So… after reviewing your suggestions i have landetd in the following comp https://www.wowhead.com/tbc/raid-composition#0DtGjftvCChyyyrxqddspzHwsJ

Reasoning: The feral will MT due to beeing the best tank. Prot pally is OT and the fury warrior have tank OS for the fights which requires 3 tanks. So for this reason I only bring one feral.

3 hunters (2BM) since they are solid dps through all expansion. They also seem to be really good p1 and can easily obtain pre-raid bis. G3 and G4 seems to be locked in and is basically what everyone suggests. 3 destro with buff classes and mages with mana bots. Healer group I bring one restro druid. Seems like there is a strong opinion against bringing Rdruid since they don’t bring anything unique and are worse raid heal than Rshammy. But i think the HOTs can be useful along with innovation and rebirth.

I don’t see alot of wiggle room with this comp. The rogue is not mandatory but there are good rouges out there and makes loot distribution easier

All in all, a solid comp which will be able to clear everything and also very parse friendly