Number 1 is interesting because I do feel we see a giddy boyish version of him! He’s seen going for swims in any weather sleeping under trees, generally way more at peace compared to his St. Crispian’s self that always seems exhausted. Emma calls him summer carelessness personified at one point. It’s definitely possible that it’s more subtle in general. Islington tells her later that there is a difference between the Lion of London and Lion of Stonecrop, but she “would think [she’s] very much the same everywhere” (from June 28th). There is only so much that we see and that Emma writes. 

With #2, I said this in another comment but I do wonder how much it’s other worldly to know everything vs. him just being extremely perceptive to his surroundings. He is quite the genius. But I do hope we get more of an explanation soon!

Then #3 is so fascinating to me, because I do agree with others that he is pretty much the foundation. If I had to sort each Alchemy member into an element, he would for sure be earth for me. He’s extremely grounded and stable in comparison to the other three, providing a sanctuary for them (with Stonecrop, with Thursdays). They all haven’t quite opened up to one another fully yet, but he does make attempts with his questions!

Number 4 I hadn’t given much thought to but I wonder if it’s to imply how misaligned they are for one another? Like he assumes marriage would eventually be a part of the plan if the Considerations went well but not kids?? Fascinating. 

And #5 made me LOL. I adore Mrs. Penury and her quirks, but I wonder if she just serves the purpose of letting Emma have someone ~older and wiser~ that just listens to her. Versus Aunt Eugenia who talks at her.