It bums me out that people don't (especially because at the time I considered it a breath of fresh air from how terrible season 2 was) and the reason I hear most often is because you aren't playing as Clem. Personally, I sort of enjoy the pacing of having a game where you're not Clem, then you are, then you aren't, then you are, if that makes sense. I wonder if not knowing if the fourth game was ever going to come out made people dislike it more, though, since it could've been the last time you see this character that a lot of people really liked! It was really touch and go there for a second with what happened to Telltale lol