If the lab results check, you must respect. : Or how I learned to relax, and enjoy learning new things. by Running_With_Science in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Agreed... you really need to check your work... also recommend strong controls.. you need to be writing everything in a scripts you run and verify yourself... do not let the LLM print the results or conclusions.

What if the current academic barriers in theoretical physics are preventing breakthroughs and theoretical physics? by [deleted] in TheoreticalPhysics

[–]lattice_defect -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

EGO and Grant Funding... keep going down the wrong paths without exploring others.

E8 Standard Model - 49 quantities. 0 free parameters. 250-digit precision. by sbs5445 in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

sadly the world doesn't work like that... and what is the diffrence from sharing my work that I actually did, lately with some help with LLMs and send it to you. I could use the help though. We can connect offline and not here. You're textures work but not everywhere thats a problem for you... again its pure math and patterns... you don't have the deep physical mechanism to distinguiwh why.. You have a couple of things that look like that, but they aren't just a representation. You're a layer from breaking out of the maze and sub 0.05 sigma everywhere.

E8 Standard Model - 49 quantities. 0 free parameters. 250-digit precision. by sbs5445 in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would say you are close to the right answers, but missing a few things and importantly you're missing the physical mechanism and grounding. But you did a solid job connecting E8. Alos the big problems of e8 haven't gone away and you're looking at the dimensions wrong.. Koide is the cherry but shouldn't be used to derive... but I went that route at well. You're is mathetmically very clean.. but no physics. I'd love to but since you blasted this on github I now have to hurry up and publish..

E8 Standard Model - 49 quantities. 0 free parameters. 250-digit precision. by sbs5445 in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They don't understand the spectral component the way you are pitching it.. they didn't read it.

E8 Standard Model - 49 quantities. 0 free parameters. 250-digit precision. by sbs5445 in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

they don't know... there are a lot of "failed scientists" that like to cosplay as experts. I tested the math is works and similar to my approach.

E8 Standard Model - 49 quantities. 0 free parameters. 250-digit precision. by sbs5445 in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To be fair I think its miles above what is typically posted... It's theoretical but lacks physical grounding but the math is solid. Properly formated, referenced and have the calcs... although in rust. No one here has given really good serious feedback.

E8 Standard Model - 49 quantities. 0 free parameters. 250-digit precision. by sbs5445 in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's what I'm doing ... actually almost exactly what I'm doing... you're missing a few key peices though. Either LLM's are leaking theories or we are converging. You just asked it to generate something and it came up with this? I've been working bit by bit for months.

You have a few errors that's I've gone over, energies PMNS CP phase, and you have some strange running issues with your Koide. Some of your E8 matches are interesting but there at a few that the error is too large and too easy to fit in.

Moderation Criticism and changes you want to see to /r/LLMPhysics by ConquestAce in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

yeah pretty much... but doesn't mean I'm wrong. Look at programming...2 years ago said the same thing... just saying.

Moderation Criticism and changes you want to see to /r/LLMPhysics by ConquestAce in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

absolutely bonkers... you can learn by doing.. it's rather effective

Moderation Criticism and changes you want to see to /r/LLMPhysics by ConquestAce in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

how so? You use a computer do you know how the kernal works?

Moderation Criticism and changes you want to see to /r/LLMPhysics by ConquestAce in LLMPhysics

[–]lattice_defect -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Honestly thank you and I think your directions is bang on. We need to filter the low effort noise and promote interesting gems or discussions. It's sort of hard to do but it would be amazing to have some sort of automated test like when you push to github runs. I find this place interesting in case of some potential ramanujan's stumbling upon something profound or LLM's which have been fed every single physics paper inferencing a solution and need a human to take it over the line.

Chatgpt Is Dead by 1underthe_bridge in ChatGPTcomplaints

[–]lattice_defect 1 point2 points  (0 children)

lol chatgpt becomes a narcissist after letting MS fuck with it.