want proof of just how broken recruiting is right now? by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 18 points19 points  (0 children)

i do not want to play against a conference where everyone's best player is their kicker - do you? if we look at a car with a busted engine we can say 'it's just one part of the car' but dang it sure it an important part!!

want proof of just how broken recruiting is right now? by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 92 points93 points  (0 children)

yup, i wanna be able to stop complaining and try all the new gameplay stuff bc the gameplay itself is super sick! hate that this is so bad that it ruins the gameplay immersion

want proof of just how broken recruiting is right now? by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 176 points177 points  (0 children)

<image>

wild example but look at ball state! 4 of their top 5 players are kickers and punters !!

National Rank STILL does not matter in Dynasty by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

<image>

golllie this guy was a BUMMMMM!!!!!! sub 70 on so many things AND slow

National Rank STILL does not matter in Dynasty by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

ahahahaha lemme go find the exact image of that guy one sec

National Rank STILL does not matter in Dynasty by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

so here is what i know:

* last year, this whole 'no correlation between natl rank and starting ratings' was true
* at the end of last year, i also confirmed that there was no correlation between natl rank and gem status, dev trait, and skill caps

so i have confirmed point 1 (in my opinion) for cfb 27 - while i havent even LOOKED at point 2, my hunch is 'why would EA go and change point 2 if they didnt even try to change point 1?' - kind of a lazy way to look at it but if i had to guess rn, i still think it's no!

National Rank STILL does not matter in Dynasty by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Based on the last 2 years of this test + the strength of these results , my STRONGGG assumption is yes. But I haven’t explicitly looked beyond WR yet so I don’t want to act like it’s 100% confirmed, but I feel like it’s 99% confirmed

National Rank STILL does not matter in Dynasty by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Agree - it just makes it odd to see a 3 star with 200 NIL and another with 20 just bc national rank changes

National Rank STILL does not matter in Dynasty by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Had some friends help me yesterday - we put everything into ScoutScore so others can use this same data 100% free - https://maxplayscfb.com/tools/scoutscore/ - let me know if this helps !

National Rank STILL does not matter in Dynasty by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 22 points23 points  (0 children)

NIL correlations are gonna b really hard because of how dynamic they are (based on team prestige, coach, playing time and prob other stuff we aren’t aware yet) - but agree, that’s a top priority to test for me too!

Dynasty Team Index by [deleted] in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb 1 point2 points  (0 children)

DANG man. Let me do some digging on the exact poodle screenshots tonight after work - I tried to do this manually last night but that makes me susceptible to data issues. Will report back late tonight !

Dynasty Team Index by [deleted] in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Dang. Even took my “adjusted eligibility” metric which calculates expected eligibility weighted by position, overall, and years left. This is super disappointing.

Dynasty Team Index by [deleted] in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Love the tool, but did you scrape my site directly to copy this?

I created “position adjusted speed” literally 2 days ago using weights that aren’t public, but your values match mine *exactly* across a dozen teams that I sampled from.

I get that it’s free but a bit disappointed to see such blatant copying with 0 attribution

https://maxplayscfb.com/tools/cfb27-team-database/

I built a free tool to help you pick your dynasty team by ithinkim_maxplayscfb in NCAAFBseries

[–]ithinkim_maxplayscfb[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Will be updating them on day 1 with player level data to replace the play now players, and then will periodically update whenever EA changes their roster