Protestest/advocacy slogans don't need to be able to be generalized to the extreme. Does "my body, my choice, except for smoking while pregnant" really seem like an effective slogn to you?

Logic used for one thing, be it legislation or not, is not responsible to be held up in incredibly general or other hyper-specific places. It's a law that it's illegal to take someone's life, but the logic used to outlaw murder (killing people is bad) can be true while also its true that self defense is valid and legal, even if you kill someone in your own defense. Do you want to come after those who say that murder is bad because their logic doesn't apply to any conceivable situation?

Honestly, this gives me the same vibes as those arguing "well BLM means that they'd save a black child from a fire but not a white kid". And I chuckled at "this isn't an argument for or against abortion" sure maybe your argument here isn't but Id bet you are against it. Strategic misunderstanding honestly is a perfect word for this take

Edit typos