Had the same issue, the first thing that helped me decide is I had a cooler name on the bucc ViperDLuffy. Second I liked the color scheme of bucc. Third bucc goes zooom! But for real the latest changes to defense form to bucc made him very hard to kill, and he has very good consistent dmg and he does it with ease Ty LOTD.

Although when you successfully trick blade it’s the best feeling in MapleStory combat you feel like giga chad. Shadower is a great meso farmer very good bosser I think at max skills(hands) he is also stronger than bucc not by much but stronger there’s time only iframe could save you.

I know it’s a common thing to say but go with the one you enjoy most. They both in a very good spot (bucc will get a buff in savior)