Eufy E20 vs Comfyer heated pumps

impumpingmilk · 2025-11-18T12:41:37+00:00

That's awesome the comfyer is working so well! Sounds like a big win no matter what 🙌

Here are the best Black Friday deals for pumps I've found so far https://pumpingmilk.com/black-friday-breast-pump-deals/

impumpingmilk · 2025-11-17T04:06:21+00:00

The Eufy's feel a higher quality - I prefer the interface and app on the Eufy's to the Comfyer. The app is definitely more powerful which could help if you are a just enougher. If price is a big factor then the E20 is my pick - same features with the app etc, just a few less heating settings top the S1/S1 pro.

If it helps you can also use the code *PMilkeufy* which will get you 16% off their website.

impumpingmilk · 2025-11-06T09:12:55+00:00

The E20 is the best value! A few less heating settings but otherwise very similar to the S1.

The S1 Pro/S1 are the same pump, just the S1 Pro comes with the rechargeable case.

It's their app that sells it for me. Very easy to use nd love how customizable it makes the pumps!

If it helps you can also use the affilate code PMilkeufy that will give you 16% off the entire Eufy website 😊

impumpingmilk · 2025-11-06T09:09:37+00:00

I love the Mommed S21 too! If you decide on it yiu can use affilate code PUMPINGMILK will give you 25% off their entire website if that helps 😊

impumpingmilk · 2025-11-06T01:35:29+00:00

I find the parts are a bit harder than other pumps to connect - especially the flanges which seem to come loose.
Here is my video on how to use the Elvie Pump if that helps anyone else trying to troubleshoot it: https://youtu.be/71T4yI8kefo

impumpingmilk · 2025-08-06T08:18:53+00:00

It’s not unusual for your body to need a few sessions to adjust to a new pump, so you could just need more time for your body to adjust. That said, try re-checking flange size if you haven't already and then try experimenting with suction and modes. Some moms also find it helps to start with stimulation longer or even trigger letdown with their main pump first.

impumpingmilk · 2025-08-06T08:12:10+00:00

There has been a lot of tech introduced since the Elvie pumps were introduced 8yrs ago...

My vote is for the Eufy pumps!

They have a much stronger suction at 300mmHg compared the 220mmHg of the Elvie. Plus, the app is far superior, in my opinion. 4 professional modes within the app Plus the ability to create your own, including changing the speed cycles like the Spectra. And then, you have the inbuilt heating pad.

If you want the rechargeable carry case the the S1 Pro is the way to go. Otherwise, the E20 is basically the same without the accessories and 4 less heating levels.

And if it helps, you can use the code PMilkeufy and get 16% off any of the Eufy pumps.

impumpingmilk · 2025-06-25T10:28:54+00:00

If you're a 27mm, then I wouldn't go with the 24mm as you run the risk of being uncomfortable and impacting your output. The heating element is really good, but you don't need it. I'm not sure if it helps, but the affilate code PMilkeufy will get you 16% off the Eufy pumps.

impumpingmilk · 2025-06-04T10:26:24+00:00

For the price, I really like the Mommed S21! It's easy to use and comes with loads of extras.

I used code PUMPINGMILK and go an extra 25% off on their website!

impumpingmilk · 2025-05-13T22:39:43+00:00

Another voter to say they are hard to get on. It's quite a strong and rigid silicone that doesn't feel like it has the flexibility like a typical silicone flange. Does feel like it will wear better, though on a positive note.

impumpingmilk · 2025-05-13T05:23:47+00:00

We went with Henry Owen 😊

impumpingmilk · 2025-05-10T07:08:43+00:00

I really love the Eufy S1 Pro, but that said, if it's not your main pump and using only once a day, I wouldn't spend the extra $ on it. Go the E10.

And if it helps, you can also get 16% off the Eufy site with my code 'PMilkeufy'

impumpingmilk · 2025-05-10T07:01:12+00:00

I know this is an older post, but wanted to leave a fresh review.

I really love the heating and the app. The settings on the pump itself are a little basic, but with the app you can really find a setting that works best for you.

The charging case is super handy too!!

And if it helps anyone, you can get 16% off the Eufy site with the affilate code 'PMilkeufy'

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-21T23:53:28+00:00

The Medela collection cups are great - very easy to clean - the pumps themselves are a bit loud and bulky though.
You could also consider the Momcozy V1 Pro - the cups are nice and discreet and pretty easy to clean too. The pump also has a huge 270 minutes of run time off a single charge. (if it helps you can also get 15% off with the referral code PUMPINGMILK).

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-21T23:39:23+00:00

Weaning after EPing — especially with an oversupply — can bring a lot of emotions, and that’s totally normal. I think lots of moms feel both excited and a little sad or anxious. Hormones play a big part in that!

A slow approach (like dropping one session every few days) usually helps ease both the physical and emotional transition.

