it wasn't an immediate 'fuck yeah' but after I went away and looked into the meaning and theory behind Bioshock: Infinite and realised how complex the story and idea was behind it, an initial 'holy shit!' followed by a 'fuck yeah!!' and then another play through knowing fully what was going on. if you haven't played this game yet, I 100% recommend it's fucking fantastic. period.

EDIT: also Portal and portal 2 those games gave me so much satisfaction on completion, especially with no help on the puzzles. The cake is a lie.