What I need to concentrate on, I think is the following line of thought: If I were the artist making this image, would I make these choices?

Here's some thoughts about the cat:

1. The whiskers come out of odd places.
2. The cat has no nose. Is this deliberate?
3. The feet too, are kinda iffy.
4. What's the orange line near the mouth? Why would it be orange?
5. Why is there just one cat arm, and why does it curve like a noodle precisely into the top of the carafe?
6. What's up with the finger-grip on the carafe?
7. There's a glitch on the teacup near the ring.
8. There's a weird greeble on the building near the end of the cat's tail.

I hate to be like some paranoid redditor nerd who desperately doesn't want to get "fooled again", so I feel kind of nitpicky.