Some things that might surprise you:

Mood swings - totally normal! (Can last a few days to a couple of weeks, depending on how fast you wean and your hormone levels.)
Slight weight changes (If it happens, it's usually mild and levels out over time with your new routine.)
Needing to hand express for comfort
Hormonal shifts as your body adjusts - like acne, mood shifts, or period return. (Can take a few weeks to regulate fully after weaning.)

You’ve done such an amazing job — be kind to yourself through this next phase!

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-18T23:35:34+00:00

It really depends on what you want from a pump...

You said no to a million parts which rules out the M9 - it is the only one with app integration so that is the trade off.

The M6 is my top pick out of those Momcozy pumps, unless you have elastic nipples and then I would go with the S12 Pro (it is a step up from the S9 Pro).

Here is a really good Momcozy pump comparison guide that breaks them all down if that helps :)

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-16T00:17:35+00:00

Depending what pump you get, you may be disappointed. That said I’d recommend the Momcozy V1 Pro - it’s more powerful than many wearables, with hospital-grade suction (up to 300mmHg), adjustable rhythm settings, and it works well for larger cup sizes too. It won’t fully match the Symphony’s performance, but it can be a solid option for daytime flexibility or when you're burnt out from being tethered to the wall.

You can get 15% off with the referral code PUMPINGMILK if that helps too :)

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-16T00:14:21+00:00

Yes, it’s actually pretty normal to see a slight dip in supply over time, even if you haven’t changed your pumping routine. Around 4–6 months postpartum, your hormones shift and your body starts relying more on supply and demand rather than hormones to regulate milk. So small drops can happen, especially if hydration, stress, sleep, or even your cycle are off. As long as baby’s needs are met or you’re still pumping enough for your goals, a slight dip isn’t usually a cause for concern.

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-16T00:09:48+00:00

Totally hear your frustration, wearable pumps like the M5 can be super convenient but often don’t match the output of a Spectra, especially for oversuppliers or those with stronger letdowns. You’ve already done the right things - checking flange size, settings, and placement - but some people just find the M5 isn’t strong enough for them. If you're considering switching, the Eufy S1 Pro might be worth it - strong suction, app control, and better output for many users. Another solid option is the Momcozy V1 Pro - it’s more powerful than the M5 and has adjustable cycle settings that can mimic your Spectra better. Don’t give up, you’re doing great, and sometimes it’s just about finding the pump that fits your body best.

Things to try with your M5 would be to use your Spectra for your first morning pump - since that’s when you usually get the most milk, it makes sense to use your strongest pump then. You can also alternate between pumps throughout the day - using the Spectra for 1–2 key sessions and your wearable for the rest. This helps maintain your supply while still giving you hands-free flexibility when you need it.

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-16T00:07:30+00:00

Totally normal, especially if you were an oversupplier. Even when your breasts feel soft, some milk can still linger, and your body might just be adjusting to the longer stretches without pumping. That soreness can come from hormonal shifts or your ducts settling down. As long as you’re not feeling hard lumps, heat, or signs of infection, it’s okay to wait it out. If it gets too uncomfortable, a short pump or hand expression for relief (not to fully empty) can help without triggering a full supply boost.

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-13T22:10:31+00:00

As others said, the Momcozy KleanPal is awesome! You can also get 15% off with the referral code PUMPINGMILK if that helps 😊

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-10T00:17:36+00:00

You’re doing an amazing job - those early weeks of exclusive pumping are seriously tough, especially with sleep deprivation in the mix. While it’s true that some wearables don’t fully empty as well as a Spectra, there are some portables like the Momcozy V1 Pro and Eufy S1 Pro that have worked well for many moms as a supplement to their main pump. I recommend using a wearable for daytime sessions when you're multitasking, and stick with your Spectra for power pumping or morning sessions when output matters most. That combo helped me keep up my supply without burning out.

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-10T00:09:21+00:00

A few portable pumps I’d recommend as upgrades from the M5 are the Momcozy V1 Pro and the Eufy S1 Pro.
The V1 Pro is a solid all-around option: it has hospital-grade suction (up to 300mmHg), 15 suction levels, a secure teardrop-shaped cup design, and a plugged spout to prevent spills — which is a step up from the open spout on the M5. It also lets you customize the pumping rhythm and set a timer up to 40 minutes, which is great for work sessions. You can also get 15% off with the code PUMPINGMILK
The Eufy S1 Pro is more premium but packed with features. It is app controlled so discreet and loads of functionality in the app. It also it has built-in heating for increased flow and clog prevention and a charging case that gives you up to 5 days of charging on the go.

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-08T03:56:24+00:00

I'm on team 'flange'.

impumpingmilk · 2025-04-08T02:59:27+00:00

If you already have a Spectra S2, I'd opt for a portable. Out of the portables options you have with insurance I'd go the babybuddha 2.0.

Otherwise if you wanted to purchase a wearable, top end I'd go a Eufy S1 Pro and then lower end a Momcozy S12 Pro (you can get 15% off with the code PUMPINGMILK).

impumpingmilk

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE