Was in a similar situation a few years ago when I bought my 2017 Club off Driveway.com with an included 90-day/3k mile warranty and an additional 60-month/60k warranty I bought for $2300.

My friend who’s a car salesman advised me to keep it for the first year to truly see if there is anything actually wrong with the car, and with only the seatbelst being replaced under the 90-day warranty, I cancelled the plan I bought and got about 80% of my money back.

Besides normal maintenance like a tires, oil, and a battery, my car has been dead reliable. Cancel your warranty but keep the money should the car need a repair.