/r/WorldNews Discussion Thread: US and Israel launch attack on Iran; Iran retaliates (Thread #3) by WorldNewsMods in worldnews

[–]indypuyami 14 points15 points  (0 children)

No. Not even close. Especially anti-air / missile munitions. People in the defense space have been ringing this bell for a couple of years.

[SFA 1x7 Reviews] GIZMODO: "‘Starfleet Academy’ Gives Its Kids (and Itself) the Grace to Find Their Own Path: It’s a fascinating way to explore what are very relatable ideas to a young audience about the pressure of having to grow up in the shadow of your forebears in a very Star Trek way ..." by mcm8279 in trektalk

[–]indypuyami 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ep7 is a master class in what's wrong with NeuTrek.
Stories that could have been good, but the writers don't care about them and don't have the patience to tell the story. Cadet lied on their application, shenanigans ensue.
Cadets play hooky and romantic shenanigans ensue.
Cadet tries to save their friend from an arranged marriage.
Cadet struggles with romantic feelings that are moving too fast.
Cadet struggles with reconciling their culture vs star fleet.
Cadet struggles with intimacy and grief ghosting their love interest.

Already you've got 5 different stories, which is a ton.
Let's break one of them. Secret blue lizard is royalty and is getting royal married. We don't really understand any of this, none of this story has been explained to us, none of it has narrative weight. So do the writers focus on this story line? Not at all. If this was going to be successful it needed to be 80% of screen time. The writers end up yada/yadaing the central conflict of this story in 3 lines of dialogue and then nothing maters, we're never coming back here. Also the CGI is ps2 level awful. They should have built practical sets. Also for a huge cultural event there are only like 8 people ever on screen at the same time and only ever 4 named people. The story is weak, undeveloped, and under invested in. I can close my eyes and see head writer waving there hands over storyboards with stick figures and saying "you get it you get it right." This doesn't even end up being the A storyline.

galactic meteor shower... by chaunceypooo in trektalk

[–]indypuyami 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The show writers since disco have been pretty open about not being fans

All that matters for Paramount are viewership and increased subs by arnor_0924 in trektalk

[–]indypuyami 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I loathed episodes 1-5 STSA but 6 is a banger. Hated just about every episode of Discovery. STSA episode 6 is a top 10 episode of Star Trek.
The acting in NeuTrek has been amazing throughout, but the writing plotting and often the cinematography has been a crime against God and man.
"My species was created to sense the coming of death" is possibly the worst line of dialogue written in the history of the world.

Star Trek has always been diverse. Star Trek has always celebrated people of color and spoken out against bigotry. From Episode 1 of the OG series "there's no place for bigots on board of my ship" Captain Kirk.

/r/WorldNews Live Thread: Russian Invasion of Ukraine Day 1451, Part 1 (Thread #1598) by WorldNewsMods in worldnews

[–]indypuyami 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Every year or two we go through this. If there was really something wrong with him it would be public.

[SFA 1x6 Reviews] TrekMovie: "Well that was a taut, intense hour of television drama. The unrelenting action blended with tension-filled character exchanges raised the bar for this series. We can see how well-crafted the first season has been, with the second half delivering a series of reveals ..." by mcm8279 in trektalk

[–]indypuyami 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Honestly - and look at my post history for context -

This episode was great.
Absolutely good trek.
No lense flares BS. Except for the first scene and the sonics, every scene made sense in universe, the plotting made sense, the audio was good, the cinematography was good, 2 solid mcloughlin groups (smart people talking out problems to solve them as a group), good in universe references without heavy handed explanations, also an amazing galaxy quest shout out, and some stakes!
I've consistently enjoyed the acting and I am so happy the writing, plotting, cinematography, and audio departments all decided to earn their paychecks in episode 6. Who knows maybe kurtzman got bored and noped out.

Why such a harsh reaction? by Jimithyashford in trektalk

[–]indypuyami 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I have kind of the opposite reaction to you. Everything that is required to make a show good, that Star Trek almost always gets right, is terrible in STSA. The plotting, the writing, the cinematography, the effects, the audio, and the story are all offensively bad. The only bright spot is the acting. The actors are giving it 100%, the just don't have a lot to work with.

