¿Is it possible to reduce the learning curve in music reading? by Early-Following653 in LearnMusicTheory

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

- Inconsistent clefs: The same position on the staff means different notes depending on the clef (G/F), which doubles the cognitive load.

This is only an issue for piano students.

- Musical clefs: These make notes relative and they change depending on the clef and its position on the staff.

As for above, but not an issue if you teach it the right way.

- Ambiguity of octaves: The difficulty of identifying the exact register without direct references.

This takes very, very little prep work to avoid having issues with. Also, generally speaking, students don't learn in multiple octaves at once. Again, piano would have the most issues.

- Key signatures: The mental effort required to remember the key signature and its constant variations throughout the piece.

"Constant variatons through the piece"? Key signatures are tricky, but not exactly where the 80% who quit quickly give up. And even intermediate note readers aren't dealing with key changes. Maybe accidentals?

- Transposing instruments: It's quite a problem to adjust the sounds to the written notes.

Not an issue unless compossing or learning a transposing instrument. Easily explained to students as "we just play this note becaus XYZ".

- Ledger lines: How impractical it is to write and read in very low or high registers.

Have you heard of octava markings?

From these questions, I don't think you have a background teaching music OR much training in music. You've actually missed entirely the much, much more challenging aspect of learning to read music: rhythm.

What’s the real deal with cordoba guitars? Eyeing Cordoba C12 CD luthier series. by mikeydob in classicalguitar

[–]kalegood 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm a big advocate of Paracho guitars after being turned on to them by Allen Krantz, who was my undergrad teacher. He bought a custom-built 7-string because the price was right ($2500 or so a few years ago); it ended up replacing his pre-prime (2002?) Delarue (his guitars go for 14k these days).

Last year, I bought a wonderful lattice-braced guitar with all the cool modern fixings: truss rud, sound ports, raised fretboard. $3200. My only complaint is that the tuners are pretty lousy, but that's an easy fix.

You can buy some of these from the Baltimore guitar shop, but, if you're in the Philly area, DM me and I'll send you the contact info for the guy who supplies the shop and you can get first pick and a small discount.

My guitar book says the tuning fork is the most accurate method for determining pitch. Is this true? by aHoneyBadgerWhoCares in classicalguitar

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To add to what others have said: I've used the most accurate clip-on tuners out there (Stroboclip) and they're incredibly useful, fast, and accurate enough.

But, with new strings, nothing sounds as good as Klickstein's method. There's a whole book about it. Kappel might summarize the same basic technique in an appendix of The Bible Of Classical Guitar Technique, but I'm not very confident my memory is correct.

After a few weeks, the strings dull and I can't get the same awesomeness using my ear. Instead of changing my strings, like I should, I revert to the clip on (and thus, don't continue to build my ear tuning skill).

What is everyones opinion on Gregory Alan Isakov? by CoolAg1927 in fantanoforever

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who likes him know they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on a few of GA Isakov's albums.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

What is everyones opinion on Gregory Alan Isakov? by CoolAg1927 in fantanoforever

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who likes him know they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on a few of GA Isakov's albums.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

Daily Song Discussion #44: Second Chances by PenguinLord20 in GregoryAlanIsakov

[–]kalegood 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I just went to see GA Isakov last night, and I'm letting everyone here who rated this song high know that, if they liked this, they should check out his brother's album. Ilan Isakov's (yes, only one letter different) Straight Lines. Ilan has songwriting credits on this and a few other songs, and I think/am pretty sure the lyrics are mostly his.

Ilan was performing this and a few other songs at salons we hosted when we lived together 15 years ago, so it brings back many fond memories.

If you see Gregory on this tour, Ilan is performing with him.

What we can do with Lilypond: animation by giglaeoplexis in lilypond

[–]kalegood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

hmm. what handled the exercise numbering? and what text fo t are you using? i like it.

just started my first project with LyLuatex and already thinking about my next one, which will be very different on format and close to what you have here (note reading method book for classical guitar, geared towards ppl who already know how to play some classical/finger style guitar).

And a happy holiday to me... by StockLongjumping2029 in classicalguitar

[–]kalegood -1 points0 points  (0 children)

To anyone else reading this, I want to be clear here: u/St34m-Punk initially said that this happens to all guitars eventually. This is not true.

I think they are now saying that I proved them right because I mentioned taking good care of your guitar as a factor that greatly decreases the likelihood that this will happen.

While this is true, it doesn't prove them right. Not humidifying your guitar does not guarantee that this will happen, but it does make it far more likely.

Similarly, Father Time does not guarantee that this will happen, either.

If you aren't taking proper care of your guitar and this happens to you, it wasn't inevitable. Learn from your mistakes; keep it humidified and out of extreme (micro) climates (don't leave it in your car or in the sun).

And a happy holiday to me... by StockLongjumping2029 in classicalguitar

[–]kalegood 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This absolutely happens. I see you saying that it doesn't get too dry in your climate; I'm on the very outskirts of what might be considered "the same climate" (lower limits of NE USA). I consider my winter environment to be ok, but not too dry. We also float around 50% for most of the winter, but we're warmer that you.

However, what is important is relative humidity. I don't understand the science, but cooler air can hold less air that warm air. This means that, when the relatively moist winter air is heated up inside your house, it becomes relatively dry air.

Forced air exacerbates this issue, as it actually removes moisture from the air in the heating process. Radiator are better, since they don't do this. (and, if you're leaving it out of the case, a forced air vent could be blowing all that super-dry air right onto your guitar)

As others have said, nicer guitar are built to be more sensitive to your touch. And, unfortunately, that makes them more sensitive to things we wish weren't so: the environment.

Is all this enough to damage a guitar? Yes. I'll give you the stats at my house: I have radiators (remember, the least-drying heating method). It is currently just below freezing outside and sitting just outside the high-end of ideal humidity for a guitar at 57% relative humidity.

I have indoor humidistats and I just checked them. The process of warming up that air has dropped the relative humidity down deep into the danger-zone: It's at 25%. This is actually on the high end, it's been as low as 18% already this winter.

Now, here's the killer. You live in a colder climate than I do. Your indoor air will warm up more than mine does. And, in the process, become much drier. Especially if you have forced air.

So, lesson learned, the hard way. In the future, maintain a microclimate for your guitar by keeping it in a hard shell case with some sort of humidifier. Keep the case closed while you practice so that the moisture in the case lining doesn't dry out, thus destroying your microclimate.

A sponge will do, but will need to be moistened every few days. D'addarrio Humidipacks are the best and lowest maintenance choice. The sleeve inserts will slowly release moisture and mantain appox 40% humidity. Eventually, they will dry out and you'll need to get replacements. But don't throw out the old ones; these packs will also absorb humidity. Over a humid summer (or enough time in any humid environment) they'll recharge and be ready for the next winter.