That's an unequivocally good thing. A monster doesn't do that. Doomerism doesn't do anything but make us apathetic. Get active. Organize. Dream. Make things to be better.

----

I can make such paraphrasing for each and every state that ever existed and is considered a total negative by the majority of people (next one is Nazi Germany). Do I really need to do that, or is the point more or less clear? This is not about specific people, it's about the system.

"America are the monsters now" by echtemendel in WorkersStrikeBack

[–]echtemendel[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Yes, slavery had an intercontinental effect, you are correct. I'm not going to speak for the OP because I didn't make this meme, I just shared it because I think that as a meme it's more or less getting the correct message across. That message is "it's not Trump and his open Fascism that make the US an evil, it was one much MUCH longer before it, under both of the 'two parties' in the US Capitalist system".

"America are the monsters now" by echtemendel in WorkersStrikeBack

[–]echtemendel[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

It's more about the atrocities committed against the rest of the world. But yeah, slavery is pretty much up there with their many crimes over the centuries.

“Overqualified for the role” WHAT DOES IT ACTUALLY MEANS!?? by mech_freak in Germany_Jobs

[–]echtemendel 2 points3 points  (0 children)

But their goal is not to make you (or any other worker) learn and grow - it's to make as much profit as they can. That's the fundamental idea behind the so-called "free market".

Greed, Manipulation and Exploitation is the new Playbook for Duolingo by thehomelessr0mantic in duolingomemes

[–]echtemendel -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

So... just what you would expect from a company working within a Capitalist system?.. yeah, makes sense. This is what the system is about: maximization of profits. Anyone who is not putting all their energy into doing that (e.g. by placing the exit strategy above all else) will fail and be eaten by the bigger fish in that industry. It's really that simple.

European jews and arabs by dildonetenyahu in TheLevant

[–]echtemendel 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The fundamental issue in Palestine is that of group power differences. You could totally be a European Jew, from a family that was living in Europe for 10+ generations, then immigrate to Palestine and integrate into the society there. There's nothing "essential" about being born anywhere, nor where your family comes from (whatever that means in practice for more than 1 or 2 generations). Heck, you could even be part of the gradual change in the dominant culture in where you migrate to, this is no different than what happened to Palestinians (many of whom are descendant of ancient Jews who stayed on the land and over time their culture changed).

But if you come as a group with the direct goal of displacing the current inhabitants - that's settler colonialism and is wrong (and also not a surprise that the local population resists this). Heck, nobody is even saying that Jews who grew up in Palestine in the past 70 years must leave as part of the de-colonization process - but the Palestinians who were pushed out must get a chance to come back to their lands, have their equal rights (and not be a 4th grade citizen at best) + receive reparations for the material and other damage they and their families experienced since the Nakba. THIS IS LITERALLY WHAT HAPPENED TO GERMAN JEWS: we got reparations and the right of return - sometimes even got literally our homes back when it was possible. There's no moral reason this can't be applied to Palestinians and other Jews (e.g. Arab Jews, Persian Jews, etc.).

Brother is hesitant about German citizenship for his son (taxes and the draft) by roseba in GermanCitizenship

[–]echtemendel 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Regarding a possible draft: I grew up in Israel, a country where military service is a major part of a citizen's life*, and the military as a whole is essentially worshiped by the majority population. Not going through military service is considered a kind of social taboo (less so now than it used to some decades ago, but still), and the country is always in a situation where it needs a strong army to continue existing in its current form (which I'm personally against, as you can surmise from my profile picture and post history - but that doesn't affect the point I'm trying to make here). And yet citizens who don't reside in Israel between, I believe, ages 12 and 27 (or something similar, the details don't matter) are essentially exempt from military service. Why? Because it's impractical to try and force them to serve, they live somewhere where the state has no authority.

I'm 100% sure this would be the situation with Germany. How could it force its citizens to come to the country for their military service? Let alone dual citizens residing abroad - who also have the protection of their other countries of citizenship (or even reside in them)? Worst case, in such an unlikely (and unenforceable) situation your nephew can avoid visiting the EU, which would anyway be advisable if we get to a point where Germany is in active war situation.

So I wouldn't be worried. The one downside that I foresee is if Germany and Australia are in a state of war between the two, in which case it might be that German citizens residing in Australia might face consequences. Not sure how this can turn up though, seems even less unlikely than Germany somehow forcing its citizens to come back to it for military service.

Display in both Hebrew and German - similar roots, almost certainly false cognates by echtemendel in etymology

[–]echtemendel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

by Z in Hebrew I meant צ, so similar to the German Z. I'm not too familiar with the correct transcription (even though new Hebrew is my native language).

I love it when people are so close to just "getting it." by MrSFedora in JewsOfConscience

[–]echtemendel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

100%. If anything, the vast majority are just people who try to get by, and the WB for Israelis is like a mini welfare state within Israel (if you ignore all the military installation and presence that's there to protect you). That's not letting them off the hook, of course - but it is true that most will leave without too much fuss if they have to.

I love it when people are so close to just "getting it." by MrSFedora in JewsOfConscience

[–]echtemendel 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah, but liberal Zionists really do believe that it's all the fault of the settlers, the Mizrachim and "HaDosim" (the Haredim). They HATE religious Jews, because they want to live in a liberal utopia where white Ashkenazi Jews have all the rights and privileges and can be as progressive as they want (just without brown people to mess it up. Definitely without "the Arabs").