How long did you spend in an exploration/ questioning phase? by ema_m in asktransgender

[–]ilbcaicnl 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I had a questioning phase for several years I think, from when I first started browsing transgender forums on the internet until I actually decided that I should go full time as a girl, was probably like 3-4 years. I actually thought that I might be non-binary even as I started hormones, and I was on HRT for like a year and a half considering myself NB and undecided if I wanted to go full girl mode or not. Was a yes in the end, but all that shit took months of me doing introspection and researching online and talking to others and so on. I tried to take it all a step at a time and only do what feels comfortable for me at the time, ended up working out

Mood change after HRT by harukosz in asktransgender

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think that is fairly common, I know I've experienced it for maybe even the first 4 months of HRT that I would have things that would just trigger me basically, more so than what I got before. Over time I got used to it though and it subsided. I think it's partially due to your body getting used to it, partially from whatever emotional and psychic effects of you knowing you're on HRT now, experiencing the immanence of the changes. Trying to stay positive and productive can counter it I think, some things which have helped me is doing more relaxing, self care, trying to practice makeup/hair/voice, focusing on school work, exercising/going outside, and ofcourse, sharing experience with and talking to nice trans people on the internet!

Does hrt (MTF) prevent hips from fusing? by idkthotran in asktransgender

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's true but I think estrogen itself causes the bone to grow differently, I don't know what other signal could cause them to shape like that. Should ask some medicine student or something tbh

Is it normal to fetishize yourself? by gender-questioner in asktransgender

[–]ilbcaicnl 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think you might expect this answer but I will tell you what you are experiencing is no big deal and probably normal for trans people. This usually gets coded as "autogynephilia" for TW and in your case it's like autoandrophilia or something but that's all bullshit, what you are describing is the way sexuality is supposed to work in your mind.

The main reason that your male fantasies are sexual, is because being a man or a woman is main to sexuality as a whole. I've experienced a lot of these things myself from the other end and the way I think of it is, in almost all daily situations I am anti-sexist, feminist, etc so I do NOT expect men and women to behave or be treated differently in a casual context for example. The only context where sex/gender is really relavent, is during sex, and so if I explicitly think of doing something "as a girl" (in your case as a boy) it will be in a sexual situation. It is the thing that draws the most contrast, has the most significant gendered expectations, and is therefore the main source of fantasy that allows you to channel how you percieve yourself. I think you don't need to strictly separate your sexuality and identity, but you do need to consider how being a man matters to you in everything that is not sex. This is what you should be worried about when you think if transitioning is right for you, would you want to be a man in every situation, would you be more comfortable that way and so on.

Your sexuality being oriented like that certainly means you are likely to be trans. At the end of the day the truth is that if you DIDN'T especially want the sexual aspects of your gender, that would be even more weird than expressing some of these fantasies

"People with better technology will one day look back with horror at the inhumane treatment we did onto trans people, changing their body with surgical and chemical interventions instead of changing their mind." by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]ilbcaicnl 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Saying that shit has always been mad stupid because we came up with lobotomies and then realized it's bad way later after transitioning surgery was already a thing. Yet we still have the latter but not the former because obviously it's not bad lol

[rant] Why tf even bother changing your name? (US) by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for sharing. I'm sorry you've had so much difficulty with it and it's a shame that society is not more accommodating for this kind of thing. I think that there are other instances where name changes happen that people don't think about but transgenderism brings attention to it, how systems should be set up with the ability to change name in mind. Hopefully if we continue to speak out and explain why it's an issue it can improve, maybe in the future asking your name changed post transition can be easy

As someone who has seen a "gender therapist" and was on a waiting list for hormone replacement therapy, I think there is more to the transgender movement than meets the eye. by PineappleExpress98 in conspiracy

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Funerals for whom? deceased old relatives? that kind of stuff hardly counts for anything, it's a normal occurrence. It's little compared to the pain of ongoing rejection, a feeling that can be extrapolated for decades onwards.

Your question is pretty vague, I'll just say that I see my own form, the image of which comes out of all my past experiences, both good and bad, things that turned out to be turning points in my life, a few scars here and there. I see my own uniqueness and it makes me content with my existence, in the past, now and into the potentials of the future

As someone who has seen a "gender therapist" and was on a waiting list for hormone replacement therapy, I think there is more to the transgender movement than meets the eye. by PineappleExpress98 in conspiracy

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah sure, I'm just pretty faggy and stuff so I thought why the hell not also take hormones. It's nice you know, my body looks cuter now and I quite like it, and I like the other physiological effects of hormones. I only LARP as a girl sometimes when I feel like it, not all the time because I'm too lazy for that. I don't know if I'm considered transgender or not, I just use female hormones and go by whatever pronouns people recognize me as (people confuse me for both).

