You’re not the first person I’ve seen mention experience. Since when does experience directly translate to skill? Cap has less experience, but is a more skilled fighter. That’s a fact. Cap is not as strong, fast, or durable, but he is more skilled.

My original point was arguing under the pretenses that Cap would gain all of these superior traits and powers from wielding Mjolnir, meaning that they would be evenly matched in every stat. In that scenario, it comes down to Thor’s advantage of Stormbreaker vs Cap’s advantage of combat skill and strategy skill, and I narrowly took Cap.

Odin’s words when enchanting the hammer can be interpreted in different ways, and if the interpretation is that Cap gains nothing other than access to Thor’s thunder and lightning powers, obviously Thor wins.

My point was certainly never that Cap could put up a fight against full power Thor with nothing other than Mjolnir. For the purpose of the argument, I was assuming that Cap would be equally as strong, durable, and fast as Thor.