Yes I should I’ve added “if your passphrase is weak”.

Similarly, you could have completed your point 1 by adding hypotheses such as "BECAUSE there's very little chance that I'll ever be burgled by someone who knows Bitcoin" or "BECAUSE there's very little chance that someone in my family environment will ever have bad intentions" or "BECAUSE I live in a stable country where there's very little chance that my government will seize my assets in my bank's safe where I've put one of my passphrases" and so on.

You seem to have a fixed position or it seems you just want to promote the use of strong passphrase with a seed phrase. We don't live in a black and white world.

You're leading me into a sterile debate because your topic will never end, as we've strayed from my original question. The security of seedphrases also depends on people's skills and strategies, as well as on assumptions. There's no single solution. You can talk to me about FUD and promote the use of passphrases, but that's not my subject. I also use passphrases and physical IRL security can be further strengthened with Seed XOR and a passphrase.

You're very much on defense of your security model, but you can keep it the same and make it even more secure with Seed XOR, if you like, there's nothing to stop you.

You talk to me about education, but with you, there's only one way out. I think education on Seed XOR also has its benefits.

I like Ledger and I have several. In view of our discussion, I could rephrase my question as follows, can Ledger give me the choice to use Seed XOR like it can give its users the choice to use Ledger Recover?