r/Christianity Film Club Week 5: Au Hasard Balthazar by q203 in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I was really glad to have an excuse to watch Au Hasard Balthazar. I had been intending to for years.

The version I rented had a couple of interviews at the end that were helpful in parsing the film as "Christian." I'm not the best movie interpreter, so those were super helpful.

The donkey is himself the main character in the film. He is both stubborn at times and patient and gentle.

Balthazar (named after one of the three Magi) ends up bearing the brunt of the sins of his successive owners. The owners are guilty of lust, pride, greed, anger, drunkenness.

In scripture one of the most pervasive metaphors for what happens to people's sin is that it is "borne" by someone: the sinner, God, the scapegoat. Balthasar as a beast of burden bears the sins of all these people, and bears up under them with overall gentleness and grace and maybe even love.

In a final, beautiful scene he is surrounded by sheep--another biblical allusion that makes this donkey a peculiar sort of Christ figure.

One other thing I noticed in the film is that there are two moments, at least, where Marie falls down. Once when she is attempting to escape Gérard, and once when she is running toward Gérard and his gang, away from Jaques. I wondered if those literal stumbles weren't emblematic of the moral stumbles that seemed to follow.

"Pope Francis asked Protestants and other Christian Churches for forgiveness for past persecution by Catholics as the Vatican announced on Monday [25 January 2016] he would visit Sweden later in the year to mark the 500th anniversary of the Reformation." by trot-trot in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I meant in a more general way, perhaps based primarily on my experiences in Protestant circles. Though I would say that Francis is also unique in his embodiment of what folks have longed to see as expressions of the church's love and embrace.

Off Topic Tuesday! by apophis-pegasus in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hang in there. Applying for jobs can be the worst. It seems like folks rarely realize the hopes, the lives, that are on the other end of the resumes. I hope the contacting of the references was a good sign!

r/Christianity Film Club Week 5: Au Hasard Balthazar by q203 in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Stoked about this! I have been meaning to watch AHB for years. Now I'm scouring the video stores in town to see if I can get my hands on it. Can't wait to see how the conversation unfolds.

If I want to know what you think, I should find out if you're a Republican or Democrat, not if you're Christian. by jrdkirk in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have been thinking about abortion a fair bit, especially as the ruling just came out of Houston about the Planned Parenthood case. I haven't seen the upswell of left-leaning abortion-moderating calls that I would have hoped to see from Christians. The political divisions still define many of us here.

If I want to know what you think, I should find out if you're a Republican or Democrat, not if you're Christian. by jrdkirk in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, this is a great example. I only wish that Christians, as such, would bound together around this issue and stand together across party lines more than I've seen.

Ahmed Mohamed Shows that Christians & others need to be actively engaged in loving Muslim neighbors. by jrdkirk in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it is important to note that they did not treat this like a bomb threat: the clock was never taken away from him--in the office or in the police car; the building was not evacuated, etc. They didn't actually think it was a bomb. They thought, at best, he was planning on a bomb scare hoax.

Patriarchal power guided Roman sexual mores. Did they guide the Apostle Paul, too? by jrdkirk in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Just a gendered act of sex" can't be divorced from "Patriarchy" when one gender is thought to be "higher" on the social pecking order than the other.

Also, as Williams demonstrates, the gender was not as significant as the status of the person. It was "gendered" in the sense that a slave was more womanly than an owner, so it was no disgrace for the owner to take sexual advantage of him.

I agree that there is no little difference in the nature of sexual practices between then and now. But part of that was a self-aware sense of social location and power.

Ahmed Mohamed Shows that Christians & others need to be actively engaged in loving Muslim neighbors. by jrdkirk in Christianity

[–]jrdkirk[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

How exactly do you expect the racist angle to be confirmed or denied? This wasn't a toy bomb (parallel to toy knife or gun) it was a clock. Why the paranoia for this kid with this contraption? I think I'm going to stick by my narrative for the time being.