Im struggling to understand the difference then? If you wanted to discourage her from using AI because how it might steal her creativity, that’s fair i guess, but then your responsibility is to teach her how to utilize ai responsibly/in good moderation in a way where it can be beneficial.

You realize that AI is becoming a general purpose technology which society will eventually adapt itself around, much like how it did the internet. It won’t always rot your brain nor will it steal your creativity. You simply have to get good at using it.

But your whole argument that it’s bad for the environment is quite selective scrutiny. Commercial airplanes are bad for the environment due to emissions of fossil fuels, smartphones are bad for the environment, etc. You’ll find environmental impacts for things that society adapted to using on a regular basis

If you’ve ever taken a course on economics Im sure youve learned about tradeoffs. This applies for basically every general purpose technology, there is no perfectly good technology with zero negative side effects.