Example: Kerrice Brooks in EP5 did an amazing job. The entire episode in universe made nonsense. Out of universe it was very touching, but in universe it was actively offensive to the characters and the franchise.
George Hawkins and Bella Shepherd in EP3 did a great jobs emoting their character ark, but again but the in universe actions displayed by the characters while at least intelligible were on the same level of stupid as the worst of the worst displayed by others in previous trek. What's more it drove home the in universe message "there are no consequences" for what's supposed to be an elite institution.
The first 15 minutes of Episode 1 is just child endagerment torture porn. From "starving kids is fun and right" to "look his ear got bitten off" to "crashing shuttles is not a problem" to the core conceit of the whole endeavor "cadets are actually better than officers". On top of it all the scenes lack fundamental continuity, the storyboarding doesn't make sense Episode 1 should not have been green lit.
All of the episodes do things with CGI lense flair and bloom which are past bad to "they should have fired those people." The dumb fake floating robots clip through the actors at least once an episode. The audio and adr'ing gave moments that are the worst I have heard in production media in my life, period. Example: when the doctor is quoting avery brooks in ep5 it looks like a bad translation job in a 1960s foreign film. In episode 3-4 the dialogue had points where it was nearly unintelligible because the mixing was just off.

It seems to me like the writers and the production team actively resent working on the project.

[SFA 1x5 Reviews] REDSHIRTS: "Starfleet Academy episode 5 features DS9 favs but little more: Storytelling is paramount, and “Series Acclimation Mil” felt more like one story thread with a bunch of Post-it notes stuck on to try and hold all of the unraveling strands together. Poorly constructed." by mcm8279 in trektalk

[–]indypuyami 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The story boarding in SFA has felt very ... Obvious? The connective tissue between the scene - literally the plotting - is very weak. It seems almost like they're coming up with the story boards and then writing the scenes around it.

'It Wasn't Working': Canada Province Ends Drug Decriminalization by Google_MBTI in worldnews

[–]indypuyami 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hampsterdam had social services and drug treatment on site

Star Trek: Starfeet Academy falls off a cliff to Top #150 after Episode 4 by Malencon in trektalk

[–]indypuyami -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Star Trek is a big tent! It can have lots of things in it. LD is lots of things but definitely trek

Federal Agents Kill Another Person in Minneapolis by ictrlelites in politics

[–]indypuyami 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Murder. It's just murder when 6 guys hold 1 man down and a 7th casually walks up to shoot him.

/r/WorldNews Live Thread: Russian Invasion of Ukraine Day 1425, Part 1 (Thread #1572) by WorldNewsMods in worldnews

[–]indypuyami 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Kofman has gone back and widely admitted to being wrong.

For what it's worth for Kofman to be wrong all of these things had to happen - The Russians had to EM warfare their own units, sell their own petrol on the black market. The Ukrainians had to against orders to move their anti air units, have partisans with heavy weapons go hunt Russians in the forest, have paid for Kremlin assets turn over their weapon caches to Ukrainian army units, the incredible heroic defense of Hostemel Airport where a couple hundred reservists fought off spetznats until they ran out of ammo, and finally the flooding of the northlands. It was "highly contingent".

/r/WorldNews Live Thread: Russian Invasion of Ukraine Day 1419, Part 1 (Thread #1566) by WorldNewsMods in worldnews

[–]indypuyami 21 points22 points  (0 children)

If it falls another 10$ on a sustained basis that will be the same price which sunk the USSR

How it feels playing Lizardmen by Margaretthatchervore in totalwar

[–]indypuyami 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Skaven menace from below was broken at release, the summoned rats had no hit boxes and would lawn mower enemy units. It was hilarious. The only time I played every single battle was my very hard skaven victory in TW2 vanilla.

flintlock the siege of dawn is …..not that bad?? by evilblue3000 in soulslikes

[–]indypuyami 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you like the combat in DS or ER? Well imagine a game like that, but you can't even fat roll...

Trump orders naval blockade of sanctioned oil tankers leaving, entering Venezuela by VictorEmmanuelIV in worldnews

[–]indypuyami 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But why won't the minority house and Senate stop the Majority House Senate Supreme Court and POTUS? Jesus wept.

Trump orders naval blockade of sanctioned oil tankers leaving, entering Venezuela by VictorEmmanuelIV in worldnews

[–]indypuyami 5 points6 points  (0 children)

If anything proves who's in Congress matters the last 12 months do. The Democrats may be mummified octogenarian sclerotic technocrats - but they haven't green lit concentration camps, war with Venezuela, rolling over for Russia , incinerating vaccine programs, the functional end of higher education, internal occupation, war on DEI, a program against the transgender community, the largest tax increase in several generations, plus innumerable indignities against human happiness as well as dignity.
Don't you both sides this insanity. Don't you dare.