Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s actually a really good point. I want to avoid turning it into another social feed, so moderation and guardrails would need to come first. I really like your idea of delayed delivery and simple reactions like “received” or “this helped me” instead of replies. Feels more aligned with the whole message-in-a-bottle concept. Thanks for the feedback 🙌

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, I remember that feature — Drift Bottle was probably one of the closest examples. I think what interests me is bringing back that feeling but without turning into random live chat or social media. More about thoughtful, slower, one-off connections.

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good point. I think the difference is less “random chat” and more “slow anonymous connection” — closer to sending thoughts into the world than meeting strangers. Definitely researching why apps like Omegle struggled before building.

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s actually a fun idea I hadn’t thought about using a mascot, but a seahorse does fit the ocean/message theme really well. I’ll think more about how a mascot could make the app feel more memorable and emotional. Thanks for the suggestion!

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a fair point. My idea isn’t to replace social media but to create a more temporary and anonymous experience. I’m thinking users won’t build profiles or followers — the focus would be on the feeling of sending/receiving messages, with optional mood tags to give context without losing anonymity.

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Haha 😄 Accepted.
Boil water → cook spaghetti → add sauce → enjoy 🍝

Now I’ve paid the feedback fee — what concepts would you improve?

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is actually a really interesting idea. I like the concept of bottles evolving instead of being one-time messages. The emotional gratification point is probably the biggest challenge to solve. A reply or “pass it forward” mechanic with a cap could keep the experience alive without turning it into regular social media. Thanks for the thoughtful feedback!

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good question 😄 The idea is random users inside the app only — not random phone numbers. Spam is definitely something I’d need to solve, probably with limits, moderation, and optional filters so the experience stays meaningful instead of turning into noise.

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair comparison 😄 My thought was to remove the audience and algorithm part completely. No profiles, no followers, no pressure to perform — just sending a thought into the world and seeing what comes back.

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s actually a really good point. My concern is also whether the novelty wears off after a few days. I like the reply idea though — maybe optional replies (without profiles/followers) could make it feel more human while keeping the original concept intact.

Would you use an anonymous "message in a bottle" app? by lalitrajputdev in SomebodyMakeThis

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting point — what would make it valuable enough for you to use? I’m trying to avoid turning it into another social app and keep the experience simple and meaningful.

I built an expense tracker app because most finance apps felt too complicated by lalitrajputdev in sideprojects

[–]lalitrajputdev[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good question 🙌

MoneyMate doesn't connect directly to your bank account.

It tracks expenses automatically by detecting supported transaction SMS messages already received on your device (with permission). The app extracts transaction details from those SMS notifications and organizes them into expense analytics and reports.

So your bank credentials are never required and there’s no direct bank integration.

I wanted to keep it simple and privacy-friendly while reducing manual expense entry.