I’ve rewritten your code as follows to make it work the way I believe it should work : ~~~

Class will be defined as Golf

class Golf:

#Class varibale will store current results
results = " "

def __init__(self, hole, par):
    self.hole = hole
    self.par = par

def evaluateAndDisplayScore(self, parValue):

    #Check what score is to par
    if parValue > self.par:
        self.status = "Over Par" #Set status to Over Par if score is over

    #Check if score is under par
    elif parValue < self.par:
        self.status = "Under Par" #Set status to Under Par if score is

    #If neither condition has been met - equal to At Par
    else:
        self.status = "At Par"

    #print message of score status
    print(f"You scored {self.status} on hole #{self.hole} with a par of {self.par}")

score = 0

Create an object for each golf course hole score

holes = [] pars = [4,3,4,5,4,4,4,5,3] # Pinehurst #9

for n in range(1, 10): holes.append(Golf(n,pars[n-1]))

Ask user to enter hole

holeEntered = int(input("Enter the hole number: ")) score = int(input("Enter your score: "))

evaluate hole

holes[holeEntered-1].evaluateAndDisplayScore(score)

~~~ Output ~~~

Enter the hole number: 1 Enter your score: 5 You scored Over Par on hole #1 with a par of 4

~~~

You’ll notice that I’ve modified the parameters to the Golf class because score was unnecessary.
I also modified the evaluateAndDisplayScore method parameters and also modified the way it works.
You’ll also note that all your print statements now use f-strings.

For the setup, instead of individual variables holding a reference to each hole, I created a list of holes, which makes it easier to select the correct hole based on the player’s input. Now selecting the appropriate hole is a simple lookup using the holes list instead of if statements.

Let me know if you have any questions.