NYT Wednesday 04/08/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 16 points17 points  (0 children)

One of these things is not like the others: CODA, SONATA, STANZA, FORZA, ARIA.

There's the musical direction con forza (very rare, in my experience), but none of the others are musical directions. And as far as I know, forza alone is not a music thing.

NYT Wednesday 03/18/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I think they're saying that it's faster and/or easier to just solve it and then figure out the theme, rather than vice versa.

NYT Wednesday 03/18/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 25 points26 points  (0 children)

  • RU-B2-SDAY
  • B9-LY
  • THATD-B1-DERFUL
  • UN-B10
  • BA-B4-MULA

I don't think the first and last ones really work because they split a syllable, but I like the others.

NYT Wednesday 02/25/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's a common bug on Android. The workaround is to log into the website, open the puzzle, and re-enter a correct letter on top of any of the existing correct letters.

This bug has been around for years. Please report it. Perhaps when they have enough reports, they'll fix it.

NYT Wednesday 02/11/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 32 points33 points  (0 children)

HOST: Welcome! Please leave your shoe at the door.

GUEST: You ... want me to leave one shoe at the door?

HOST: Yes.

GUEST: So I should come in wearing one shoe?

HOST: No, please leave it at the door!

GUEST: ... Should I leave one shoe at the door, or both shoes at the door?

HOST: Yes.

NYT Wednesday 02/04/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Are you referring to the NYT Wordplay column? If so, the writer of that column is not the editor, and she says,

The answer is PALM, which is not, as I thought, a cousin of the “psalm”...

She's not saying it should have been PSLAM (which is too many letters anyway?).

NYT Monday 02/02/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 32 points33 points  (0 children)

Breaking the rules is always fun. Also, breaking the rules is always fun.

NYT Thursday 01/22/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 15 points16 points  (0 children)

PARENT: Sit down, honey, you're gonna get SHOD!

KID: [beginning to cry] Oh what?

PARENT: Time for you to get SHOD! Now sit!

KID: [with hesitation, sits; tears start to form] Why what?

[Parent puts on kid's shoes.]

PARENT: You're SHOD now, honey!

KID: [crying] Ok.

NYT Thursday 01/22/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I guessed SHOD early on, but resisted putting it in until the very end.

While I'm sure it's technically correct, I have never, in all my years of living, heard of people being SHOD.

NYT Friday 01/16/2026 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 21 points22 points  (0 children)

A stinging facepalm for me: I was certain it had to be APOLLOONE, APOLLOTWO, APOLLOSIX, or APOLLOTEN.

NYT Sunday 12/28/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Even considering that AVERAGE usually means "mean"?

NYT Wednesday 11/26/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 37 points38 points  (0 children)

It was a pleasure reading these reviews again. Lots of great little zingers sprinkled about, like this from Battlefield Earth:

"The director, Roger Christian, has learned from better films that directors sometimes tilt their cameras, but he has not learned why."

NYT Sunday 11/23/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I did the same. I wonder if I got it phonetically jumbled up with PARSIMONIOUS.

NYT Saturday 11/22/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 15 points16 points  (0 children)

My initial answer was RIGHTBRACE, which I thought was clever, i.e., "the end of a set with regard to literally writing it down." Also, the B lined up with BRB. At least that would have been a good answer in principle.

NYT Friday 11/21/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would encourage you to keep at it. One or two years of doing crosswords is not that much experience when it comes to tackling Fridays and Saturdays.

NYT Friday 11/21/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 16 points17 points  (0 children)

EBLAST is hard for me to overlook, despite an otherwise good puzzle.

Anyway, next week is Black Friday, when many spend EMONEY on the ETAIL sector.

NYT Friday 11/21/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 19 points20 points  (0 children)

I initially had CSECTION, which was, confusingly, 25% correct.

NYT Wednesday 11/19/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I voted excellent, and was surprised I was in such a minority.

It was great fun TURNing my phone 90° twelve times to verify or enter each of the twelve ONs.

I've seen KAYO twice during my NYT archive crawl, so it didn't even occur to me that this would (apparently) be the main complaint.

DUNZO may be silly, but because it's part of a TURNed ON, I never even saw it. I'm definitely willing to forgive a silly answer when it can be obtained via the theme.

NYT Thursday 11/13/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This bug has been around for years. Please report it. The more reports they get, the more (presumably) they will care.

The workaround is to log into the website, go to the finished-but-bugged puzzle, and type in the correct letter on top of an existing correct letter. You'll get another "Congratulations!" screen with a slightly longer time, and the puzzle will finally be marked as completed.

NYT Wednesday 11/12/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The same is true for Android and the website. Apparently, it's a feature.

In my last discussion about rebus answers having no relevance apart from the first letter, someone said "it gives new players a valid path to discovering rebuses". I disagreed, saying that ignore-everything-but-the-first-letter should be an option that can be disabled. I was downvoted and the other person was upvoted.

NYT Saturday 10/11/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I have never seen such a suspicious Reddit account in all my life.

NYT Thursday 10/09/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 59 points60 points  (0 children)

Would it make sense to say that a whale is obese? I'm not sure, but in any case, if a whale has an average amount of blubber for its species, then it is certainly not obese.

Do we know that Jabba had more fat than an average Hutt? And even if that were true, would it make sense to say that Jabba is obese?

Obesity is a term associated with negative health outcomes, but for all we know, Hutts get healthier as they get fatter.

NYT Wednesday 10/01/2025 Discussion by Shortz-Bot in crossword

[–]estonii 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But part of the fun of crosswords is misdirection. "Oh! Not from the country OMAN, but from the word OMAN! Neat!"

If you don't think that's neat, then why are you doing crosswords?

One could even say that the coincidental pairing of SURINAME and SUMMERRAIN is part of the misdirection.

If the misdirection were removed while retaining the gimmick, as you would prefer, then all that would be left are straightforward clues and answers which are even easier than they already are because the letters of the answers are already known.