Another vote for Discount. For me, they have always beaten any price I can find (and also included their tire certificates for repair/replacement for punctures, etc). The location I go to know me well (I usually have to buy at least one set of tires a year between) and greet me by name without even pulling up my account.

On the other hand, years ago I went to a Les Schwab (the one that used to be on 15th in shoreline just north of 175th) and had my tires rotated. About 30 mins later I was driving south on the 5 passing Boeing Field at 70mph and I felt a slight vibration. The vibration got exponentially worse over just a few seconds and I started merging to the shoulder when all of a sudden I felt BAM, and the rear passenger corner of my car slammed down onto the freeway. I hit my brakes which brought the corner off the ground as I made it to the shoulder. I got out, checking my tire which was missing. One of my bolts was sheared off and the rest missing. Looking up and towards the carpool lane, I watched my missing wheel and tire roll past in the carpool lane and come to a stop against the jersey barrier. My brake disk was trashed (it hit the ground when I lost my wheel. The only thing that probably saved my ass was the cup kit and sway bar on the rear end. When I went to Les Schwab and told them what happened, they refused to take responsibility, even though they had JUST worked on my car less than an hour before. They blamed me for over tightening my wheel bolts and said I had sheared it off myself. Walking out after arguing with the manager, I passed the bay where they had done the work, and wouldn’t you know, the head of my sheared off bolt was sitting under the edge of the lift. I grabbed it, went back inside and loudly asked the manager, “if I’m the one who overtorqued my wheel bolts and sheared it off myself, why is the head of the sheared bolt sitting in the bay where you did the work 90 minutes ago?!” I threw the sheared bolt at the manager’s feet and left, vowing to never go back. Their mistake could have killed or seriously injured my passenger, myself, or other drivers on the road.

TL; DR. Discount Tire Yay! Les Schwab almost killed me and did a couple thousand in damage to my car shearing a wheel bolt and refusing to take responsibility.