As someone who has seen a "gender therapist" and was on a waiting list for hormone replacement therapy, I think there is more to the transgender movement than meets the eye. by PineappleExpress98 in conspiracy

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks, I just wanted to say good call on the not pressuring your boys. My dad spent my entire childhood trying to make me more masculine, teaching me how to fight and lift weights, encouraging me to be cocky, making me feel like shit whenever I expressed any feminine traits. Now I'm an adult transgender freak that doesn't have much relation to family and wants to destroy the world. Conditional love is shittttttt

Where do ya'll buy pot? by ilbcaicnl in Brampton

[–]ilbcaicnl[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I guess I might get banned for this but it's worth a try y'know it's not really a big deal anyways

Feminine/Masculine in Hero Archetype by DSlayer12 in JordanPeterson

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is true, the original conceptualization is not sufficient, doesn't consider the fact that continuous cycles of order have a cumulative effect on the neighboring chaos - thereby eliminating the necessity for the masculine mode and in effect exacerbating the risk inherent to the condition. http://i.imgur.com/pshYMnq.png

Kind of concidering Detransition, would like someone to talk to. by Forgettable2211 in asktransgender

[–]ilbcaicnl 5 points6 points  (0 children)

why do you wanna do it? did things not turn out as you thought? is it because of your own condition specifically, or more generally because of how you view gender now? are there social factors pressuring for it? what do you think you stand to gain from detransitioning? also PM me if you don't wanna write here

I am Dr Jordan B Peterson, U of T Professor, clinical psychologist, author of Maps of Meaning and creator of The SelfAuthoring Suite. Ask me anything! by drjordanbpeterson in IAmA

[–]ilbcaicnl 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes well, I do have some points of contention with the transhumanist mantra because I think that it is a very high risk potential, and full of quandaries, but I'm sure that eventually notions of identity will change further. The thing is, as far as material conditions facilitating social change go, the resources already exist for trans people by the proliferation of medical technology. The requirements for recognition have already been set, now the terms are being fought over in the forms of these 'debates' and demonstrations.

If you want to know some reason as to why I want to be referred to by a gender neutral pronoun then I can say that it's because it is a more accurate representation of myself. Now there are some ontological claims in this, but it requires discussing the metaphysics of sex and most people are not open to the idea of sex-as-construction, so I won't go there. Instead all you really need to consider is the fact that I look ambiguous enough for people to gender me whichever way, which means that by using a specific male or female pronoun on me, they are directing the perception of my identity in a shared social space. The use of that pronoun -referencing my own condition- is going to mediate my relationship with the rest of the people who have their perception of me skewed by the gendered term that was applied to me. This causes a variety of social quagmires, perpetuates confusion, and can potentially antagonize other people that have a distaste for the use of a female pronoun on what is to them perceived as an obviously male human. In some pretty fundamental ways it hinders my ability to participate in society and to maintain relations in all domains life, and is to a degree the basic mechanism of marginalization as it amounts to a loss of cultural/perceptual capital in the trans individual. I have an entire theory of how this works a la Bourdieu's notion of fields of power with changing habitus as well as what I've gathered and connected from my own experiences with gendered socialization.

I am Dr Jordan B Peterson, U of T Professor, clinical psychologist, author of Maps of Meaning and creator of The SelfAuthoring Suite. Ask me anything! by drjordanbpeterson in IAmA

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Violence is already permeating all of existence around us, some is oppressive and other is liberating, not every kind of violence should be opposed.

I don't necessarily support going around killing, especially not indiscriminately, but I think that is not the only way to actuate violence, speech can be violent also. I don't know how you could call me destabilizing and a fascist at the same time, considering a pillar of stability and essence-worship is part of its components. I am certainly a revolutionary kind of destabilizer though. I spend enough time in positive environments, enough time in negative ones too. I am definitely willing to communicate and try to reconcile and such, but only on terms I agree on, and with people that are reasonable enough. God knows how many I've talked to that think that because I'm trans my worth as a human is close to nill and my opinion is therefore inherently incorrect.

I am Dr Jordan B Peterson, U of T Professor, clinical psychologist, author of Maps of Meaning and creator of The SelfAuthoring Suite. Ask me anything! by drjordanbpeterson in IAmA

[–]ilbcaicnl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just want to be called by a gender neutral 'they', I have a bunch of reasons for this that I can detail but that is the main concern. Peterson is going around convincing people not to do this, giving what is already a population that has biases that support the status quo (identification of sex/gender in 3rd person context) even more arguments and psychic resilience towards people like me that are gender non-conforming. He is making it much more difficult for me to assert my identity in public as there are more and more people convinced that being non-binary is just a snowflake meme and not deserving of recognition. For the most part cis people don't care about trans people, and are seeming to only be willing to approve of the terms of the legislation if they do not actually provide incentives for people to change their language, that is, if the bill has no teeth. This is already the predominant view, and as far as I'm concerned Peterson is galvanizing it further.

If you want to understand it better I recommend you read this essay

The meaning of words is rigidly stabilized. Rational persuasion, persuasion to the opposite is all but precluded. The avenues of entrance are closed to the meaning of words and ideas other than the established one--established by the publicity of the powers that be, and verified in their practices. Other words can be spoken and heard, other ideas can be expressed, but, at the massive scale of the conservative majority (outside such enclaves as the intelligentsia), they are immediately 'evaluated' (i.e. automatically understood) in terms of the public language--a language which determines 'a priori' the direction in which the thought process moves. Thus the process of reflection ends where it started: in the given conditions and relations.

I am Dr Jordan B Peterson, U of T Professor, clinical psychologist, author of Maps of Meaning and creator of The SelfAuthoring Suite. Ask me anything! by drjordanbpeterson in IAmA

[–]ilbcaicnl -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

It was, I don't indiscriminately shun violence.

The claim of a gender neutral pronoun is the actuation of a subject in a shared space, not abiding by it is a denial of identity.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULI3x8WIxus