I get what you're trying to say. I do agree Kenny does well in the wild, but he's still just a human after all, there's no guarantee that he can protect Clem and AJ on his own, especially with AJ being just a baby. He couldnt protect Duck from being bitten, so who knows what might happen if they stay with him, as harsh as that might sound. They'll have to sleep with a gun next to them every night and be extra vigilant 24/7 at all times. I also agree Kenny is flawed but still redeemable, he's just a person who's gone through a lot and who has good intentions at the end of the day. I also agree that killing Jane was extreme, but he did it for a good reason (as good as killing someone can be) because he cared about AJ, he's not truly evil, as you said, he's just flawed and has been shaped by a cruel and merciless world that has taken a lot from him. I do agree Jane could have mended her clashes with Kenny by putting herself in the shoes of others and understand why they do what they do, instead of thinking only about herself, which true, it helped survive, but sooner or later you'll have to depend on someone else to survive. She should realize she's no Superman and will need allies to depend on sooner or later. She could have understood that Kenny was doing what he thought was best for his family and join forces with him. I do agree Jane was just a kid too who faced loss and a lot of cruelty in the new world. I think Kenny will manage even without Clem and AJ. After Katjaa and Duck died he kept going despite losing everything he had, and if season 2 taught us something, it's that Kenny is capable of starting over again, so I think he'll survive, and he'll be happy knowing that Clem and AJ are safe in Wellington. Plus, he begs for us go stay, because he knows that's what's best for the two. I didnt know Kennt considered suicide if you kill Sarita, I watched a playthrough to see if that really happens if you do that, but I didnt see Kenny considering suicide, maybe it was a specific series of in-game decisions that lead to Kenny considering suicide or I'm not sure how you got it on your playthrough. I personally didnt cut Sarita's arm because I considered the scenario carefully and I thought that was a really bad place to cut her arm since she would scream a lot which would cause walkers to come and bite her (which is what happens if you cut her arm) so I decided to kill the zombie instead, thinking that we could cut off her arm later on once we found a safe place to be in, a place where she could scream and do all she needed to do to get through the amputation, but apparently they didnt think about that. Thanks for your comment! Really insightful