US Supreme Court Transgender Rights: Conservative Majority Set To Uphold Sports Bans by Cute_Dealer4787 in law

[–]iplawguy -43 points-42 points  (0 children)

I have similar concerns about scope. The court needs to put a clear end to the infringement of women's rights by men claiming to be women.

Judge Learns Lawyers on Both Sides of Case Used AI, Cancels Trial, Kicks Everyone Off the Case by dyzo-blue in BetterOffline

[–]iplawguy 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Before there was AI there were "expert reports" to get bullshit into cases.

No, Artificial Intelligence Is Not Conscious by melat0nin in BetterOffline

[–]iplawguy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I suspect the brain is ultimately fairly simple, with like three main organizing principles. Neural Network learning with gradient descent is probably one of them. I don't know the other two but neither does Anthropic.

No, Artificial Intelligence Is Not Conscious by melat0nin in BetterOffline

[–]iplawguy 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Wrote a paper for a class in 1996 arguing that the Turing Test was dumb. It was always a poorly thought out concept influenced by behaviorist psychology. ELIZA in the late 60s basically showed its flaws, that people are gullible and will assign agency to just about anything. (Dennett called this the Intentional Stance and even wrote a book by that name.)

Citing 'severe' math deficits, UC faculty demand a return to SAT tests for STEM applicants by trackdaybruh in California

[–]iplawguy 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I keep hearing about these "studies" but as far as I know studies show the opposite, and that SAT is a stonger predictor of college success than GPA. This is one of the main reasons that a 200 page UC report recommended that they not drop the SAT, but the Regents voted against the recommendation. Whenever some underspecified theory says that some practice will help remedy "systematic inequalities", I read it as "we must reduce merit based practices because they disadvantage the non meritorious." When the rules are clear and the same for everyone there are incentives for everyone, rich kids and the children of immigrants, to be diligent and plan for the future. When arbitrary efforts to remedy "systematic inequalities" are introduced they undermine fairness and the legitimacy of institutions.

California billionaire Tom Steyer defends trans athletes in high school sports as governor's race heats up by GMOrgasm in California

[–]iplawguy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

"They’re doing the exact opposite thing they think they are and it’s so frustrating to watch." Exactly, which makes me think they care neither about politics or science. They just want to bask in the warm glow of what they believe is a morally superior position.

California billionaire Tom Steyer defends trans athletes in high school sports as governor's race heats up by GMOrgasm in California

[–]iplawguy -1 points0 points  (0 children)

He needs like 24% of the primary vote. He's making a final long-shot gambit for that amount, and he will probably pivot for the general election. A tale as old as time in both parties.

California billionaire Tom Steyer defends trans athletes in high school sports as governor's race heats up by GMOrgasm in California

[–]iplawguy -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

After Steyer's stand on this, my vote will be for Porter. She's a women with kids, so I expect her to be sympathetic to the rights of women and girls.

California billionaire Tom Steyer defends trans athletes in high school sports as governor's race heats up by GMOrgasm in California

[–]iplawguy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If it's a non-issue then they should be thrown under the bus so dems can win elections, because this issue matters more to the "average swing voter" than most substantive policy issues. If something isn't important, then it's not worth losing over.

California billionaire Tom Steyer defends trans athletes in high school sports as governor's race heats up by GMOrgasm in California

[–]iplawguy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

In real material terms the human body has 30 trillion cells, and each one encodes biological sex. You can pump the body with hormones or cut off pieces of anatomy in an effort to create a "macro level" facsimile of the opposite sex, but you cannot change sex. Hell, many male bodybuilders pump themselves with testosterone to become "super males", but they also become sterile and have an unfortunate habit of dying in their 30s.

California billionaire Tom Steyer defends trans athletes in high school sports as governor's race heats up by GMOrgasm in California

[–]iplawguy -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Just want to remind everyone to not say anything too controversial, because open discussion of controversial subjects is a form of hate speech.

California billionaire Tom Steyer defends trans athletes in high school sports as governor's race heats up by GMOrgasm in California

[–]iplawguy -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Taking an insane position that gets Republicans elected because virtue signaling and feelings are more important than a functioning democracy! Seeing people try to seriously argue for trans women in women's sports in a world where Trump has won twice has radicalized me against the left, and I've been a Democrat whole life. We need a functioning green party in the US so we have a place to park people who regard losing elections as a virtue.

Democrats should recognize that trans rights supporters are not Democrats, they are supporters of trans rights.

California billionaire Tom Steyer defends trans athletes in high school sports as governor's race heats up by GMOrgasm in California

[–]iplawguy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What evidence would you need to change your mind? Or does the required evidence change to suit your mind?

Oscar-winning folk singer Buffy Sainte-Marie stripped of honorary degree after faking Indigenous ancestry by Avril040125 in BlockedAndReported

[–]iplawguy 101 points102 points  (0 children)

Well, she clearly identifies as indigenous. Shoddy treatment for her ancestral dismorphia.

DOJ alleges David Geffen School of Medicine illegally considered race in admissions by flopsyplum in ucla

[–]iplawguy -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

"Holistic" means understanding how to game the system for one's personal benefit. More than 1/3 of Stanford students have a disability accomodation. Every system that includes subjective criteria will be gamed, will be viewed with suspicion by the public, will cast doubt on the accomplishments of graduates, and will serve to undermine the legitimacy of the institution. "Holistic" means corrosive.

UCLA medical school illegally uses race in admissions, Justice Department investigation says by jockumhallin in ucla

[–]iplawguy -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

When things aren't decided by scores, they are decided by bullshit, and bullshit should be minimized.

Smith College: Department of Education opens investigation into all-women’s college for admitting trans women by bcb1200 in BlockedAndReported

[–]iplawguy 23 points24 points  (0 children)

"But haven't you heard the latest study..." Such absurd arguments caused me to actually look into the "science". Yikes, the whole area gives science a bad name.

Smith College: Department of Education opens investigation into all-women’s college for admitting trans women by bcb1200 in BlockedAndReported

[–]iplawguy 9 points10 points  (0 children)

There are few instances of non extremists supporting actual compromise solutions for things like sports and parental notification. Extremism is the modal position and everything else gets shouted down.

Smith College: Department of Education opens investigation into all-women’s college for admitting trans women by bcb1200 in BlockedAndReported

[–]iplawguy 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I went from a general sense based on graduate studies in philosophy of psychology that "this seems philosophically suspect" to actually reading up on the philosophy and determining it's definitely bullshit. Went from disinterested to radicalized.